Jake Carlisle

Remove this Banner Ad

Yep, it will be good to looking to trade for him in 2017.

He'll be looking for a new club after his 2 year suspension ends

;)
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Majak Daw kicked 6 against the Dogs, while looking just as clueless as Carlisle against any other team. And with him we don't even have to worry about 2 year bans :D DAW2HAWKS2015!!!! Who's with me???

Steven Tyler said:
Who'd he play on, Jordan Roughead? :rolleyes:
Click to expand...
Yes actually
 
Gold Member said:
Is he a massive tool or is it the s**t tatts in the Neo Nazi font?
Click to expand...


No way, he's not a massive tool.
He's an Essendon player.

So he's just a gigantic tool.
 
Schoenmakers2Puopolo said:
Majak Daw kicked 6 against the Dogs, while looking just as clueless as Carlisle against any other team. And with him we don't even have to worry about 2 year bans :D DAW2HAWKS2015!!!! Who's with me???


Yes actually
Click to expand...
I haven't seen an update in the last couple of weeks, but isn't a 2-yr sporting ban kinda the least of Daw's worries right now?
 
The previous Carlisle thread....most supporters thought he was an ordinary player, goes to show how foggy our brown and gold glasses currently are.
Other than his "maybe" impending ban...he would slot into our side without a shadow of doubt and is superior to Shoey in almost all facets as a KP player.
 
dipper86 said:
The previous Carlisle thread....most supporters thought he was an ordinary player, goes to show how foggy our brown and gold glasses currently are.
Other than his "maybe" impending ban...he would slot into our side without a shadow of doubt and is superior to Shoey in almost all facets as a KP player.
Click to expand...
I'm not so sure he does. Runs in straight lines only forward or back which is why he struggled on Buddy. He is very poor forward - Shoey show much more in a handful of games.
 
Brishawk said:
I'm not so sure he does. Runs in straight lines only forward or back which is why he struggled on Buddy. He is very poor forward - Shoey show much more in a handful of games.
Click to expand...

You have got be kidding me.....Buddy makes a mockery of most defenders, last year he played far too loosely on Buddy .

Really watching yesterday and the weeks before I saw some great movement. He reads the play a hell of a lot better and most of all he's a contested pack marking forward/backman.
 
Close the thread, his asking price has gone from 450k to 700k overnight. Pass.
 
Give me Longer and Carlisle please.....Bookmark this and we will review the Longer quote as well if required. (will be a star)
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Just because he plays for Essendon, doesn't mean we can't give credit when its due. And for Carlisle it is definitely due.

He is a quality player ( I think better defender than forward, but whatever...)

Has a great pair of hands, I don't care who he is playing against, when a player can clunk marks all day like he does, you know he has something good about him.

Would fit into our defense nicely when Lake has had enough
 
dipper86 said:
You have got be kidding me.....Buddy makes a mockery of most defenders, last year he played far too loosely on Buddy .

Really watching yesterday and the weeks before I saw some great movement. He reads the play a hell of a lot better and most of all he's a contested pack marking forward/backman.
Click to expand...
If he is so great why isn't he playing as a defender? He really hasn't done much of anything as a forward.
 
We'll see how Carlisle goes when he's got a decent defender on him. I'll reserve judgement on him until then.

Some of those efforts from the Bulldogs yesterday were horrendous, and the week before he had such household names to compete with as Langdon and Frost.

He's taken apart two pitiful defenses.

Now...Robbo is saying he's the best player in the game currently.

LOL
 
Echols said:
We'll see how Carlisle goes when he's got a decent defender on him. I'll reserve judgement on him until then.

Some of those efforts from the Bulldogs yesterday were horrendous, and the week before he had such household names to compete with as Langdon and Frost.

He's taken apart two pitiful defenses.

Now...Robbo is saying he's the best player in the game currently.

LOL
Click to expand...
The Bulldogs concede a lot of goals to key forwards every week. Form against them is worthless.
 
Carlisle would be useless playing for Hawthorn. He's a stick and our midfield continually bomb the ball long and deep because the KPF's aren't allowed to lead past the 30m mark thus requiring them to be pack markers. He's not built for that.
 
Brishawk said:
If he is so great why isn't he playing as a defender? He really hasn't done much of anything as a forward.
Click to expand...
Have you seen there forward line.....that's why. He's there best forward and best backman.
He's had a very good 3 week period...going into a position that's foreign to him, massive learning period for him.
 
savagelunchbox said:
Carlisle would be useless playing for Hawthorn. He's a stick and our midfield continually bomb the ball long and deep because the KPF's aren't allowed to lead past the 30m mark thus requiring them to be pack markers. He's not built for that.
Click to expand...

He's hardly a stick and one of his his strengths is his pack marking.
 
dipper86 said:
He's hardly a stick and one of his his strengths is his pack marking.
Click to expand...

I only hope Tim O'Brien was watching the way Carlisle went about it on the weekend....He has almost the exact same mechanics as Carlisle & needs to attack the ball with the same ferocity/commitment....Carlisle is certainly one of the form players in the comp at the minute. He is the same age as Gunston. I know which one of those 2 I'd rather have!:)
 
At the start of this drug saga Robbo dragged every essendon person through the mud and then nailed the players identities in the paper. Robbo after copping a hiding from the media and essendon hierarchy for printing the players identities has spent the past 2 months sucking up every essendon person including Bomber Thompson on his 360 show.
 
200cm swingmen with any ability do not grow on trees, I would have him at the Hawks. We have a history of developing players with flaws into gems.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top