Round 14 - Richmond vs. GWS Giants

[nick1408]

Can name some of the worst ones as I have done?

Anthony Miles getting belted in front of the umpire in the forward pocket in the first quarter near the player race (can't remember the player who hit him). This wasn't shown on TV as the camera was on another GWS player but you can hear the crowd react to it. (1st quarter)

Ivan Maric paid holding the ball against in the first quarter after handballing in front of him

Ryan Griffin taking Dustin Martin high in the first and being paid holding the ball

Dylan Grimes having Jeremy Cameron kick out towards his face

Heath Shaw tackling Edwards without the ball in the first quarter

Dylan Shiel being paid push in the back from a Shane Edwards tackle where he tackled him fairly then rolled over

Rance going off for blood rule and umpire not stopping the game

Richmond had no holding the ball decisions paid to them until the last quarter.

Don't get me wrong - GWS lost because of poor umpiring decisions but to me it was the umpires evening up their poor first half instead of just being consistent across the four quarters.

Probably deserves another post but I thought both Marchbank and Downie played well yesterday

 

[From 45]

Watch again you might learn something, anout how to play hard football.

Richmond and hardness don't go together

 

[Tiger2709]

Richmond and hardness don't go together

Yeah sure, take it to Bay 13 young man

 

[kozi]

Richmond gifted this game by the umpires. Kidding themselves of they think they are doing anything this year, absolute head cases

The only headcase here is you

 

[Brown Bottle]

Richmond and hardness don't go together

This isn't the Bay. If you want to be an idjit take it over there

 

[Colonial]

This isn't the Bay. If you want to be an idjit take it over there

Funny considering theres half a dozen cracks about giants crowds and yet nothing is said about the bay.

Weird


Ps not a crack at mods just how the non mods carry on here with whats allowed on the main board. The mods do a great job.

 

[Brown Bottle]

Funny considering theres half a dozen cracks about giants crowds and yet nothing is said about the bay.

Weird


Ps not a crack at mods just how the non mods carry on here with whats allowed on the main board. The mods do a great job.

Not weird at all. I was at the game. I didn't read all 30 pages then and I'm not about to start now.

I posted my thoughts on the match after I got home. I got notified when he posted and his post was bay-worthy. Anyone who watched the game yesterday would know that both sides were pretty hard at it so his comment is just a troll. I would have said the same if he'd said that about the Giants.

 

[Calcium Man]

Can name some of the worst ones as I have done?

I can show you

 

[From 45]

This isn't the Bay. If you want to be an idjit take it over there

Relax tiger.. It's an opinion based on watching richmond games. Whether u agree or not is irrelevant to me.

 

[Brown Bottle]

Relax tiger.. It's an opinion based on watching richmond games. Whether u agree or not is irrelevant to me.

That's ok. Your opinion demonstrates your irrelevance.

 

[From 45]

That's ok. Your opinion demonstrates your irrelevance.

That makes no sense. If you're going to get defensive when someone posts something about your club that you don't agree with , don't come on to the main board

 

[Brown Bottle]

That makes no sense. If you're going to get defensive when someone posts something about your club that you don't agree with , don't come on to the main board

You're questioning Richmond's hardness after the way they've played this season? If you don't want people to call you out don't troll on the main board. I don't need to be defensive about anything. You're the one making statements that are clearly wrong which makes what you're doing either a troll or stupidity.

 

[telsor]

Why is this thread here and not in gameday?

 

[smasha]

Why is this thread here and not in gameday?

Gameday thread I can't find.
Unless someone's cracked the shits,a Pie fan?hehe.

 

[smasha]

Lol Why is this in the umpiring thread?
Lmao.

 

[smasha]

Captain Courageous Cotchin himself.

Had a terrific game again unlike your namesake.

 

[smasha]

The relevance is demonstrating that he is a classless flog, and spitting on another player is clearly up his alley. The only one who seems to need the tissues is you.

Hardly got any press.
Swap jumpers though and it would be all over the media.

 

[Colonial]

Hardly got any press.
Swap jumpers though and it would be all over the media.

Probably because everyone has seen the different camera angles that show he wasnt spitting at the player.

 

[smasha]

Probably because everyone has seen the different camera angles that show he wasnt spitting at the player.

Swap jumpers and the press would be onto the Richmond player no doubt.

 

[copthat]

This thread is an absolutely golden read.

 

[Colonial]

Swap jumpers and the press would be onto the Richmond player no doubt.

Yes because the vic press love us

 

[telsor]

Yes because the vic press love us

More that they don't care about you....Making a big deal about one of your players wont get any additional readers/clicks.

 

[Colonial]

More that they don't care about you....Making a big deal about one of your players wont get any additional readers/clicks.

They care enough to blame us for anything thats wrong with the game.

 

[smasha]

Tiger Army pass the pepper shaker.
Too salty in here!

 

[telsor]

They care enough to blame us for anything thats wrong with the game.

I think you over rate your importance there. Sydney might cop a bit, you're just an afterthought.