- Nov 30, 2006
- 4,580
- 5,454
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Is there any other teams?
FWIW Abbott pic and bio removed from Collingwood website in the rookie list section.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
DislikeFWIW Abbott pic and bio removed from Collingwood website in the rookie list section.
I agree with babylove's repsonse to you but would add:But do traded in picks count as "their next pick" or was that specific to those they had prior to the trade period? I mean if they've traded out their original early picks (even if they've replaced them with others) how can they be counted towards point calculations? Isn't that why most of these clubs traded out their early picks to other clubs?
GWS will most likely use pick 10 for academy matching...so doesn't affect our pick.Then if they have to use their pick 10 then that's not a case where our pick 27 will slide out. In fact, if clubs with academy players are forced to use their early picks then we could potentially move up the order rather than slide out.
GWS will most likely use pick 10 for academy matching...so doesn't affect our pick.
Brisbane will not use pick 2 for academy matching, their next pick is 38, so if other clubs bid (before our pick 27) then Brisbane will use their later picks to match & effectively jump ahead of our selection, pushing us back 1 pick.
Sydney have picks 33, 36 & 37 which they will use for matching, so they will also match an early bid & push us back 1 pick.
GoldCoast have picks 6, 16 & 29. Most likely use pick 6 as a live pick, then use pick 16 & 29 for matching?
Nobody knows exactly (a) which club will bid for academy/FS players & which pick they bid (b) which Bids will be matched.
So the precise impact on our selection 27 is an unknown at this moment.
The below phantom draft, has us sliding to pick 31.
Brett Anderson's Phantom Draft.
1. Carlton - Jacob Weitering
2. Brisbane - Josh Schache
3. Sydney - Callum Mills
4. Melbourne - Charlie Curnow
5. GWS - Jacob Hopper
6. Essendon - Darcy Parish
7. Essendon - Sam Weideman
8. Gold Coast - Clayton Oliver
9. GWS - Matthew Kennedy
10. Melbourne - Kieran Collins
11. Carlton - Harry McKay
12. Brisbane - Eric Hipwood
13. Adelaide - Wayne Milera
14. Carlton - Aaron Francis
15. Richmond - Callum Ah Chee
16. Adelaide - Ben McKay
17. St.Kilda - Rhys Mathieson
18. Hawthorn - Riley Bonner
19. Brisbane - Ben Keays
20. Gold Coast - Ryan Clarke
21. North Melbourne - Mitchell Hibberd
22. Hawthorn - Daniel Rioli
23. Carlton - Jade Gresham
24. W/Bulldogs - Darcy Tucker
25. W/Bulldogs - Braden Fiorini
26. Fremantle - Harley Balic
27. West Coast - Aidyn Johnson
28. Essendon - Tom Cole
29. Essendon - Ryan Burton
30. North Melbourne - Mason Redman
31. Collingwood - Alex Morgan
32. North Melbourne - Ben Crocker
33. Gold Coast - Luke Partington
34. St.Kilda - Bailey Rice
35. W/Bulldogs - Josh Dunkley
36. West Coast - Greg Clark
37. GWS - Harris Himmelberg
38. Port Adelaide - Brandon White
39. Fremantle - Jesse Glass-McCasker
40. Melbourne - James Parsons
41. North Melbourne - Will Snelling
42. Hawthorn - David Cuningham
43. Port Adelaide - Jack Cornell
44. Melbourne - PASS
45. GWS - Matt Flynn
46. W/Bulldogs - Callum Moore
47. Richmond - Blake Hardwick
48. Sydney - Mitch Brown
49. Gold Coast - Kurt Mutimer
50. Essendon - Declan Mountford
51. Carlton - Jack Silvagni
52. Carlton - PASS
53. Fremantle - Josh Schoenfeld
54. West Coast - Tyrone Leonardis
55. Collingwood - Reuben William
56. Geelong - Sam Skinner
57. St.Kilda - Liam Hulett
58. Sydney - Daniel Houston
59. Adelaide - PASS
60. Sydney - PASS
61. North Melbourne - PASS
62. Fremantle - PASS
63. West Coast - PASS
64. Hawthorn - PASS
65. Collingwood - Jack Firns
66. Brisbane - Corey Wagner
67. Gold Caost - Michael Hartley
68. Essendon - PASS
69. St.Kilda - PASS
70. Collingwood - PASS
71. Geelong - Tom Doedee
72. Port Adelaide - Nick Coughlan
73. W/Bulldogs - PASS
74. Richmond - Mitch King
75. Brisbane - PASS
76. Gold Coast - PASS
77. Geelong - Yestin Eades
78. Port Adelaide - PASS
79. Richmond - PASS
80. Geelong - Hugh Haysman
Academy and Father Son Bids.
