Hang on, I didn't realise Brett wanted to keep coaching, he did a great job getting them where they were this year and you'd think the committee would have stuck with him. Anyone know why they decided to look elsewhere?
Lodden Valley Football League Part 2
- Thread starter blown budget
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Hang on, I didn't realise Brett wanted to keep coaching, he did a great job getting them where they were this year and you'd think the committee would have stuck with him. Anyone know why they decided to look elsewhere?
sometimes there is 1 or 2 people in a club that want to change things and they think they can get the results they need straight away, sometimes that don't work, i think brett should of been given the chance again, to improve his list again, and yes ycw have to finish 3rd or it was the wrong move.
Prowler
Rookie
- Feb 5, 2009
- 26
- 0
While I admit I dont know the circumstances in this particular case, I think you will find that most decisions regarding coaches are voted on by the committee and not just 1 or 2 people.sometimes there is 1 or 2 people in a club that want to change things and they think they can get the results they need straight away, sometimes that don't work, i think brett should of been given the chance again, to improve his list again, and yes ycw have to finish 3rd or it was the wrong move.
Wildcard
Debutant
From my understanding - and likewise I don't know all the details - the interviews for the position were conducted by an "independent" panel and they provided a recommendation to the committee who accepted the recommendation. As for who the panel consisted of and how their independence was determined, I'm sure there are people who know but I am not one of them.
Hard decisions needed to be made at YC to go to the next level. Finishing 1st is the only option in 2011 as it is every year. Keep in mind that prior to Calivil having their long run YC played in every Grand Final from 1996-2002. They know how to build dynasties and the bloke in charge now was heavily involved in the last one.
The Big Arab
Senior List
As a playing coach initially in 1996 and I agree. If Truth doesnt " build a dynasty" he will have failed. Also YCW constitution says coaches have to reapply each year for their position so a bad year this year and will the " independent committee" sack him, as the existing committee doesnt seem to have the nuts to make a decision.
The committee voted in has to make their own decision and live by them. I know what I would have done in the same position and it would have been reappoint Fitzpatrick. I reckon he has been right royally shafted after coming to the rescue 18 months ago. Does loyalty count for nothing?
I see some of you noted scrib's have phil the truth walsh potted already saying he will have to get some square player's on board this year.Well i think it's been 3or4 years since phill was at square and wouldn't jim angrove be in a much better postion as he played there in the 2s this year and is coaching Marong .You then say if he dose'nt finish top 3 he is gone where are bridgy/calival/ and py hill going and i suppose Miti will just step aside as well.Did you ever wonder why there were 13 new coaching postions in our area this year MAYBE IT'S A TOUGH GIG and untill you have stuck your own hand up standing on the outside and leaning on the rail is your place to be. No matter what happens in 2011 someone will win the flag and someone the wooden spoon this is something that will never change no matter who coaches who.
barfoldbob
Debutant
pretty sure we saw the Truth in the square group when we played em
dont know if in an official capacity but also spotted Truth with the square inner sanctm at finals time, 2
dont know if in an official capacity but also spotted Truth with the square inner sanctm at finals time, 2
Umpire Please
Rookie
Phil has been hangin around square for years, the players all know who he is, so if he is chasing players im sure he wont have any trouble getting a hold of them.
TheKITC
Cancelled
Just to clear it up, Phil Walsh was chairman of selectors at Golden Square.
Why would they not like cam carter i heard that calival had been chaseing him for 4yrs is this another committee decision that the player's don't like.Just like the Tank Lummis move neck em 1 third of the way though the year oh well nothing like stabilty in a club.
Musn't want to put the hard yards in over pre season that im sure Cam is planning.
If the club out there want a coach who leads by example on the training track and on the field they have got a good man
Carter mite be not a bad player but he speaks like a *, how on earth he got another coaching gig i'll go hee.
Looks like Filo spending up big again, Holdstock is a quality player but he wouldnt be travelling out there for less than 7-800 a game i can assure you.
Hasn't got a bad coaching record though Ablett. Lets his actions do his talking for him. I'd much prefer to play under a bloke who gets out and gets the hard work done out on the ground each time then a bloke who is only good with his mouth
Hit the post
Senior List
Staying at lalbert are u roota
TheKITC
Cancelled
I'm about to go over and post something similar in the HDFL thread, but Calivil aren't the only club with players strongly linked to the very same club... White Hills.
Richardson and Rogers are the names at this stage, with one or two others potentially.
Mitiamo and BL-Serpentine also have players being courted.
Miti - Two key positions, one back one forward.
Serp - On-ballers.
Not prepared to confirm names at this stage as I'm mates with most of them, but Chapman is one of the Miti players (s**t bloke so I'll air his laundry).
edit: I'm not saying these player are signed and delivered, it's only October after all. Just players strongly linked.
Richardson and Rogers are the names at this stage, with one or two others potentially.
Mitiamo and BL-Serpentine also have players being courted.
Miti - Two key positions, one back one forward.
Serp - On-ballers.
Not prepared to confirm names at this stage as I'm mates with most of them, but Chapman is one of the Miti players (s**t bloke so I'll air his laundry
).edit: I'm not saying these player are signed and delivered, it's only October after all. Just players strongly linked.
I'm about to go over and post something similar in the HDFL thread, but Calivil aren't the only club with players strongly linked to the very same club... White Hills.
Richardson and Rogers are the names at this stage, with one or two others potentially.
Mitiamo and BL-Serpentine also have players being courted.
Miti - Two key positions, one back one forward.
Serp - On-ballers.
Not prepared to confirm names at this stage as I'm mates with most of them, but Chapman is one of the Miti players (s**t bloke so I'll air his laundry
edit: I'm not saying these player are signed and delivered, it's only October after all. Just players strongly linked.
THE LIST going to W/H posted on CVF today
GAVIN BOWLES ( SOUTH BENDIGO) ASSISTANT COACH, BROCK ROGERS ( CALIVIL UNITED), JOEL WHYBIRD (MITIAMO), SAM KERR ( NEWSTEAD), ETHAN FORD (NEWSTEAD), ROHAN BOWLES (SOUTH BENDIGO), RYAN MCNISH (KANGAROO FLAT), MATT LEHANE (KANGAROO FLAT) JUSTIN WILLIAMS (BRIDGEWATER).
Will be interesting to see how the loddon valley boys do in the HDFL. Not sure if they will win a flag getting upto 7 players (the 3 signed plus KITC's mates and the shittest bloke in the LVFL) from what is considered a weaker league plus a couple from MDFL which many would consider weaker again. Good luck to all the boys and hope they represent the LVFL well when they go across but think W/H wont top Heathcote, LBU, Elmore or North Bendigo with whats listed.
Who is coaching at White Hills?
Special Comments
Draftee
Jason Stevens, think he was a k flat man for a while??? Dont quote me on that one.
TheKITC
Cancelled
Jason 'Jugga' Stevens.
Coached Flat 18's for ages after being a revelation in the same post ast Castlemaine. Did recruiting and assistant coaching at Flat then moved on to be senior assistant at White Hills this year. Is now obviously the head honcho there.
- Status
