Hartlett vs Martin vs Ziebell vs Shuey

Which 1 of these players will be the best? Hartlett vs Martin vs Ziebell vs Shuey


  • Total voters
    697
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

Hartlett had 15 disposals and a behind. Am I missing something here?
Hartlett was very good can't believe he only had 15 touches tbh.
Ironically the worst game of the lot was probably martin despite the fact he had close to 30 disposals. Just goes to show disposals can mean crap all.
Ziebell only had the 12 possessions but was very influential in the clinches.
 
Only 15 disposals but what he did with it, his pressure acts, leadership and courage were all first class. Hartlett finally is living up to his potential and playing consistent footy week in week out
 
Was Hartlett okay after the game? Think he pulled up a bit tight or sore late in the last quarter didn't he?

Shame about Matty White, poor bloke can't catch a break come finals time :(
 
Was Hartlett okay after the game? Think he pulled up a bit tight or sore late in the last quarter didn't he?

Shame about Matty White, poor bloke can't catch a break come finals time :(
Yeah just cramps, looked like he tore a hamstring or something, thankfully not the case.
 
He's doing it when it counts something Martin is yet to prove
To be fair to Martin, he didn't play badly a week ago in an absolute belting and he's only had the one chance this year.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Martin will be the best. Closely followed by Hartlett. Ziebell could be a gun mid/fwd weapon for North on day and Shuey will continue to be a very good midfielder. All will be stars if injury doesn't stop them
 
He's doing it when it counts something Martin is yet to prove

Pretty harsh on Martin - he's stood up at times this year kicking important clutch goals for the team when the game was on the line (see vs Carlton, Adelaide and Sydney).

If you're talking purely finals footy, Dusty's only played 2 games (both losing efforts) so again, a bit premature to say he doesn't do enough.

Martin:
2013 - EF vs Carlton (19 disposals, 1 goal) fairly quiet admittedly but probably can be excused given it was his first final in front of 95k.
2014 - EF vs Port (29 disposals) one of the few who could take anything from the game as we got flogged.

Hartlett:
2013 - EF vs Collingwood (21 disposals).
2013 - SF vs Geelong (19 disposals, 1 goal).
2014 - EF vs Richmond (15 disposals).
2014 - SF vs Freo (33 disposals).

Take away Hartlett's game against Freo on the weekend, and on paper, doesn't look like there is much there to suggest he's a big finals player just yet (admittedly, all players in this poll are still young and should 'hopefully' get plenty more of finals games in future).
 
Take away Hartlett's game against Freo on the weekend, and on paper, doesn't look like there is much there to suggest he's a big finals player just yet (admittedly, all players in this poll are still young and should 'hopefully' get plenty more of finals games in future).
You can't take away one from four games though and especially when it is the biggest final they have played.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top