- Melbourne bids Pick 3 for Callum Mills, Sydney Matches the bid by giving up Picks 34, 37, 38 and 45.
- Essendon bids Pick 5 for Jacob Hopper, GWS match the bid by giving up Picks 12 and 35.
- Melbourne bids Pick 9 for Matthew Kennedy, GWS match the bid by giving up Picks 41, 50, 52, 55 and 60.
- Adelaide bids Pick 12 for Eric Hipwood, Brisbane match the bid by giving up Picks 39, 39 and 40.
- Gold Coast bids Pick 19 for Ben Keays, Brisbane match the bid by giving up Picks 41 and 42.
- W/Bulldogs bids Pick 34 for Bailey Rice, St.Kilda matches the bid by giving up Pick 38.
- Port Adelaide bids Pick 37 for Harrison Himmelberg, GWS match the bid by giving up Picks 54 and 55.
- Port Adelaide bids Pick 43 for Jack Cornell, GWS Chooses not to match the bid.
- Collingwood bids Pick 55 for Reuben William, Brisbane chooses not to match.
Because the Academy clubs will use their late picks (stockpiled) to match bids for their academy players.Why do we have Pick 31? We have Pick 27
GWS will most likely use pick 10 for academy matching...so doesn't affect our pick.
Brisbane will not use pick 2 for academy matching, their next pick is 38, so if other clubs bid (before our pick 27) then Brisbane will use their later picks to match & effectively jump ahead of our selection, pushing us back 1 pick.
Sydney have picks 33, 36 & 37 which they will use for matching, so they will also match an early bid & push us back 1 or 2 picks.
GoldCoast have picks 6, 16 & 29. Most likely use pick 6 as a live pick, then use pick 16 & 29 for matching?
Nobody knows exactly (a) which club will bid for academy/FS players & which pick they bid (b) which Bids will be matched.
So the precise impact on our selection 27 is an unknown at this moment.
The below phantom draft, has us sliding to pick 31.
Brett Anderson's Phantom Draft.
