Mike Sheahan end of season top 50 2014

[Watson_my_mind]

1) Joel Selwood
2) Nathan Fyfe
3) Lance Franklin
4) Robbie Gray
5) Gary Ablett
6) Josh Kennedy
7) Jordan Lewis
8) Jarryd Roughead
9) Dyson Heppell
10) Travis Boak
11) Scott Pendlebury
12) Eric Mackenzie
13) Luke Hodge
14) Luke Parker
15) Matt Priddis
16) Aaron Sandilands
17) Sam Mitchell
18) Shaun Burgoyne
19) Rory Sloane
20) Tom Rockliff
21) Luke Breust
22) Shane Mumford
23) Patrick Dangerfield
24) Callan Ward
25) Pearce Hanley
26) Nick Malceski
27) Bryce Gibbs
28) Daniel Talia
29) Cale Hooker
30) Matthew Broadbent
31) Nick Riewoldt
32) Alex Rance
33) Dayne Beams
34) Dustin Martin
35) Tom Hawkins
36) David Mundy
37) Brodie Smith
38) Grant Birchall
39) Nick Smith
40) Brendon Goddard
41) Trent Cotchin
42) Tom Liberatore
43) Nathan Jones
44) Ben Cunnington
45) David Swallow
46) Brent Harvey
47) Sam Jacobs
48) Hayden Ballantyne
49) Nick Dal Santo
50) Robert Murphy

Why Mike, why. In my opinion, Murphy shouldn't be in the list, where is Brandon Ellis, Jack Gunston, Dion Prestia, Jay Schulz, Eddie Betts, Josh Kennedy amongst others.

Why is Broadbent so high. Why is Tom Hawkins so low. Brent Harvey had a better year than Luke Hodge. Gap between Sandilands and Jacobs is too large.

 

[MinerBoy]

First to criticize.

Franklin should be #1

 

[Rustin Cohle]

Pure trash, as per usual.

 

[Firebat]

Hard to please everyone.

Ablett is still no.1
Then all of North

Then Fyfe Selwood etc.

 

[Watson_my_mind]

First to criticize.

Franklin should be #1

 

[Magma]

it reads like the first 15 is okay, if not a few to be rearranged, and then he just throws random names in after.

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Broadbent at 30 is an eyebrow raiser. Good player, but wouldn't be top 100 let alone 30.

 

[longsuffreosupp]

Matt Priddis 15. List must've been made in the last week.

 

[TyHawk]

People gotta stop shoving Selwood as the best, cuz he ain't Top Ten and Gunston isn't important apparently.what the .....

 

[MinerBoy]

What if I told you Broadbent made this list over Jack Gunston

I'd say "Mike's Mad"............and did

 

[Hollow Knight]

Rockliff and Hanley top 25. I endorse this.

 

[DonDynamite]

Broadbent huh. Here I was thinking I probably overrate some of my side's players, turns out I severely underrate them.

 

[MC Extra Dollop]

Selwood?!

Holy s**t, Mike...I'm not even going to try to justify that one.

 

[Firebat]

Rockliff and Hanley top 25. I endorse this.

Course you do.

Hanley top 25 is a joke.

Good fun player, but top 25? Lawl.

 

[Hollow Knight]

You'll catch on.

 

[Augustine]

I feel like Mike got to around 40 and went s**t I forgot North Melbourne.

Oh well, who cares. I actually like Mike but not his top 50s. Pretty sure Rockliff wasn't in his predicted top 50 at the start of the year from memory.

 

[The_Reaper]

At least Mackenzie is rated correctly as West Coast's best.

Still not good enough for AA though

 

[jwint43]

sam mitchell, trent cotchin too low, cale hooker too high

 

[Toffee Lion]

3 Players in the top 50 is nice for us, even if it's Mike Sheahan.

 

[base615]

Where's Tony Armstrong? The bloke played 8 quarters in 1 day FFS.

 

[Watson_my_mind]

3 Players in the top 50 is nice for us, even if it's Mike Sheahan.

I see what you did there.

 

[Jaeger]

People need to stop caring about this.

 

[Squibbs]

Did he put every players' name in the competition into a hat, close his eyes and start picking out players?

 

[_Christoh_]

Wait...I must be tripping, I thought I just saw Broadbent in that list.

 

[Engimal]

Our best player is 44th in the AFL? Yeeah, nah. Also, if Sandilands is 16th, Jacobs isn't 47th.