Round 1, 2015

[mike123]

FB - Frost Gwilt Frost
HB - Warnock Frawley Robinson
C - Garlett O'Rourke Jaksch
HF - Scharenberg Ryder O'Keefe
FF - Mitchell Walker Nicholson
FOLL - Cox Clisby Pendlebury

Which Garlett?

 

[Markfs]

Scharenberg wont be available Old Sport.

good point....we'll need to pick up someone else in the draft...

 

[Markfs]

Which Garlett?

Dayle..... there was a lot of people here desperate to get him last year

 

[Markfs]

This fixes the scharen prob. Thanks for the feedback guys!!

FB - Frost Gwilt Frost
HB - Warnock Frawley Robinson
C - Garlett O'Rourke Jaksch
HF - Garlett Ryder O'Keefe
FF - Mitchell Walker Nicholson
FOLL - Cox Clisby Pendlebury

 

[mike123]

This fixes the scharen prob. Thanks for the feedback guys!!

FB - Frost Gwilt Frost
HB - Warnock Frawley Robinson
C - Garlett O'Rourke Jaksch
HF - Garlett Ryder O'Keefe
FF - Mitchell Walker Nicholson
FOLL - Cox Clisby Pendlebury

Who's the other Garlett?

Is it Cruize

 

[Markfs]

Who's the other Garlett?

Is it Cruize

maybe we can get the whole extended family in so that there's 22 garletts playing for us in 2015...

 

[Baird]

B: Tom Langdon - Nathan Brown - Marley Williams
HB: Paul Seedsman - Lachlan Keeffe - Scott Pendlebury

C: Steele Sidebottom - Taylor Adams - Dylan Shiel

HF: Timothy Broomhead - Travis Cloke - Jamie Elliott
F: Jarrod Witts - Jessie White - Jeff Garlett

R: Brodie Grundy - Mark Whiley - Dayne Beams

INT: Nathan Freeman- Tony Armstrong - Jarrod Pickett
Sub: Jarrod Garlett

Heritier Lumumba for Jeff Garlett

Alex Fasolo for a second rounder (Jarrod Garlett)

Darcy Moore goes second round and we use our first round pick on Jarrod Pickett.

Ben Reid for Dylan Sheil and Mark Whiley

Ben Reid is contracted until 2018

 

[mike123]

Ben Reid is contracted until 2018

Doesn't mean we can't trade him, just makes the situation allot harder and more unlikely.

 

[Shaneprice97]

This fixes the scharen prob. Thanks for the feedback guys!!

FB - Frost Gwilt Frost
HB - Warnock Frawley Robinson
C - Garlett O'Rourke Jaksch
HF - Garlett Ryder O'Keefe
FF - Mitchell Walker Nicholson
FOLL - Cox Clisby Pendlebury

A Gwilt sandwich that just came out of the freezer

 

[Seedsfan]

B: James Gwilt - Nathan Brown - Marley Williams
HB: Tom Langdon - Lachlan Keeffe - Paul Seedsman

C: Steele Sidebottom - Taylor Adams - Dylan Shiel

HF: Dayne Beams - Travis Cloke - Jamie Elliott
F: Jarrod Witts - Ben Reid - Jeff Garlett

R: Brodie Grundy - Scott Pendlebury - Mark Whiley

INT: Timothy Broomhead - Nathan Freeman - Jarrod Pickett
Sub: Jarrod Garlett

Gwilt and Jeff, are you hell bent on wanting to run the side into the ground. Also there is no way we will recruit Shiel and Whiley and then be able to draft Pickett Jarrod Garlett and Moore

 

[Seedsfan]

B: Tom Langdon - Nathan Brown - Marley Williams
HB: Paul Seedsman - Lachlan Keeffe - Scott Pendlebury

C: Steele Sidebottom - Taylor Adams - Dylan Shiel

HF: Timothy Broomhead - Travis Cloke - Jamie Elliott
F: Jarrod Witts - Jessie White - Jeff Garlett

R: Brodie Grundy - Mark Whiley - Dayne Beams

INT: Nathan Freeman- Tony Armstrong - Jarrod Pickett
Sub: Jarrod Garlett

Heritier Lumumba for Jeff Garlett

Alex Fasolo for a second rounder (Jarrod Garlett)

Darcy Moore goes second round and we use our first round pick on Jarrod Pickett.

Ben Reid for Dylan Sheil and Mark Whiley

Moore is a good chance of going second round, why would we trade Fasolo he is the type of player we need? Jeff is s**t but we have been there already. Taking Pendlebury out of the midfield? Trading Ben Reid for mids you must have rocks in your head. I have seen it all now and lastly where is Swan?

 

[THATSGOLD]

This fixes the scharen prob. Thanks for the feedback guys!!

FB - Frost Gwilt Frost
HB - Warnock Frawley Robinson
C - Garlett O'Rourke Jaksch
HF - Garlett Ryder O'Keefe
FF - Mitchell Walker Nicholson
FOLL - Cox Clisby Pendlebury

Haha. Love it. Why haven't we started threads on Clisby Nicholson etc

 

[jackcass]

How can you justify playing both grundy and witts... It doesnt work.... We need two power fwds and white to be the 3rd fwd 2nd ruck, not white being the 1st or 2nd fwd.. Playing the LEigh brown role

2 rucks dont work

Most of our early season victories came with both Witts and Grundy playing.

 

[Matt_352]

Williams - Brown - Langdon
Malceski - Jacksch - Sidebottom
Freeman - Pendlebury - Petracca
Grundy - Beams - Adams
Swan - Cloke - Broomhead
Elliott - Reid - Kennedy

Witts Moore Thomas ???

