Round 5 Tips and Crowd Expectations

[DangerSloane]

Tigers by 37 crowd 22,345
North by 23 crowd 33,128
Dockers by 77. Crowd 24,198
Bombers by 33. Crowd 29,777
Port by 25 crowd 27,598
Giants by 2 crowd 19,526
Suns by 67 crowd 18,562
Dogs by 29 crowd 26,123
Hawks by 32 crowd 68,679

LOL!
Given you have the giants winning, which is fine...but I think that would be a record low crowd for any crows game ever.

 

[DangerSloane]

Yes they are..... But aren't they aren't the quality of Pendlebury, Beams and Swan.

To be fair I dont think theres 3 mids in one team that compare to those three.

 

[go_the_dockers]

To be fair I dont think theres 3 mids in one team that compare to those three.

Fyfe, Mundy and Barlow
Hodge, Mitchell, Burgoyne
Watson, Goddard, Stanton

They are all comparable, but probably not quiet as good as the 3 Collingwood players.

 

[Marmozet]

Brisbane Lions vs Richmond: 32 points, 19k
Collingwood vs North Melbourne: 18 points, 55k
Sydney vs Fremantle: 15 points, 22k
West Coast vs Port Adelaide: 28 points, 36k
Essendon vs St Kilda: 16 points, 42k
Adelaide vs GWS: 34 points, 39k
Melbourne vs Gold Coast: 24 points, 14k
Bulldogs vs Carlton: 19 points, 33k
Geelong vs Hawthorn: 4 points, 68k

 

[I Lost My Keays]

Brisbane v Richmond (29)
Collingwood v NM (7)
Sydney v Fremantle (11)
WCE v Port (17)
Essendon v St Kilda (44)
Adelaide v GWS (35)
Melbourne v GC (49)
WB v Carlton (39)
Geelong v Hawthorn (8)

 

[TheMcGrathMan]

Richmond by 69, 25k

North by 15, 46k

Fremantle by 45, 23k

Essendon by 59, 39k

Port by 16, 40k

Adelaide by 104, 38k

Gold Coast by 32, 24k

Carlton by 3, 26k

Geelong by 1, 77k

 

[samFFC]

To be fair I dont think theres 3 mids in one team that compare to those three.

Bollocks

Fyfe, Mundy and Barlow
Hodge, Mitchell, Burgoyne
Watson, Goddard, Stanton

They are all comparable, but probably not quiet as good as the 3 Collingwood players.

Yep
How many premierships have the Collingwood trio won?

Hodge/Mitchell/Burgoyne > Collingwood trio.

Also, how did the Pies go against Freo in Round 1?

 

[SuperSub17]

Bollocks



Yep
How many premierships have the Collingwood trio won?

Hodge/Mitchell/Burgoyne > Collingwood trio.

Also, how did the Pies go against Freo in Round 1?

Since when do premierships measure the quality of a player? By that logic Brent Renouf was a better player than Harvey/Buckley/Ablett etc

 

[peppy la pew]

What is the go with picking crowd numbers ? Have never understood it, do you include it in the tipping comps.

FFS, it's hard enough picking winners, never mind points, but crowd numbers.

Then we have people arguing because the tipped too low etc, just crazy.

 

[akneal]

Fyfe, Mundy and Barlow
Hodge, Mitchell, Burgoyne
Watson, Goddard, Stanton

They are all comparable, but probably not quiet as good as the 3 Collingwood players.

Fyfe mundy and barlow are the only three there that i really think are anywhere near.
Swan and Pendlebury would be in the top 6 or so in the comp, and Beams taking out last season would just about be in the top 10.

 

[akneal]

Bollocks



Yep
How many premierships have the Collingwood trio won?

Hodge/Mitchell/Burgoyne > Collingwood trio.

Also, how did the Pies go against Freo in Round 1?

What ridiculous comments.
Three players aren't a whole team. Fremantle have a better overall team than collingwood..... with a better game plan....... Doesn't mean that there aren't any pies players who are better than Fremantle players. Lachie Neale must be better than Scott Pendlebury at the moment then according to your logic?

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

What is the go with picking crowd numbers ? Have never understood it, do you include it in the tipping comps.

FFS, it's hard enough picking winners, never mind points, but crowd numbers.

Then we have people arguing because the tipped too low etc, just crazy.

People want to I guess, there's no harm in it. Although arguing over them is pretty silly, I'm with you on that one.