1. Carlton - Jacob Weitering
2. Brisbane - Josh Schache
3. Sydney - Callum Mills
4. Melbourne - Charlie Curnow
5. GWS - Jacob Hopper
6. Essendon - Darcy Parish
7. Essendon - Sam Weideman
8. Gold Coast - Clayton Oliver
9. GWS - Matthew Kennedy
10. Melbourne - Kieran Collins
11. Carlton - Harry McKay
12. Brisbane - Eric Hipwood
13. Adelaide - Wayne Milera
14. Carlton - Aaron Francis
15. Richmond - Callum Ah Chee
16. Adelaide - Ben McKay
17. St.Kilda - Rhys Mathieson
18. Hawthorn - Riley Bonner
19. Brisbane - Ben Keays
20. Gold Coast - Ryan Clarke
21. North Melbourne - Mitchell Hibberd
22. Hawthorn - Daniel Rioli
23. Carlton - Jade Gresham
24. W/Bulldogs - Darcy Tucker
25. W/Bulldogs - Braden Fiorini
26. Fremantle - Harley Balic
27. West Coast - Aidyn Johnson
28. Essendon - Tom Cole
29. Essendon - Ryan Burton
30. North Melbourne - Mason Redman
31. Collingwood - Alex Morgan
32. North Melbourne - Ben Crocker
33. Gold Coast - Luke Partington
34. St.Kilda - Bailey Rice
35. W/Bulldogs - Josh Dunkley
36. West Coast - Greg Clark
37. GWS - Harris Himmelberg
38. Port Adelaide - Brandon White
39. Fremantle - Jesse Glass-McCasker
40. Melbourne - James Parsons
41. North Melbourne - Will Snelling
42. Hawthorn - David Cuningham
43. Port Adelaide - Jack Cornell
44. Melbourne - PASS
45. GWS - Matt Flynn
46. W/Bulldogs - Callum Moore
47. Richmond - Blake Hardwick
48. Sydney - Mitch Brown
49. Gold Coast - Kurt Mutimer
50. Essendon - Declan Mountford
51. Carlton - Jack Silvagni
52. Carlton - PASS
53. Fremantle - Josh Schoenfeld
54. West Coast - Tyrone Leonardis
55. Collingwood - Reuben William
56. Geelong - Sam Skinner
57. St.Kilda - Liam Hulett
58. Sydney - Daniel Houston
59. Adelaide - PASS
60. Sydney - PASS
61. North Melbourne - PASS
62. Fremantle - PASS
63. West Coast - PASS
64. Hawthorn - PASS
65. Collingwood - Jack Firns
66. Brisbane - Corey Wagner
67. Gold Caost - Michael Hartley
68. Essendon - PASS
69. St.Kilda - PASS
70. Collingwood - PASS
71. Geelong - Tom Doedee
72. Port Adelaide - Nick Coughlan
73. W/Bulldogs - PASS
74. Richmond - Mitch King
75. Brisbane - PASS
76. Gold Coast - PASS
77. Geelong - Yestin Eades
78. Port Adelaide - PASS
79. Richmond - PASS
80. Geelong - Hugh Haysman
Academy and Father Son Bids.
- Melbourne bids Pick 3 for Callum Mills, Sydney Matches the bid by giving up Picks 34, 37, 38 and 45.
- Essendon bids Pick 5 for Jacob Hopper, GWS match the bid by giving up Picks 12 and 35.
- Melbourne bids Pick 9 for Matthew Kennedy, GWS match the bid by giving up Picks 41, 50, 52, 55 and 60.
- Adelaide bids Pick 12 for Eric Hipwood, Brisbane match the bid by giving up Picks 39, 39 and 40.
- Gold Coast bids Pick 19 for Ben Keays, Brisbane match the bid by giving up Picks 41 and 42.
- W/Bulldogs bids Pick 34 for Bailey Rice, St.Kilda matches the bid by giving up Pick 38.
- Port Adelaide bids Pick 37 for Harrison Himmelberg, GWS match the bid by giving up Picks 54 and 55.
- Port Adelaide bids Pick 43 for Jack Cornell, GWS Chooses not to match the bid.
- Collingwood bids Pick 55 for Reuben William, Brisbane chooses not to match.
I don't know enough about the draftees to comment on their prospects, Knightmare would know more.Must admit I know nothing about the 3 players he has got us selecting so will have to check them out. Morgan is very pacey isn't he?
What I did notice was that he has Ryan Burton getting awfully close to our first pick. Two more spots please! Has his stocks fallen that much?
Mason Redmond and Aidyn Johnson aren't far away from us too and have been talked up as possible selections.
Declan Mountford was also spoken about to be of interest to us (by Scout on EB&W) and he is taken by Essendon just before our 2nd pick. If he gets to our 2nd we might pounce on the back of testing really well at the combine.
He hasn't got the Frost upgrade either at 70 which was probably an oversight.
I don't know enough about the draftees to comment on their prospects, Knightmare would know more.
Hine may use 3 live picks (27, 66 & 77), hence the upgrade for Frost may be pick 83.
