Hurley, Pears and Ryder Vs Goldstein, Hansen and Grima

[TeamHurley]

Which Trio is better?

 

[schimma2snake]

There's little between Hurley and Hansen, Grima and Pears are an odd match considering the age difference and it is questionable if Ryder is even a number one ruckman.

I'm happy to stick with the North trio.

 

[Slattery_20]

Hard because Pears has been out so much recently while the others have been playing.
This year Hurley and Ryder have looked like they've stepped up a notch thus far.
Grima & Hansen weren't all that impressive on the w/e in a rough game (didn't see the WCE game); Goldstein held his own & battled pretty well.

On current form, Hurley & Ryder are in front of the rest. Where the others rank is a bit hard to say, definitely up for argument. I will say North's young talls looked at least as good as their older ones (Firrito, Petrie, Edwards) on the w/e.

 

[DapperDon]

There's little between Hurley and Hansen, Grima and Pears are an odd match considering the age difference and it is questionable if Ryder is even a number one ruckman.

I'm happy to stick with the North trio.

I love Big Footy.
Hurley has shown more in his 2 seasons that Hansen has shown in 5 (seems to be going backwards at an astounding rate).

Age means nothing when comparing talent, and Pears has it all over Grima

Not questionable at all, Essendon have 2 number 1 ruckman. That's what makes them such a dangerous duo, but if we compared Ryder to Goldstein, Ryder is ahead. Quite comfortably.

Stick with the North trio, I'm happy with that

 

[schimma2snake]

This isn't a contest. Grow up.

 

[WN123]

This isn't a contest. Grow up.

I thougts thats exactly what a poll was.

 

[HyperAgressiveDonk]

The Essendon trio. Not much of a contest really.

 

[lamaros]

There's little between Hurley and Hansen.

Ahhhh.. BigFooty! Never lets you down.

 

[TeamHurley]

Yeh I thought the same myself but Kings Army seems to think that the north trio are better

 

[Jade]

Essendon trio.

No contest

/thread.

 

[The OBSTacle]

1) Hurley is a better kick than Hansen, but Hansen is a better overhead mark and has a bigger tank. Not much in that.

2) Pears is promising, but Grima is currently the better player. Pears will probably end up passing Grima.

3) Goldstein, hands down.


North.

 

[NAUGHT5]

1) Hurley is a better kick than Hansen, but Hansen is a better overhead mark and has a bigger tank. Not much in that.

The better player >> bigger tank and mark.
You can point to every attribute in the book, but Hurley is still the better player.
The Essendon trio, comfortably IMO.

 

[Ambrosia]

1) Hurley is a better kick than Hansen, but Hansen is a better overhead mark and has a bigger tank. Not much in that.

2) Pears is promising, but Grima is currently the better player. Pears will probably end up passing Grima.

3) Goldstein, hands down.


North.

Ryder is a better at kicking, marking, tackling and arguably rucking.

Goldstien may go past him in the future but he isnt close now.

 

[BrownPearHookers]

Hurley, Ryder, Pears and Hooker
vs
Walker, Tippett, Davis and Otten

This would be a good contest.

North strength is else where.

 

[jonoman89]

Not even a contest....

....North.

And by North i mean Essendon. In a canter.

 

[Tippaz]

TeamHurley is obsessed with Hurley

 

[The OBSTacle]

It's amazing the impact that 2 games can have on people.

This is why I firmly believe that 95% of bigfooty posters opinions are worthless.

 

[lards]

Would pick all 3 Essendon players before any of the North ones. Wasn't Hansen one of the spuds Boomer was having a go at? Grima is average and Ryder is much better than Goldy.

 

[SA HAWK]

Bombers trio is a fair bit better imo.

 

[The Nostradamus]

if we were judging right now
ryder>goldy
grima>pears
hurley>hansen

essendon trio win 2-1, but i wouldnt be surprised to see goldy go past ryder, revisit this poll in 3 years time

 

[WN123]

if we were judging right now
ryder>goldy
grima>pears
hurley>hansen

essendon trio win 2-1, but i wouldnt be surprised to see goldy go past ryder, revisit this poll in 3 years time

Why would Goldstein go past Ryder. They are the same age. (3 months apart)

 

[Ambrosia]

Why would Goldstein go past Ryder. They are the same age. (3 months apart)

Cept that ryder has about 80 games of experience on Goldstien

 

[Kings Army]

Yeh I thought the same myself but Kings Army seems to think that the north trio are better

Wow you have hit a new low here. Find 1 post of mine where I rate the 3 Roos players against the 3 Essendon. Stupid poll. What the poll should have been was:

Gumby V Hansen - 2 and 3 in the same draft
Grima V Hooker - late draft picks in the same draft
Goldstein V Bellchambers - 21 and 22 year old ruckmen.

In that case the Roos easily.

Why not poll the midfields?

 

[TeamHurley]

?

Well look who finally decided to show up and eat humble pie.

Name the North melbourne players who play in the same position and are better than them. Has nothing to do with where they were drafted

 

[WN123]

Cept that ryder has about 80 games of experience on Goldstien

58.... Yeah saw that, but Ryder played his first few seasons in a completely different role.