Player X vs Y

Status
Not open for further replies.

keithrichards

Premiership Player
Dec 11, 2008
3,299
4,000
Shepparton
AFL Club
Melbourne
Current have a midfield of:

Selwood, Rockliff, Pendlebury, Cotchin, Liberatore, Kennedy, Fyfe, Beames (Shenton, Acres)

Have 2 trades left to get rid of Fyfe and Beames, and I can afford any player I want - which is the best way to go? I'm presuming I will win the prelims that i am in this week, as I'll have 22 on the field and my opponents will have 20 or less.

Initially thinking Sloane and Priddis, but wondering others thoughts on Watson, Lewis, Murphy, Sidebottom....

Any thoughts/reasoning would be great!
 
Jul 2, 2008
2,292
1,126
Brisbane
AFL Club
Geelong
1. Sloane - reliable
2. MMurphy - good form and a track record
3. Greene - insane form but I wouldn't trust him. Depends on the size of your aggots.

Watson V Sidebottom?

Sidebottom. Watson faded in the second half, still working back into match fitness so he's more of a risk. Sidey should do well against Giants
 

aflcliche

Club Legend
May 26, 2010
1,716
1,026
AFL Club
Carlton
Last 2 trades, for Beams and Fyfe -

Selwood & Priddis VS Rockliff & Sloane / Sidebottom / other ?

Basically if I get Rockliff I can afford all except Selwood and Priddis.
 

keithrichards

Premiership Player
Dec 11, 2008
3,299
4,000
Shepparton
AFL Club
Melbourne
Current have a midfield of:

Selwood, Rockliff, Pendlebury, Cotchin, Liberatore, Kennedy, Fyfe, Beames (Shenton, Acres)

Have 2 trades left to get rid of Fyfe and Beames, and I can afford any player I want - which is the best way to go? I'm presuming I will win the prelims that i am in this week, as I'll have 22 on the field and my opponents will have 20 or less.

Initially thinking Sloane and Priddis, but wondering others thoughts on Watson, Lewis, Murphy, Sidebottom....

Any thoughts/reasoning would be great!
Any advice toxic ? You seem to be the man in the know!
 
Any advice toxic ? You seem to be the man in the know!

Jobe v gold coast is appealing
Priddis will get you 110 -125
Sloane massive appeal
Cunnington is interesting. No boomer and dees final rd

Safe
Sloane and jobe
 
Jobe lacking match fitness (23 point second half last week) and no Heppell = tag.

Gold coast...wouldnt matter who tagged him imho.

Can see jobe getting 26+ possies and kicking a couple

Only downside is blue taggers iin final rd
 
Yeah I'm gonna go with Sloane. Sloane is just so consistent and he has a good record against North as well.

Now to decided VC/C. What are your thoughts on Robbie Gray as VC?

Leaning towards either VC Gray & C Sloane or VC Sloane & C Selwood/Buddy

I dont do Friday vc

Jelwood vc
Cockchin c

For me
 

keithrichards

Premiership Player
Dec 11, 2008
3,299
4,000
Shepparton
AFL Club
Melbourne
Jobe v gold coast is appealing
Priddis will get you 110 -125
Sloane massive appeal
Cunnington is interesting. No boomer and dees final rd

Safe
Sloane and jobe
thanks mate

Beames to Sloane is locked in

May see how my match ups are looking before pulling the trigger on Fyfe, and then decide tomorrow arvo if i should go to Priddis or Watson.
 
thanks mate

Beames to Sloane is locked in

May see how my match ups are looking before pulling the trigger on Fyfe, and then decide tomorrow arvo if i should go to Priddis or Watson.

Plan for both weeks is my only tip
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back