List Mgmt. Operation "Get Scharenberg"

[mattymac]

Do you think Geelong are overrating Dangerfield?
I do... I've got news for them.. With or without him they wont play finals for at least 2 years..
I think the whole this is so disrespectful to Selwood, Enright, S.J and Bartel who are all much more decorated

They definitely seem to think he's the messiah. For me it was always that ridiculously good back line that defined Geelong's success and that's what they're losing. Danger won't change that.

 

[Freddy Bassett]

They definitely seem to think he's the messiah. For me it was always that ridiculously good back line that defined Geelong's success and that's what they're losing. Danger won't change that.

How many years have we played finals with the messiah?
Not saying I don't want to keep him and I am not saying he isn't our best player but if they think he will turn them into flag contenders they are seriously deluded

 

[Legz]

How many years have we played finals with the messiah?
Not saying I don't want to keep him and I am not saying he isn't our best player but if they think he will turn them into flag contenders they are seriously deluded

Only need to look at Ablett at GC as another prime example.
1 elite player doesn't guarantee success.

 

[Golumless]

Do you think Geelong are overrating Dangerfield?
I do... I've got news for them.. With or without him they wont play finals for at least 2 years..
I think the whole this is so disrespectful to Selwood, Enright, S.J and Bartel who are all much more decorated

There is a very Carlton to Judd feel to this chase.

 

[mattymac]

There is a very Carlton to Judd feel to this chase.

Yep, seems more about marketing than football. Give the fans something to cling to in an otherwise pretty barren time on the horizon

 

[Pugsley]

True but with CEY, Grigg, knight & the rat?

Scharenberg plays a different position.

 

[Damp Squarie]

Kerridge to Brisbane for Aish

GTFO...cant we trade Wright instead...Kerridge has proven he is a match winner, Wright hasn't

 

[Pugsley]

GTFO...cant we trade Wright instead...Kerridge has proven he is a match winner, Wright hasn't

We'll always have Norf.

 

[Freddy Bassett]

Only need to look at Ablett at GC as another prime example.
1 elite player doesn't guarantee success.

With all due respect to Danger, you cant compare the two. Ablett at the Cats won flags, Brownlows, B&F's.. Elite disposal... Continued team success

 

[Legz]

With all due respect to Danger, you cant compare the two. Ablett at the Cats won flags, Brownlows, B&F's.. Elite disposal... Continued team success

Sorry wasn't trying to compare them.
Was merely trying to add to the argument that Danger alone won't rocket Geelong back up the ladder.

 

[baldandbroke]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-09-17/young-pie-staying-put-scharenberg-inks-new-deal

 

[Pugsley]

Operation glad Scharenberg ?

 

[Cleric]

Its a pitty we didnt get him. Would be a way better get than M Talia and Hampton are.
He is quality, captain material.

 

[Mattrox]

Its a pitty we didnt get him. Would be a way better get than M Talia and Hampton are.
He is quality, captain material.

Lever is our future captain material.

Sharenburg would have been nice, but Hampton is a dire need.

 

[CrowCro]

GTFO...cant we trade Wright instead...Kerridge has proven he is a match winner, Wright hasn't

Kerridge is vb part 2. If he was any good he'd be playing. Doesn't read the game well and is awful in traffic. Kicked a few goals up forward with the ball going over the back

 

[Damp Squarie]

Fair point.
There are some players that need to be cut though...perhaps they should both go.
Lets face it,Wright is never gonna be a Callaghan

 

[EVILCROW]

Bad news for Matt with a 2nd ACL but as a Crows supporter, glad we didn't get him now!

 

[Elder van Berlo]

Bullet dodged.

 

[Pugsley]

Is the a warning from the footy gods to stay away from drafting players that have suffered knee injuries ?

 

[LiquidCrow]

Feel for the kid. Heard it was his good knee, too.

 

[baldandbroke]

Is the a warning from the footy gods to stay away from drafting players that have suffered knee injuries ?

What, like Lever?

 

[Pugsley]

What, like Lever?

I was alluding to Burton but Lever is a fulcrum that was never in doubt

 

[baldandbroke]

I was alluding to Burton but Lever is a fulcrum that was never in doubt

Yeah I know - just saying that there is no rule ... could add Menzel to that list?

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

That sucks

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Damn Shame ......no other words for the lad