Analysis Scott Selwood Debate

[Altum Volantes]

Well maybe not Jetta - maybe Yarran?

At this stage it's likely to be a player with a couple of question marks, most traded players are, but if they have some good run and carry attributes and can create a tough match up around the wing and half forward, I would say that will add more to the side than what Selwood has in the last 2 years.

 

[Godfather32]

Well maybe not Jetta - maybe Yarran?

At this stage it's likely to be a player with a couple of question marks, most traded players are, but if they have some good run and carry attributes and can create a tough match up around the wing and half forward, I would say that will add more to the side than what Selwood has in the last 2 years.

Trade up with our two first rounders for one higher pick?

 

[Altum Volantes]

Trade up with our two first rounders for one higher pick?

Possibly, but they'd have to be pretty damn keen on someone very good I think.

History suggests they might prefer the draft.

 

[neng]

I don't want Jetta in the team unless he's willing to play one hundred percent team football. Not sure he's that good to be honest I like the way we're developing our own players right now.

He has bought into the Swans culture since he got there so I'm sure playing team football won't be the problem. I'd be happy to have him.

 

[Godfather32]

He has bought into the Swans culture since he got there so I'm sure playing team football won't be the problem. I'd be happy to have him.

Is he that good though? Does he offer much more than Hill, whose spot in the forward line I'd be presuming he'd take?

 

[Altum Volantes]

Is he that good though? Does he offer much more than Hill, whose spot in the forward line I'd be presuming he'd take?

I think more likely he'd put pressure on Matt Rosa on the wing and into the midfield.

 

[Godfather32]

I think more likely he'd put pressure on Matt Rosa on the wing and into the midfield.

I'd rather play Duggan there than Jetta. And I'd rather take a risk on Bennell than Jetta.

 

[neng]

Is he that good though? Does he offer much more than Hill, whose spot in the forward line I'd be presuming he'd take?

He'll be involved with the wing-half-forward rotations which doesn't involve Hill as much. Hill will kick more goals at the end of the season but Jetta will contribute more around the ground.

 

[Godfather32]

He'll be involved with the wing-half-forward rotations which doesn't involve Hill as much. Hill will kick more goals at the end of the season but Jetta will contribute more around the ground.

Yeh, I dunno, I'm just not convinced he's worth a 1st round pick.

 

[Eastern Rangers]

Trade up with our two first rounders for one higher pick?

Give this man a cookie.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[Godfather32]

Give this man a cookie.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

How'd you know I like cookies?

 

[Bacchus]

Is he that good though? Does he offer much more than Hill, whose spot in the forward line I'd be presuming he'd take?

Would be more of a wingman I think. Has extreme pace that Hill doesn't have and is more involved in the game than Hill. Hill is just a bit part player who can kick the odd amazing goal. Clearly the team is not too far off (amazingly). Just one or two of the right players to finish off the cake like Chick and Stenglein (although not necessarily hard nuts like them, the game has changed since then).

 

[Biggie]

How'd you know I like cookies?

Who doesn't like cookies?

And if you don't you're pretending you don't.

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

Yeh, I dunno, I'm just not convinced he's worth a 1st round pick.

He probably is to us at subi, the ground is perfect for him.
With our current make up he adds something we dont have to the mix as well.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Yeh, I dunno, I'm just not convinced he's worth a 1st round pick.

He's not. Jetta is Wellingham 2013 2.0

 

[fidstar]

Just came in here to lol at Geelong offering Selwood 500k a year.

Will enjoy that first round compo pick!

 

[the harry]

I'll be disappointed if he doesn't leave now its gone this far.

 

[donpyke92]

Good luck to Selwood if he leaves to play with his brother. Quietly confident that we will do very well out of the deal. He obviously isn't interested or perhaps doesn't understand 'premiership windows', but kudos for family loyalty. I like him as a hard inside player, especially coming on as sub, but think we're tracking nicely in that department for mids if he goes. As for trades,I wonder why people think Jetta is awesome for us on the wing..Gaff and Masten both having stella seasons, or am I missing something? If we have any targets in our sights, I'd be going O'meara or Bennell all day long.

 

[Yippy Yi Yeo]

Good luck to Selwood if he leaves to play with his brother. Quietly confident that we will do very well out of the deal. He obviously isn't interested or perhaps doesn't understand 'premiership windows', but kudos for family loyalty. I like him as a hard inside player, especially coming on as sub, but think we're tracking nicely in that department for mids if he goes. As for trades,I wonder why people think Jetta is awesome for us on the wing..Gaff and Masten both having stella seasons, or am I missing something? If we have any targets in our sights, I'd be going O'meara or Bennell all day long.

Couldn't agree more about jetta, inconsistent and not the type of player we need, plus he's shown he's a dickhead. O'meara and bennell would be far handier and are much younger

 

[Macca81]

have to chuckle at the comments on the Geelong board. I guess one mans trash really is another mans treasure...

 

[Jack_the_Ninja]

Selwood could be ok at Geelong, only as a bettering ram and if he sticks to his team rule ( hand Pass only and get rid of it as soon as you can ).

 

[wce4premiership]

O'meara would be an amazing get but I don't see it happening. Anyway, no certainty Selwood is leaving, the media generally know nothing.

 

[mick06]

Couldn't agree more about jetta, inconsistent and not the type of player we need, plus he's shown he's a dickhead. O'meara and bennell would be far handier and are much younger

Dickhead? For the dance act? Passionate for his team mates and not being able to fully grasp whats going on, yes. Dickhead is a bit far for mine

 

[Godfather32]

Dickhead? For the dance act? Passionate for his team mates and not being able to fully grasp whats going on, yes. Dickhead is a bit far for mine

Yeh, out of the whole mess I don't mind what Jetta did, sticking up for his team mate.

 

[greatwhiteshark]

Will be good to watch another club stuck with a player on a high salary they have to play to save face.