 

[eth-dog]

Brisbane v Richmond - 25 pts, 17,205

Collingwood v North Melbourne - 15 pts, 51,111

Sydney v Fremantle - 4 pts, 28,619

Essendon v St Kilda - 65 pts, 43,812

West Coast v Port Adelaide - 37 pts, 32,701

Adelaide v GWS - 49 pts, 42,104

Melbourne v Gold Coast - 26 pts, 19,121

Western Bulldogs v Carlton - 22 pts, 22,222

Geelong v Hawthorn - 2 pts, 75,294

 

[samFFC]

Since when do premierships measure the quality of a player? By that logic Brent Renouf was a better player than Harvey/Buckley/Ablett etc

Touché, but the point is that we are talking about the key engine room of the best teams of the past few years. Must compare like with like, and in the clutch situations, I'd say I would prefer the Hawks mids to the Pies.

 

[samFFC]

What ridiculous comments.
Three players aren't a whole team. Fremantle have a better overall team than collingwood..... with a better game plan....... Doesn't mean that there aren't any pies players who are better than Fremantle players. Lachie Neale must be better than Scott Pendlebury at the moment then according to your logic?

As with above, have to compare like with like.

 

[MCG-Unit]

Brisbane Lions v Richmond 24
Collingwood v North Melb 10
Swans v Dockers 10
Essendon v St Kilda 1
WC Eagles v Port Adelaide 10
Adelaide v GWS Giants 40
Melbourne v G Coast 19
W Bulldogs v Carlton 7
Geelong v Hawthorn 10

 

[Synth Hawk]

Brisbane Lions v Richmond 44

Collingwood v North Melb 25

Swans v Dockers 38

Essendon v St Kilda 35

WC Eagles v Port Adelaide 35

Adelaide v GWS Giants 22

Melbourne v G Coast 9

W Bulldogs v Carlton 44

Geelong v Hawthorn 54

 

[DangerSloane]

Bollocks



Yep
How many premierships have the Collingwood trio won?

Hodge/Mitchell/Burgoyne > Collingwood trio.

Also, how did the Pies go against Freo in Round 1?

3 players dont win flags drongo.

 

[Howard Littlejohn]

Brisbane v Richmond, Gabba, 22pts, 24k
Collingwood v North Melbourne, MCG, 17pts, 57k
Sydney v Fremantle, SCG, 28pts, 25k
West Coast v Port Adelaide, Subiaco, 14pts, 39k
Essendon v St Kilda, Docklands, 68pts, 43k
Adelaide v Greater Western Sydney, 77pts, 39k
Melbourne v Gold Coast, 3pts, 18k
Western Bulldogs v Carlton, 11pts, 26k
Geelong v Hawthorn, 29pts, 66k

 

[Crow_Magnon]

Brisbane Vs Richmond 27pts 17k

Collingwood Vs North Melbourne 8pts 43k

Sydney Vs Fremantle 24pts 23k

Essendon Vs St Kilda 68pts 41k

West Coast Vs Port Adelaide 34pts 38k

Adelaide Vs GWS 77pts 39k

Melbourne Vs Gold Coast 20pts 16k

Western Bulldogs Vs Carlton 39pts 28k

Geelong Vs Hawthorn DRAW 72k

 

[jordz82]

Looks like not many are real keen to put tips in this week......

 

[SuperSub17]

Brisbane vs Richmond - 43 points, 21K
Collingwood vs North Melbourne - 10 points, 55k
Sydney vs Fremantle - 21 points, 27k
West Coast vs Port Adelaide - 24 points, 37k
Essendon vs St Kilda - 33 points, 40k
Adelaide vs GWS - 35 points, 36k
Melbourne vs Gold Coast - 17 points, 20k
Western Bulldogs vs Carlton - 18 points, 33k
Geelong vs Hawthorn - 7 points, 74k

 

[TheMcGrathMan]

Brisbane vs Richmond - 43 points, 21K

Genius tipping

 

[Stewies Power]

Collingwood vs. North Melbourne - by 25pts (53k)
Sydney vs. Fremantle - by 36pts (24k)
West Coast vs. Port Adelaide - by 12pts (36k)
Essendon vs. St Kilda - by 37pts (40k)
Adelaide vs. GWS - by 41pts (39k)
Melbourne vs. Gold Coast - by 30pts (22k)
Western Bulldogs vs. Carlton - by 8pts (30k)
Geelong vs. Hawthorn - by 10pts (70k)

 

[tige19]

Brisbane vs. Richmond - by 29pts - (20k)
Collingwood vs. North Melbourne - by 32pts (61k)
Sydney vs. Fremantle - by 34pts (22k)
West Coast vs. Port Adelaide - by 22pts (40k)
Essendon vs. St Kilda - by 17pts (37k)
Adelaide vs. GWS - by 42pts (35k)
Melbourne vs. Gold Coast - by 30pts (26k)
Western Bulldogs vs. Carlton - by 11pts (29k)
Geelong vs. Hawthorn - by 16pts (60k)

I'll have $5k bet Hawthorn vs Geelong attracts at least 10k more than the north/coll match!!