The 66 & 77 picks will come forward to mid to late 50's picks (with academy clubs spending their picks on academy players & some other clubs commencing to pass in the 50-60's range.
The plan does seem as you've stated.
The plan is use those first three picks and upgrade Frost. With the option to take a fourth (against the odds) if we see someone we want to senior list, that we may not see being available come the rookie draft.
Regarding those players mentioned.
Alex Morgan is an overager. Has played very little through injury. Production has been mild at best. But he has AFL qualities with his pace and ability to take on the game as well as come composure with ball in hand as someone who can avoid tackles and dance with ball in hand as well as use it reasonably. Given his mild production I'm not so excited, particularly when talking about our first selection.
Burton is a productive tall leadup forward but has failed but I'm struggling to see what he can do at AFL level as not tall enough to be a key forward, or really have the style of game to be compatible as a key forward. Then doesn't have the midfield ability. So even forgetting injuries I'm not as keen on him as others seem to be. Capable as he is overhead, and reliable ball user as he is.
Mason Redman is a nice tall fwd/mid. Improved over the course of the season and has shown signs without dominating in any one area of the game. He is more a developing tall utility but for me probably at this point lacks a definite point of difference to be overly excited about.
Aidyn Johnson has pace and can take on the game. Has missed most of this season with injury. But production has only been mild when he has played.
Mountford is a productive mid who can play a bit outside a bit inside. Doesn't have a major point of difference and is more a high work rate type.
Thanks Knightmare you don't sound very excited by those listed there at all. If you were to take off your unbiased hat and put on your Pies supporter hat who do you really want for us at 27?
Of those realistic options. And 50/50 to be there but Luke Partington for me is the pick at 27. High level accumulator but has very good pace and skills and offers good scoreboard impact. Good inside/outside balance. And not sub 180cm. He relatively the guy I'd be most excited to hear us read out on draft day at the 11th rated talent on my draft board (one position ahead of Darcy Parish).
Kerbatieh not listed above?
Sam Weideman!Thanks Knightmare you don't sound very excited by those listed there at all. If you were to take off your unbiased hat and put on your Pies supporter hat who do you really want for us at 27?
Eddie can talkSam Weideman!
If Eddie can't rig the draft, what use is he?
Sorry KM, I meant from Brett Anderson's Phantom draft.I was going off the names from the above quote. Kerbatieh is a goal first, goal second, think about doing something else 3rd type small forward. Has a long kick, quick but poor endurance and you can tell he has a real ego about the way he plays - which can be a good and bad thing.
Kerbatieh not listed above?
Sorry KM, I meant from Brett Anderson's Phantom draft.
From your description, sounds like Kerbatieh is similar to a younger Fas
GWS will most likely use pick 10 for academy matching...so doesn't affect our pick.
Brisbane will not use pick 2 for academy matching, their next pick is 38, so if other clubs bid (before our pick 27) then Brisbane will use their later picks to match & effectively jump ahead of our selection, pushing us back 1 pick.
Sydney have picks 33, 36 & 37 which they will use for matching, so they will also match an early bid & push us back 1 or 2 picks.
GoldCoast have picks 6, 16 & 29. Most likely use pick 6 as a live pick, then use pick 16 & 29 for matching?
Nobody knows exactly (a) which club will bid for academy/FS players & which pick they bid (b) which Bids will be matched.
So the precise impact on our selection 27 is an unknown at this moment.
The below phantom draft, has us sliding to pick 31.
Brett Anderson's Phantom Draft.
