Paul Seedsman vs Shaun Atley

[Shaneprice97]

Both talented back flanker wingman who love to get the ball and run. Both were picked up in the 2010 draft, one at #17 and the other at #76, who do you think is better at this stage?

 

[Wayne Arnold]

This poll seems to be limited to 100%. Think you should contact the mods.

 

[KillaKanga]

For 2014 or career?

Atley for both anyway, just curious

 

[HBFlanker]

This is surely not a genuine poll??

 

[thetradesman]

Surely not a poll, Seedsman by far.

 

[HBFlanker]

Surely not a poll, Seedsman by far.

lol

 

[thetradesman]

North supporters at it again!

 

[the big lebowski]

Good poll. Both players have a lot in common.

I know Seedsman had an injury interrupted start to the year. Atley on the other hand is having his best season to date, after a somewhat disappointing season last year.

Both are very good kicks and speedy. I know Atley is top five for running bounces this year. Obviously Seedsman is well down as he has only played 6 games, but his average bounces is almost double Atley's!!!!

That said, i think Atley is the better defensive player of the two.

Great poll for the future, as one pure speed, run and carry and precise kicking of half back, they are two of the best youngsters in the comp.

 

[Rainfall]

Had to vote for Seedsman because who is Atley?

 

[Donakebab]

Had to vote for Seedsman because who is Atley?

The next Chris Judd...

 

[Rainfall]

The next Chris Judd...

Dont make me laugh

 

[Barnzy]

This is surely not a genuine poll??

Why not?

Similar types. Seedsman for mine. Atley is more hype than substance.

 

[HBFlanker]

Someone ask Adrian Dodoro his opinion of Atley

 

[KillaKanga]

Had to vote for Seedsman because who is Atley?

23 disposals last year when we beat your mob.

27 last Friday in a win over the Hawks.

Averaging more disposals than Seedsman, not saying he's clearly better than Seedsman because he's not but to ask who he is, is either insulting or maybe just a reflection of your knowledge.

 

[HBFlanker]

Anyone that says "who is Atley" clearly has no knowledge of football and shouldnt be posting in a football forum.

 

[Heaps of fun]

Seedsman seems like the smarter footballer to me with Atley more physically gifted; stronger and faster. Not much between them.
Just noticed Seedsman's weight on collingwoodfc.com.au. He's put on 15kg in the three and a half years since being drafted? Seems incorrect.

 

[the big lebowski]

Why not?

Similar types. Seedsman for mine. Atley is more hype than substance.

How so? He is hyped as being a line breaker. He has had the 5th most bounces in the AFL this year.

Hype = Substance it would seem.

 

[carnthedons]

Interesting poll. Both set things up from halfback, Atley's obviously quicker, Lezzo has better disposal. I'd take the Seed at this stage but it's close. If Atley translates into a line-breaking midfielder at some point, then I'd probably lean his way.

 

[Collingwoodity]

Why not?

Similar types. Seedsman for mine. Atley is more hype than substance.

A young North player? Well I never...

 

[Adam H]

A young North player? Well I never...

Yeah you just don't hear of a hyped up young player at Collingwood.......

 

[Collingwoodity]

Yeah you just don't hear of a hyped up young player at Collingwood.......

Yeah. We do. From you. Calling them s**t.

 

[Rainfall]

23 disposals last year when we beat your mob.

27 last Friday in a win over the Hawks.

Averaging more disposals than Seedsman, not saying he's clearly better than Seedsman because he's not but to ask who he is, is either insulting or maybe just a reflection of your knowledge.

Might have something to do with when I think of North I think of Petrie, Goldy, Hansen, Wells, Swallow, Bastinac, Thomas, and Boomer that's about it
When 10 years ago I only thought off Sinclair, Archer and Rocca

 

[the big lebowski]

Atley's obviously quicker, Lezzo has better disposal.

Is he? And does he?

I thought Seedsman was as quick. And Atley is a beautiful kick.

 

[pieman123]

Is he? And does he?

I thought Seedsman was as quick. And Atley is a beautiful kick.

Seedsman is definately a better kick

 

[the big lebowski]

Seedsman is definately a better kick

2% better disposal efficiency this year for Seedsman this year. 3% better for Atley last year.

Are you sure you haven't been sucked into the Atley can't kick crap that some morons sprout?