Competition NAFL Reserves 2014/15 Hub Thread

[Fizzler]

So what are people's thoughts on which finals system to go with? I'd like to have it sorted out sooner rather than later.

Also, this is completely hypothetical, but for next season how would people feel about being able to change their designs once during the season, just for the reserves? You probably couldn't do any drastic changes to your design, but just little clean ups (not too different from the Heavy Weight Champs, but maybe a bit stricter). My reasoning is that the Reserves is made up of a lot of beginners and inexperienced designers, and in a lot of ways is about improvement. In both seasons that it's run there have been comments like "why did I do it like that?" "I could do that so much better now" etc. etc. only a few weeks in. There'd be a week or two, mid season, when people could re-enter their designs, although if I was running it, I'd be a bit tight on how different the overall design could be. Thoughts?

You should go with what TGDesigns came up with. By the way I like this changing up thing. I would have used it this season.

 

[rabbitoh21]

so only a change in the template is fair? to be fair a change in template, no matter what would result in a change in design, because a different template would be a different size, so the sash or whatever may be thicker/ bigger to fit the template, so if only changing the template is what it were to end up as, then i'd vote no for this because it's virtually impossible not to change the design a little bit because of it.

it's either template/ minor design/ both or nothing

Obviously minor tweaks wouldn't be a change in design. But going from a yoke to a V, or a sash to stripes, that's a different story IMHO

 

[NM_Mitchell]

i never said that should be allowed, i only suggested changing thicknesses and cleaning up the design and/ or changing the template

 

[Dylan8]

I think there will be people who won't bother changing stuff who may be disadvantaged. Perhaps post-comp, voluntarily, people can tweak or even vitally change stuff to show their progress and or how they would have done things differently.

 

[Jack Stevens]

Good debate, guys, and I'm finding myself agreeing a lot with both sides.

Keep in mind this would happen well into the season, so if anyone entered deliberately lazy jumpers at the start, they'd probably lose every game for the first half of the season and dig themselves into a ditch.

I'd also encourage teams like Greensborough Golds, who are already killing it, not to update their jumpers.

Other teams getting a disadvantage is also a big problem.

 

[Jack Stevens]

Round 19 http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/nafl-reserves-2014-15-round-19.1085213/

 

[Gibbsy]

I don't mind the updating of templates/presentation but any design change post-round 1 is a no from me.

 

[Jack Stevens]

There's now a poll in this thread for the finals. Vote early, vote often.

 

[Jack Stevens]

Round 20 http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/nafl-reserves-2014-15-round-20.1085414/

 

[Jack Stevens]

Round 21 http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/nafl-reserves-2014-15-round-21.1085648/

 

[Jack Stevens]

With only 3 rounds to go, its now mathematically impossible for any team to enter or exit the top 6. The NAFL Reserves Commission congratulates the teams who have qualified for the 2015 NAFL Reserves Finals Series, and wishes good luck in future seasons for those who have not.

 

[rabbitoh21]

With only 3 rounds to go, its now mathematically impossible for any team to enter or exit the top 6. The NAFL Reserves Commission congratulates the teams who have qualified for the 2015 NAFL Reserves Finals Series, and wishes good luck in future seasons for those who have not.

#howaytheexiles

 

[Jack Stevens]

The poll will now close on Saturday arvo. I'd rather have a more conclusive margin than the one vote that we have now, though, so get voting!

 

[Gibbsy]

The poll will now close on Saturday arvo. I'd rather have a more conclusive margin than the one vote that we have now, though, so get voting!

100% more conclusive now

 

[El_Scorcho]

I voted for the winning bid just to make it more conclusive

 

[Jack Stevens]

Care to share your idea, Dylan8?

 

[Dylan8]

yes scrap the finals and do a rematch of last season's GF instead since you probably cheated

ill see you at survivor series 2001

WINNER TAKES ALL


(im vince mcmahon and you're that noob shane mcmahon)

Spoiler

vince wins

 

[Jack Stevens]

So we'll fix a fix by using a sport that is based around fixes?

Sounds good, we'll go with that one.

 

[El_Scorcho]

If this happens, would it be possible for me to drop from the rafters at the death wearing Dylan8's guernsey, only to knock him out cold with a chair the second he turns his back, before taking my guernsey off to reveal St Mark's design and dragging St Mark's unconscious body on to Dylan for the pin and then wake up the ref for the 3 count?

 

[Dylan8]

If this happens, would it be possible for me to drop from the rafters at the death wearing Dylan8's guernsey, only to knock him out cold with a chair the second he turns his back, before taking my guernsey off to reveal St Mark's design and dragging St Mark's unconscious body on to Dylan for the pin and then wake up the ref for the 3 count?

I'm afraid not, since I have dibsed being Vince, and thus I am the CEO and Chairman of the whole deal.

 

[El_Scorcho]

What if I'm Diamond Dallas Page and I make it a Diamond Cutter instead of a chair shot?

 

[Dylan8]

It's a deal but only if you swap and roles of St Mark and myself so he's the heel and I'm the face.

 

[Dylan8]

Nobody ever liked Shane McMahon anyway

 

[El_Scorcho]

Agreed

 

[El_Scorcho]

But!

I'm now a heel as well and I'm screwing you over to a chorus of boos and spraypainting "El Scorcho" on you after the pinfall.

Yyeesssssssssss