I could be wrong, but that goal he kicked on Saturday night was remarkably similar to the goal he missed early in the semi final against the Dogs in 2009...don't know why, just had that feel to it...at least he kicked truly this time.
Past Sam Sheldon (2007-2012)
- Thread starter Lady Lawrence
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Hollow Knight
Imperfect vessel
- May 3, 2005
- 96,485
- 106,664
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- Scuderia Ferrari, Dallas Cowboys
Yeah almost identical.
I was already having deja vu before he kicked it. Was pleased to see him finish, although it felt like he ran about 25 metres without bouncing.
Ironmonger
Brownlow Medallist
- Aug 13, 2001
- 10,452
- 17,513
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- Melbourne Victory
That spot up of McGrath running into goal was actually very impressive.
I thought he was one of our better players, to be honest. Always seemed to be nearby when the ball was around our half-forwardline.
Still not sure what his future is though. I can't see him getting a game in a top eight side.
I thought he was one of our better players, to be honest. Always seemed to be nearby when the ball was around our half-forwardline.
Still not sure what his future is though. I can't see him getting a game in a top eight side.
Grimreepah
BigFooty One Armed Man
Good on you Sammy, gave that contest 100% and came out of it a little worse for wear... but came back to kick an absolute pearler!
Needs to consistently find more of the ball though, otherwise he simply won't be able to really impact games.
Needs to consistently find more of the ball though, otherwise he simply won't be able to really impact games.
Man, I was very iffy on Sammy earlier in the year, but he is slowly but surely becoming one of my favorites. Tends to kick goals at critical moment and his celebration's are always exhilarating for the team and the crowd. Doesn't shirk contests and definitely one of the few young fella's on our list with a fair bit of aggro in him 
I look forward to seeing more of him in the near-future
I look forward to seeing more of him in the near-future
Bucking Beads
Brownlow Medallist
But Sheldon doesn't really play the same role as either of the players you have named..
- Aug 10, 2005
- 46,545
- 42,486
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Any of them can play on the forward flank and I don't really like having forwards tag defenders as Sheldon's job has been some weeks.
Bucking Beads
Brownlow Medallist
Well what you like and what is good for the team are 2 different matters. Some people just don't get it
- Aug 10, 2005
- 46,545
- 42,486
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
So you're saying that you'd rather see Sheldon getting a run in the firsts while Polec and Bartlett are left in the amateur league?
One word: Potential.
Grimreepah
BigFooty One Armed Man
10 things I like
Mark Robinson
Mark Robinson
7. Commitment without injury
West Coast's Luke Shuey and Brisbane's Sam Sheldon had eyes for the slippery ball when they collided on Saturday night. It could've been much worse and they were lucky this time.
If those players earn their games the way the MC have deemed Sheldon to have done then sure.
I would be mighty pissed if we were still giving away games on potential rather than output though.
Even his harshest critics must be intrigued to what another preseason can do for Sammy.
Bucking Beads
Brownlow Medallist
I've still seen some suggest he should be delisted.?
Plus he was drafted underaged compared to the norm. But yep he had to show something this year otherwise the lynch mob would have got their way.
No way. Yes I wasn't his biggest fan earlier on in the year but he has shown improvement and he has definately earned another year! I remember how big a fan of him I was when we first drafted Sammy but since then it just got lower and lower. It is on the up again this year
Milk Steak
Norm Smith Medallist
- Aug 30, 2011
- 5,903
- 5,265
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- Detroit Lions
Re: Who do we delist?
Completely agree with Fairley. Sheldon is the little engine that can't. He tries hard, but can't keep his feet and rarely hits a target, he's had enough chances. I like Hawksleys "hussle", but watching his disposals against Sydney, he's far too sloppy. Maguire I has been woeful since he arrived, but we could probably keep him in the ressies incase we get alot of injuries again. With Buchanan, I don't know why, but I get the feeling he could be really handy if given more games. And Stiller, what can I say, have never thought he's up to it, he doesn't run hard. If you watch a game just look at Stiller, an opponent will have the ball 4 meters away from him and he goes 40% trying to get to him, then once the ball is kicked away, Stiller will make a late attempt to tackle just to give the illusion he is putting pressure on. I am ready to smashed for this post too
Completely agree with Fairley. Sheldon is the little engine that can't. He tries hard, but can't keep his feet and rarely hits a target, he's had enough chances. I like Hawksleys "hussle", but watching his disposals against Sydney, he's far too sloppy. Maguire I has been woeful since he arrived, but we could probably keep him in the ressies incase we get alot of injuries again. With Buchanan, I don't know why, but I get the feeling he could be really handy if given more games. And Stiller, what can I say, have never thought he's up to it, he doesn't run hard. If you watch a game just look at Stiller, an opponent will have the ball 4 meters away from him and he goes 40% trying to get to him, then once the ball is kicked away, Stiller will make a late attempt to tackle just to give the illusion he is putting pressure on. I am ready to smashed for this post too
- Aug 10, 2005
- 46,545
- 42,486
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Re: Who do we delist?