1. Carlton - Jacob Weitering
2. Brisbane - Josh Schache
3. Sydney - Callum Mills
4. Melbourne - Charlie Curnow
5. GWS - Jacob Hopper
6. Essendon - Darcy Parish
7. Essendon - Sam Weideman
8. Gold Coast - Clayton Oliver
9. GWS - Matthew Kennedy
10. Melbourne - Kieran Collins
11. Carlton - Harry McKay
12. Brisbane - Eric Hipwood
13. Adelaide - Wayne Milera
14. Carlton - Aaron Francis
15. Richmond - Callum Ah Chee
16. Adelaide - Ben McKay
17. St.Kilda - Rhys Mathieson
18. Hawthorn - Riley Bonner
19. Brisbane - Ben Keays
20. Gold Coast - Ryan Clarke
21. North Melbourne - Mitchell Hibberd
22. Hawthorn - Daniel Rioli
23. Carlton - Jade Gresham
24. W/Bulldogs - Darcy Tucker
25. W/Bulldogs - Braden Fiorini
26. Fremantle - Harley Balic
27. West Coast - Aidyn Johnson
28. Essendon - Tom Cole
29. Essendon - Ryan Burton
30. North Melbourne - Mason Redman
31. Collingwood - Alex Morgan
32. North Melbourne - Ben Crocker
33. Gold Coast - Luke Partington
34. St.Kilda - Bailey Rice
35. W/Bulldogs - Josh Dunkley
36. West Coast - Greg Clark
37. GWS - Harris Himmelberg
38. Port Adelaide - Brandon White
39. Fremantle - Jesse Glass-McCasker
40. Melbourne - James Parsons
41. North Melbourne - Will Snelling
42. Hawthorn - David Cuningham
43. Port Adelaide - Jack Cornell
44. Melbourne - PASS
45. GWS - Matt Flynn
46. W/Bulldogs - Callum Moore
47. Richmond - Blake Hardwick
48. Sydney - Mitch Brown
49. Gold Coast - Kurt Mutimer
50. Essendon - Declan Mountford
51. Carlton - Jack Silvagni
52. Carlton - PASS
53. Fremantle - Josh Schoenfeld
54. West Coast - Tyrone Leonardis
55. Collingwood - Reuben William
56. Geelong - Sam Skinner
57. St.Kilda - Liam Hulett
58. Sydney - Daniel Houston
59. Adelaide - PASS
60. Sydney - PASS
61. North Melbourne - PASS
62. Fremantle - PASS
63. West Coast - PASS
64. Hawthorn - PASS
65. Collingwood - Jack Firns
66. Brisbane - Corey Wagner
67. Gold Caost - Michael Hartley
68. Essendon - PASS
69. St.Kilda - PASS
70. Collingwood - PASS
71. Geelong - Tom Doedee
72. Port Adelaide - Nick Coughlan
73. W/Bulldogs - PASS
74. Richmond - Mitch King
75. Brisbane - PASS
76. Gold Coast - PASS
77. Geelong - Yestin Eades
78. Port Adelaide - PASS
79. Richmond - PASS
80. Geelong - Hugh Haysman
Academy and Father Son Bids.
- Melbourne bids Pick 3 for Callum Mills, Sydney Matches the bid by giving up Picks 34, 37, 38 and 45.
- Essendon bids Pick 5 for Jacob Hopper, GWS match the bid by giving up Picks 12 and 35.
- Melbourne bids Pick 9 for Matthew Kennedy, GWS match the bid by giving up Picks 41, 50, 52, 55 and 60.
- Adelaide bids Pick 12 for Eric Hipwood, Brisbane match the bid by giving up Picks 39, 39 and 40.
- Gold Coast bids Pick 19 for Ben Keays, Brisbane match the bid by giving up Picks 41 and 42.
- W/Bulldogs bids Pick 34 for Bailey Rice, St.Kilda matches the bid by giving up Pick 38.
- Port Adelaide bids Pick 37 for Harrison Himmelberg, GWS match the bid by giving up Picks 54 and 55.
- Port Adelaide bids Pick 43 for Jack Cornell, GWS Chooses not to match the bid.
- Collingwood bids Pick 55 for Reuben William, Brisbane chooses not to match.
Poor guy, doesn't matter what he says or how he acts...Mad Dog Morgan would be a great pick up for us.