Jack Ziebell vs Dustin Martin

[Squibbs]

Thought this might be an interesting one.

Any mention of Dustin Martin and his chopsticks, I may burst into tears. Fire away.

 

[The Dice Man]

Reckon Martin should add some chopsticks to his tattoo collection... Very very visible for the new season.

 

[ManOfClay]

Both could be better than they are but Martin is a lot more polished.

 

[M Malice]

ziebells best i think is better but he does not produce it often enough so martin for me.

 

[Chrizzt]

Not the player from OP's team

 

[Squibbs]

Not the player from OP's team

Good one. I wanted to see people's actual opinions.

 

[gym4life]

There already is a poll like this. It is also so one sided this is pointless. A better comparison would be shuey vs Martin.

 

[Oraaaaazio]

There already is a poll like this. It is also so one sided this is pointless. A better comparison would be shuey vs Martin.

Hahaha what the *? The same thread you're referencing has Shuey in it as well as Dusty & JZ and Ziebell is in fact ahead of Shuey in that very poll. Wouldn't that make a thread of Shuey vs Martin even more pointless than this one?

 

[KillaKanga]

There already is a poll like this. It is also so one sided this is pointless. A better comparison would be shuey vs Martin.

I hate polls that don't have players from my team #endrant #drieseyes

 

[gym4life]

Hahaha what the ****? The same thread you're referencing has Shuey in it as well as Dusty & JZ and Ziebell is in fact ahead of Shuey in that very poll. Wouldn't that make a thread of Shuey vs Martin even more pointless than this one?

That thread is dating back to 2012. The recent thread between shuey and ziebell shuey absolutely pantsed ziebell meaning this would be a lot closer with shuey instead of ziebell.

 

[gym4life]

I hate polls that don't have players from my team #endrant #drieseyes

Just trying to make it less embarrassing for Jack. He's on quite a losing streak.

 

[Oraaaaazio]

That thread is dating back to 2012. The recent thread between shuey and ziebell shuey absolutely pantsed ziebell meaning this would be a lot closer with shuey instead of ziebell.

Well, if that's the case and you think that the poll is outdated and no longer relevant, how can you ridicule OP for creating this poll when that one exists? Maybe they thought the same way as you do about it's relevance.

 

[gym4life]

Well, if that's the case and you think that the poll is outdated and no longer relevant, how can you ridicule OP for creating this poll when that one exists? Maybe they thought the same way as you do about it's relevance.

Because this isn't close at all. Even the most one sided north supporters would vote Martin.

 

[Oraaaaazio]

Because this isn't close at all. Even the most one sided north supporters would vote Martin.

Doesn't explain why you used that other thread as a reference..... and 2 people voted for Ziebell so you're completely wrong there. Martin > Shuey but that's for another thread, which you can start if you like.

 

[gym4life]

Doesn't explain why you used that other thread as a reference..... and 2 people voted for Ziebell so you're completely wrong there. Martin > Shuey but that's for another thread, which you can start if you like.

Those two people are taking the piss. Martin may > shuey but it is a hell of a lot tighter than this thread.

 

[Squibbs]

There already is a poll like this. It is also so one sided this is pointless. A better comparison would be shuey vs Martin.

Make a Shuey vs Martin poll then?

 

[War Machine]

Ziebell (no bias)

Cunnington > ziebell > Nahas > dustbin

 

[naturally north]

Ziebell (no bias)

Cunnington > ziebell > Nahas > dustbin

Yeah look Nahas has taken his game to a level since coming to North that would have him captain of the Tigers. Not suggesting Nahas would take up such an offer though.

I think Dusty is slightly better, but not by much. But not knowing am sure we gave up some early draft picks to get Nahas across?

 

[Wargreymon90]

martin. ziebel is no where near as good

 

[Hipster Doofus]

Martin, every club would want him on the hff or in the guts over Ziebell.
Ziebell is a gun though

 

[The Dice Man]

CHOPSTICKS!!!

 

[Etsi ketsi]

I like Ziebell but at best he is just a good ordinary player.Not in Dusty's class

 

[Dazb86]

Martin. Ziebell needs to build a tank if he wants to become a great player.

 

[Heaps of fun]

Martin. Ziebell needs to build a tank if he wants to become a great player.

If he hasn't done it by now what chance can he do it though?

 

[DaVillaBlues]

Ziebell is seriously underrated by many here it seems, really should be North's captain.