Revising the top ten of the 2012 afl draft.

[MightyDons4]

My order is based on if we were to redo the draft right now

1. Daniher
2. Wines
3. Whitfield
4. Macrae
5. Stringer
6. Grundy
7. Menzel
8. Gleeson
9. Thurlow
10. Viney

 

[Cringle]

1. Troy Menzel
2. Nick Graham

EDIT: Kristian Jaksch was also drafting gold.

 

[Sylvia Saint]

My order is based on if we were to redo the draft right now

1. Daniher
2. Wines
3. Whitfield
4. Macrae
5. Stringer
6. Grundy
7. Menzel
8. Gleeson
9. Thurlow
10. Viney

Stringer to #2, he's a way better prospect than Macrae IMO.

 

[Dogsman16]

My order

1. Stringer
2. Wines
3. Daniher
4. Whitfield
5. Grundy
6. Macrae
7. Thurlow
8. Viney
9. Mayes
10. Vlaustin

 

[CasuallyDressed]

My order

1. Stringer
2. Wines
3. Daniher
4. Whitfield
5. Grundy
6. Macrae
7. Thurlow
8. Dunstan
9. Mayes
10. Vlaustin

Viney next in line

Dunstan above Thurlow and Wines above Stringer and my list is basically the same.

 

[Chaisa]

Dunstan?

 

[Dogsman16]

Dunstan above Thurlow and Wines above Stringer and my list is basically the same.

Yeah bit of bias on my behalf with Stringer ahead of Wines. Wines certainly deserves number 1 spot, although Stringer has done the hard yards as a tall forward and has kicked 6 bags of four or more goals.

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Our recruiter rated him second in the draft when we got him
From my extensive viewing of him I can say i wholeheartedly agree - the kid is a freak talent.

All clubs say that about the players they get in the first round, they are hardly going to say, ohh we wanted Macrae or wines but we had to settle for menzel.

 

[living_in_syd]

isnt dunstan in the 2013 draft?

Hows o'rourke traveling - just one game for hawks? bust there for the gws but they have so many they dont care...

mcintosh and mcbean for us at 31/33 starting to maybe look okay for us now...

 

[Wargreymon90]

Yeah dunstan was not in this draft

 

[Wargreymon90]

1. Wines
2. Stringer
3. Mayes (stagnated a little, but still all class)
4. Whitfield
5. Grundy
6. Daniher
7. Macrae
8. Vlastuin
9. Viney
10. Menzel

 

[fronkalicious]

1. Wines
2. Stringer
3. Mayes (stagnated a little, but still all class)
4. Whitfield
5. Grundy
6. Daniher
7. Macrae
8. Vlastuin
9. Viney
10. Menzel

There's no way in hell Mayes would go top 3.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Wines, Macrae, Whitfield - top 3 mids in order
Daniher, Stringer top 2 forwards in order but Stringers versatility give him an edge.

1. Wines
2. Stringer
3. Daniher
4. Macrae
5. Whitfield


Sent from my SM-N910G using Tapatalk

 

[go you pups]

Wines, Macrae, Whitfield - top 3 mids in order
Daniher, Stringer top 2 forwards in order but Stringers versatility give him an edge.

1. Wines
2. Stringer
3. Daniher
4. Macrae
5. Whitfield


Sent from my SM-N910G using Tapatalk

When it comes to importance for their teams already as 3rd year players then your top 3 is spot on and you could throw Grundy into the mix also

 

[JordanStorm]

If they'd be given more games, reckon Ben Kennedy and Mason Wood would be up there

 

[PAFCsince1870]

On output Wines and Grundy 1 and 2 for me, with an honorable mention to Macrae.

Most of this draft are still just potential.

 

[fronkalicious]

On output Wines and Grundy 1 and 2 for me, with an honorable mention to Macrae.

Most of this draft are still just potential.

Stringers kicked 41 goals in his last 18 games. I'd call that output.

 

[Gumby2Hurley]

Wines, Lachie and Macrae are the stand out mids for me but i reckon Viney will become better than Macrae.
Dogs obviously wouldn't have wanted to lose ward but being able to nail both 5 and 6 is a big plus.
Pies also did well with picks 18-20.

1. Wines
2. Stringer
3. Daniher
4. Grundy
5. Whitfield
6. Macrae
7. Viney
8. Vlastuin
Unsure from here onwards Mayes/Menzel/Thurlow would fill the last 2 spots in no particular order.

Essendon drafted okay with Gleeson developing into a decent player but still inconsistent as well as Ashby looks to become a regular next year.

 

[fronkalicious]

Wines, Lachie and Macrae are the stand out mids for me but i reckon Viney will become better than Macrae.
Dogs obviously wouldn't have wanted to lose ward but being able to nail both 5 and 6 is a big plus.
Pies also did well with picks 18-20.

1. Wines
2. Stringer
3. Daniher
4. Grundy
5. Whitfield
6. Macrae
7. Viney
8. Vlastuin
Unsure from here onwards Mayes/Menzel/Thurlow would fill the last 2 spots in no particular order.

Essendon drafted okay with Gleeson developing into a decent player but still inconsistent as well as Ashby looks to become a regular next year.

Viney just looks like a small goer to me. Not overly clean or smart with the footy. All heart, so there's a place in the game for that, but not in the same conversation as Macrae.

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

1.wines
2. Daniher
3. Stringer
4. Grundy
5. Whitfield
6. Macrae
7. Vlastuin
8. Mayes
9. Viney
10. Menzel

 

[TheLastEmperor]

1. Wines
2. Stringer
3. Daniher
4. Whitfield
5. Grundy
6. Macrae
7. Menzel
8. Mayes
9. Stewart
10. Thurlow

 

[DAWESOME!!]

Am I missing something in terms of why Daniher is featuring so high on all these lists? Is it on potential still or on what's has actually delivering now? Would have Wines, Macrae, Stringer, Whitfield and Grundy all comfortably ahead of him on output to date.

If it's on potential, fair enough.

 

[carnthedons]

Am I missing something in terms of why Daniher is featuring so high on all these lists? Is it on potential still or on what's has actually delivering now? Would have Wines, Macrae, Stringer, Whitfield and Grundy all comfortably ahead of him on output to date.

If it's on potential, fair enough.

He's averaging 2 goals a game this year including a bag of six in one of the worst attacking sides in the league as a 3rd year 201cm key forward. It's part potential and part output.

If it's on output only I'd have those 5 ahead but on a mix I'd probably put him 3rd behind Wines & Stringer. All 5 of those players physically were more ready to go than Joe from day one however.

 

[King Corey]

Club supporter starts revised draft thread. Coincidentally the revised #1 pick is a player from that club.

 

[Prochard123]

If the draft is to be held today
1. Daniher
2. Wines
3. Grundy
4. Stringer
5. Macrae
6. Whitfield
7-10 are all whatever. Similar players with unproven talent