 

[Seedsfan]

Williams - Brown - Langdon
Malceski - Jacksch - Sidebottom
Freeman - Pendlebury - Petracca
Grundy - Beams - Adams
Swan - Cloke - Broomhead
Elliott - Reid - Kennedy

Witts Moore Thomas ???

Who are we giving up for Petracca and Jacksch?

 

[Unknown Identity]

Who are we giving up for Petracca and Jacksch?

Eddie and Buckley

 

[Bard]

Williams - Brown - Langdon
Malceski - Jacksch - Sidebottom
Freeman - Pendlebury - Petracca
Grundy - Beams - Adams
Swan - Cloke - Broomhead
Elliott - Reid - Kennedy

Witts Moore Thomas ???

No Gary Ablett? I'm disappoint.

 

[Matt_352]

pick 8 plus someone like blair for pick 2, Lumumba + another player for jacksch

 

[Shaneprice97]

pick 8 plus someone like blair for pick 2, Lumumba + another player for jacksch

Blair would be lucky to get us a pick upgrade in the 3rd round after his recent season.

Let alone a 6 pick upgrade in the top 10.

 

[mike123]

Gwilt and Jeff, are you hell bent on wanting to run the side into the ground. Also there is no way we will recruit Shiel and Whiley and then be able to draft Pickett Jarrod Garlett and Moore

Gwilt is still there? I must have forgot to trade him out. I still have a hard on for Jeff. If we trade Reid for Sheil and Whiley we might get it done, I'm not even sure if Whiley has much value. As for trading Reid for Sheil, He has the evasiveness of Marley Williams, isn't as bad a kick, has a really good balance between inside an outside game, can play both on ball and on the wing and can tag, he did a really good job on Shaun Burgoyne and I think he's done a couple of other jobs.


B: Lachlan Keeffe - Nathan Brown - Marley Williams
HB: Timothy Broomhead - Jack Frost - Tom Langdon

C: Steele Sidebottom - Taylor Adams - Dylan Shiel

HF: Dane Swan - Travis Cloke - Jamie Elliott
F: Jarrod Witts - Jessie White - Jeff Garlett

R: Brodie Grundy - Scott Pendlebury - Dayne Beams

INT: Nathan Freeman - Paul Seedsman - Jarrod Pickett
Sub: Jarrod Garlett

Emg: Mark Whiley, Darcy Moore, Tony Armstrong

 

[THATSGOLD]

Hello good morning!

I am bored and daydreaming. As a result I have come up with what I think could be our Round 1, 2015 team.

FB - Seedsman Brown Toovey
HB - Williams Frawley Lumumba
C - Sidebottom Macaffer Young
HF - Scharenberg Reid Adams
FF - Elliott Cloke Freeman
FOLL - Grundy Beams Pendlebury

Int - (From) Witts Langdon Freeman Moore Blair Broomhead Keeffe Frost Kennedy

Out - Swan (Ret.) Maxwell (Ret.) Goldsack & 2nd Pick (Traded for Frawley ) .


Obviously this is based on preseason form, recovery from injury, etc. How good does our future look?

Spot on.
I reckon Macaffer and Scharenberg will be close to BOG in round 1...

 

[THATSGOLD]

Gwilt is still there? I must have forgot to trade him out. I still have a hard on for Jeff. If we trade Reid for Sheil and Whiley we might get it done, I'm not even sure if Whiley has much value. As for trading Reid for Sheil, He has the evasiveness of Marley Williams, isn't as bad a kick, has a really good balance between inside an outside game, can play both on ball and on the wing and can tag, he did a really good job on Shaun Burgoyne and I think he's done a couple of other jobs.


B: Lachlan Keeffe - Nathan Brown - Marley Williams
HB: Timothy Broomhead - Jack Frost - Tom Langdon

C: Steele Sidebottom - Taylor Adams - Dylan Shiel

HF: Dane Swan - Travis Cloke - Jamie Elliott
F: Jarrod Witts - Jessie White - Jeff Garlett

R: Brodie Grundy - Scott Pendlebury - Dayne Beams

INT: Nathan Freeman - Paul Seedsman - Jarrod Pickett
Sub: Jarrod Garlett

Emg: Mark Whiley, Darcy Moore, Tony Armstrong

Surprised you cant find room for Jack Soft Watts.

 

[mike123]

Surprised you cant find room for Jack Soft Watts.

Personally I'm not concerned with recruiting Jack Watts, but saying he can't play football is just poor.

 

[THATSGOLD]

Brown Reid Frost. Best tall backs would win a flag if all played in defence. Keeffe and Goldsack reserves.

Cloke White Grundy Gault forwards. Probably need to recruit a tall forward to get better there.

Witts Ruck.

Then Beams Pendlebury Adams Broomhead Sidebottom Thomas. Bit young. Not much depth. Needs a Dangerfeild type in there with another taller type mid. Would grab O'Rourke to see what he could do.

Small forwards a worry Elliott needs big help. Blair not up to it really.

Plenty of half back types. Langdon is great. Seedsman needs to do more. Williams could push up more. No need to worry here.

Lock down small defenders. Ramsay. Need another.

 

[DAWESOME!!]

B: Toovey Brown Keeffe
HB: Langdon J.Frost Sinclair
C: Sidebottom Beams Broomhead
HF: Kennedy Reid Karnezis
F: Elliott Cloke Grundy
Foll: Witts Pendlebury Adams
Int: Williams Freeman Swan O'Rourke

Emerg: Moore Thomas Dwyer

Pretty conservative.