Keiran Jack's throw on McDonald

[BloomingHawk]

If the MRP used "precedents", Walker & Jack = 1 week.

All the MRP's precedents are contradictory...

 

[Hoops]

Andrew Walker Round 1 = 225 points


Kieran Jack Prelim Final = $1800 fine


Can anyone see a difference?

What about Harvey slamming Selwood into the fence didn't even get a free, but did eventually

 

[Maddo11]

If the MRP used "precedents", Walker & Jack = 1 week.

Just to clarify this, the MRP can use previous offenses to determine what penalty an offense should get when charging players.

It's just they're so very very bad at it, or only have the memory of a goldfish.

Or it's a massive conspiracy.