Rank the 10 greatest Eagles players of all-time

Remove this Banner Ad

Mine changes too - but here goes
1. Ben Cousins
2. Peter Matera
3. Dean Cox
4. D. Glass
5. G. Jakovich
6. C. Mainwaring
7. P. Sumich
8. D. Kerr
9. D. Kemp
10. G. McKenna

Woosha the most imfluential Eagle of all time - in the fullness of time, the B&F MUST be named after him (and the new stadium, or at least a stand, - if and when it ever eventuates.)
 
Think Kerr deserves more love in this thread. If he isn't top 10 he's definitely just outside.

SHOULD have won a brownlow if he wasn't competing with the 2 trophy boys in his team for votes. If only he had 1 more vote cousins AND him could of won.

Always going to be remembered for being a badass off field but you can't change the fact he at least tried to carry our handicapped team 07-10
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Im really not sure how any of you can seriously rate Judd outside the top 2.

He's the best player your club has every produced.
 
Blackswan said:
Im really not sure how any of you can seriously rate Judd outside the top 2.

He's the best player your club has every produced.
Click to expand...

Pretty simple, he pissed off to Carlton and only played 134 games for us. Being the most talented doesn't make you the best player a club has ever had. You have to factor in things other than brownlows and premierships (not that you would know anything about that) :rolleyes:
 
Because he is a dirty bald Judas, over rated by the entire AFL community, gets 40 seconds to dispose of the ball when tackled and likes pressure points? :confused:

Scenario - Judd has 4 posessions for the entire game, grimaces in pain and gets a handball out of traffic to nobody in particular
Commentary - "Chris Judd just trying to will his team over the line here, just willing himself into the contest......"

^ That being said, he's still a goes down as a club great. But he's not that player nowadays.
 
Dark Sharks said:
Because he is a dirty bald Judas, over rated by the entire AFL community, gets 40 seconds to dispose of the ball when tackled and likes pressure points? :confused:

Scenario - Judd has 4 posessions for the entire game, grimaces in pain and gets a handball out of traffic to nobody in particular
Commentary - "Chris Judd just trying to will his team over the line here, just willing himself into the contest......"

^ That being said, he's still a goes down as a club great. But he's not that player nowadays.
Click to expand...

Usually just chucks it out these days.

Top Ten.

Cousins
Judd
Jakovich
Matera
Cox
Kerr
McKenna
Kemp
Glass
Sumich.
 
JackJako27 said:
Pretty simple, he pissed off to Carlton and only played 134 games for us. Being the most talented doesn't make you the best player a club has ever had. You have to factor in things other than brownlows and premierships (not that you would know anything about that) :rolleyes:
Click to expand...

I would have thought that Brownlows, the first player at your club to ever receive one, premierships, a premiership largely bought in on the shoulders of the captain would be a pretty accurate measuring tool.

Not only is Judd the most talented player to ever pull on the blue and gold, he was one of the most consistent, the best finals player your club has ever produced and quite simply no one has played at Judd's level at West Coast.

He is without doubt one of the best to have ever played for West Coast, to say otherwise is quite stupid.
 
Blackswan said:
I would have thought that Brownlows, the first player at your club to ever receive one, premierships, a premiership largely bought in on the shoulders of the captain would be a pretty accurate measuring tool.

Not only is Judd the most talented player to ever pull on the blue and gold, he was one of the most consistent, the best finals player your club has ever produced and quite simply no one has played at Judd's level at West Coast.

He is without doubt one of the best to have ever played for West Coast, to say otherwise is quite stupid.
Click to expand...
That is why everybody has him in our top 10 players of all time!?!? In case you missed it, the club has been really successful and over 25 years has had other great players too.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

FiveStrings said:
Don't feed the troll
Click to expand...

Point out one thing I have said that is false.

Those not including him in their top ten or having him outside the top 3 players to have every played for West Coast are kidding themselves and most likely still bitter from his departure, which was as much the fault of the club as it was his decision.
 
Blackswan said:
Point out one thing I have said that is false.

Those not including him in their top ten or having him outside the top 3 players to have every played for West Coast are kidding themselves and most likely still bitter from his departure, which was as much the fault of the club as it was his decision.
Click to expand...

Thanks for your contribution, but as was the case with your last 23 aliases your presence on this board is not required
 
Juddernaut33 said:
P.Matera
Ph.Matera
Cousins
The Juddernaut
Jakovich
P.Symmons
Sumich
Cox
Mckenna
Kerr
Click to expand...
actually you could make a case for Phil Matera making the top 10- remember a year when he was pretty much our forward line, for a small forward his probably the smartest forward we have ever had.

think at best though he would be around 8-15 in our ranks.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

BeornJ
Resource Eagles Player Ratings 2024
Replies
10
Views
720
BeornJ
BeornJ
KERRPOW
  • Poll
List Mgmt. Should The Eagles Request A Priority Assistance Package at The End of This Year?
12 13 14 15 16
Replies
394
Views
15K
Jumpoff Joey
Jumpoff Joey
squashface
MVP BigFooty West Coast Eagles Player of the Year 2023 - Results Thread
5 6 7 8 9
Replies
209
Views
10K
squashface
squashface
Reminiscence
Preview Round 7 - Eagles vs Suns
Replies
0
Views
152
Reminiscence
Reminiscence
Keys
  • Locked
  • Sticky
Analysis The Alesana Player Video Reviews Links Thread
Replies
4
Views
978
Keys
Keys
Obeanie1
Prediction Eagles Team 2026
Replies
19
Views
2K
GoEaglesGoSGIO
GoEaglesGoSGIO
Mop
A Pointless AFL All Time Record
Replies
7
Views
470
ioppolo
ioppolo

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top