I don't think there is anybody on this board who does not think he has to improve his output in terms of possessions and goals. Some of us think he has to improve this a lot more than others.
He averaged 11 touches and half a goal in his 16 games this season.
He only twice reached 15 possessions.
He'll get a spot on the list next season but you'd think if he can't cement his spot in the best 22 in his sixth season, next year will be his last.
And to cement his spot in the side he'll need to give more than defensive pressure and getting 3 touches a quarter.
I don't think there is anybody on this board who does not think he has to improve his output in terms of possessions and goals. Some of us think he has to improve this a lot more than others.
He averaged 11 touches and half a goal in his 16 games this season.
He only twice reached 15 possessions.
He'll get a spot on the list next season but you'd think if he can't cement his spot in the best 22 in his sixth season, next year will be his last.
And to cement his spot in the side he'll need to give more than defensive pressure and getting 3 touches a quarter.
Bucking Beads
Brownlow Medallist
No doubt Sheldon has to improve but I don't really feel the amount of ball he gets is really something we can mark against him. Needs to have a big pre season and hopefully he is a better player next year.
chopperduck
Brownlow Medallist
Re: Who do we delist?
I've really liked Sheldon this year. He isn't playing a possession gather role, so his possessions don't matter too much, it's more so what he is doing with them. He has done very well defensively and has been much improved offensively, which is a good job considering the state of our forward line in some of the games this year. He hasn't played a lot of footy in his time at the club, and hardly any back to back, so for him to play most of this year, have a solid preseason and load up for next year, we could again see a nice improvement. I like the thought of having the likes of Sheldon, Ash, Banfield, Karni up forward as the 'smalls'. Brown, Acorn/Retzy and Staker as the 'talls'. I think it has a nice balance to it.
I've really liked Sheldon this year. He isn't playing a possession gather role, so his possessions don't matter too much, it's more so what he is doing with them. He has done very well defensively and has been much improved offensively, which is a good job considering the state of our forward line in some of the games this year. He hasn't played a lot of footy in his time at the club, and hardly any back to back, so for him to play most of this year, have a solid preseason and load up for next year, we could again see a nice improvement. I like the thought of having the likes of Sheldon, Ash, Banfield, Karni up forward as the 'smalls'. Brown, Acorn/Retzy and Staker as the 'talls'. I think it has a nice balance to it.
3KZ is Football
🏆 🦍
- Jun 17, 2008
- 26,100
- 34,728
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- Fitzroy Football Club
No way. Yes I wasn't his biggest fan earlier on in the year but he has shown improvement and he has definately earned another year! I remember how big a fan of him I was when we first drafted Sammy but since then it just got lower and lower. It is on the up again this year
2011 Sam Sheldon Team Rankings:
Games Played: 16
Average Disposals Ranking: 31st (10.8 per game)
Average Kicks Ranking: 31st (5.3 per game)
Average Handball Ranking: 22nd (5.5 per game)
Average Tackle Ranking: 7th (3.9 per game)
You are right about one thing lionshine, Sheldon's tackling has improved. Other than that, this season has not been that different to last.
http://www.afl.com.au/stats/tabid/73/default.aspx#page=career&year=0&roundid=0&fixtureid=0&teamid=0&playerids=0&playerid=15647
Let's hope he improves next year and repays the faith that Voss has shown in him.
Go Sammy!
How about you judge his improvement on the way he played not on his stats!2011 Sam Sheldon Team Rankings:
Games Played: 16
Average Disposals Ranking: 31st (10.8 per game)
Average Kicks Ranking: 31st (5.3 per game)
Average Handball Ranking: 22nd (5.5 per game)
Average Tackle Ranking: 7th (3.9 per game)
You are right about one thing lionshine, Sheldon's tackling has improved. Other than that, this season has not been that different to last.
http://www.afl.com.au/stats/tabid/7...xtureid=0&teamid=0&playerids=0&playerid=15647
Let's hope he improves next year and repays the faith that Voss has shown in him.
Gibbo_88
Premiership Player
Agreed. He has definitely improved a lot 3kz and he showed more natural ability than he has before. I'm actually looking forward to seeing him play next year for once.
