Keiran Jack's throw on McDonald

[Handsome.B.Wonderful]

Surprised there's not already a thread on this. Threw McDonald into people sitting on the bench, totally unnecessary. If Walker's suspension is anything to go by, and this looks worse, he will miss the Grand Final.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/video?v=swans-could-miss-jack_1227065637278&vc=208

 

[shintemaster]

Based on Walker's he would go. Really stupid act to be honest.

 

[pazza]

Wasn't just the bench..it was the emergency umpires!

Gone.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Doesn't deserve to miss a grand final for it.. but certainly deserves a reprimand with carry over points..

 

[Sydney Bloods]

no chance, McDonald was a dirty campaigner who kicked him the guts, merely a return argy bargy.

worse case a reprimand, no carry over points he plays.

keep hating muppetts.

 

[Cynic]

Dog act but not worth a week. If he had points he'd be worried though.

 

[Cynic]

Surprised there's not already a thread on this. Threw McDonald into people sitting on the bench, totally unnecessary. If Walker's suspension is anything to go by, and this looks worse, he will miss the Grand Final.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/video?v=swans-could-miss-jack_1227065637278&vc=208

The comparison to Walker's is more than valid though and if so I can he escape one week? Guess the argument will be below the required force.

 

[MightyHawks]

There is no chance that the MRP will start charging Swans players this week...

The MRPs hand this year was shown by the Goodes and Buddy incidents

 

[Unknown Identity]

no chance, McDonald was a dirty campaigner who kicked him the guts, merely a return argy bargy.

worse case a reprimand, no carry over points he plays.

keep hating muppetts.

In no way do i hate Keiran Jack or Sydney. My Pa was a South Melbourne supporter so have always had a soft spot for the Swans.

Simple fact of the matter, regardless of him retaliating, it was extremely dangerous and unsportsmanlike. Once the Ball crosses the boundary line that's it. No Tackling, bumping etc.. You want to square up for something you do it on the field at the right moment. Doesn't deserve to miss a Grand Final for it, but the precedent has certainly been set with Andrew Walker earlier in the season (not that the MRP has consistency). Should receive carry over points but Play in the big dance.

 

[Sydney Bloods]

In no way do i hate Keiran Jack or Sydney. My Pa was a South Melbourne supporter so have always had a soft spot for the Swans.

Simple fact of the matter, regardless of him retaliating, it was extremely dangerous and unsportsmanlike. Once the Ball crosses the boundary line that's it. No Tackling, bumping etc.. You want to square up for something you do it on the field at the right moment. Doesn't deserve to miss a Grand Final for it, but the precedent has certainly been set with Andrew Walker earlier in the season (not that the MRP has consistency). Should receive carry over points but Play in the big dance.

so exactly what i said, with extra drama. its not worthy of suspension. Worst case a reprimand, he has no carry over points and isn't going to miss because of it.

Meanwhile another ******* sniper get's away with dirty s**t and nobody mentions it because its a vic side against the evil swans empire.

and you all think we're the protected bunch.

 

[Ry009]

Don't care whether he misses or not but a weak effort that his teamates should have come in and dropped him where he stood.

 

[Arwib]

Does he have carryovers or an existing record? Would think without those the lowest grade rough conduct charge and a reprimand.

 

[Unknown Identity]

so exactly what i said, with extra drama. its not worthy of suspension. Worst case a reprimand, he has no carry over points and isn't going to miss because of it.

Meanwhile another ******* sniper get's away with dirty s**t and nobody mentions it because its a vic side against the evil swans empire.

and you all think we're the protected bunch.

Get your back up as much as you like mate..
There's no hate, no interstate rivalry here..
I can't comment on the McDonald incident as i can't recall it.
Good Luck on Saturday..

 

[Sydney Bloods]

Does he have carryovers or an existing record? Would think without those the lowest grade rough conduct charge and a reprimand.

no carry over points, if its judged like walker he's free to play.

 

[Upgrayedd]

Needs to be told he's a ****ing idiot and maybe longmire slapping him in the back of the head, I dont think it warrants a suspension.

One of those "Should of been a free" in game situations

 

[V_23]

Not going to miss the Grand Final for it but it was completely stupid and dangerous.

 

[Kummerspeck]

Only incident on Jack's history is from the NAB cup in 2008. One week, early plea / 5 year good record, reprimand.

 

[J_Moore]

Wasn't just the bench..it was the emergency umpires!

Gone.

Nah.

 

[Theprofessional]

Needs to be told he's a ****ing idiot and maybe longmire slapping him in the back of the head, I dont think it warrants a suspension.

One of those "Should of been a free" in game situations

Was a free.

 

[Unknown Identity]

$1800 fine..
Strange decision, would this usually result in a fine?

 

[Slax]

$1800 fine..
Strange decision, would this usually result in a fine?

It's a really funny decission, but for this type of incident it is something that I think is more deserving of a fine for a first offence, do it a second time and you get points.

 

[Clint Bizkit]

Based on Walker's he would go. Really stupid act to be honest.

It was no different to Walker's, amazing that he is free to play.

 

[mic59]

If a bump in play can be deemed to be dangerous and worthy of a suspension then throwing a player at officials in an area where there is assorted equipment must be deemed reckless. Jack is lucky McDonald didn't hit say a camera or there is no way he could escape 225 points downgraded with an early plea and good record to 126. As it is he may get nothing or 125 points downgraded to 70.3 carryover points.

 

[jacko57]

no chance, McDonald was a dirty campaigner who kicked him the guts, merely a return argy bargy.

worse case a reprimand, no carry over points he plays.

keep hating muppetts.

If true, surely the MRP would look at it......or else BF would be full of demands for action?

 

[KissKiss]

I dont think he should miss a gf for it.

But thinking about it, how different is this type of incident from a sling tackle? Its a similar action but off the ball/not in play? There is a greater potential for injury with the fence/people/equipment.

Would be a difficult sort of thing to adjudicate on