Analysis Scott Selwood Debate

[ChampRevesby]

Third, yeah whats your point? He will get a consult and then if required surgery, odds on it will be at SJoG or Epworth.

His ankle is cooked, lets hope we can patch him up quickly and make him Geelongs problem.

 

[Bender_]

Third, yeah whats your point? He will get a consult and then if required surgery, odds on it will be at SJoG or Epworth.

Nah put him on the elective surgery list and send him out to Swan Districts, will be sweet as.

 

[BigBirdz]

The ankle needs to be weighed up with the orthopedic surgeon. I wonder where he will it get done at St John of God in Subi with likes Western Orthopedic or Epworth in Vic with OSV.

I've had a knee op at SJoG and tib fib fracture surgery at Epworth. Both were unbelievable outfits with numerous professional sports peoples signed uniforms and thank you notes adorning the corridors as you enter the consulting rooms. I couldn't say one was better than the other.

Wow Cool! i took the kids for a drive past StJonOfGod once on me way to the emergency room to get me Gout pills. I drunk to many red cans that month and she blew up. Anyways you must have been lucky to go there.
I had to go to armadale and share a room of 4 blokes when i broke me toe. Shouldnt have been ridin me dirt bike with double pluggers tho.

 

[Eastern Rangers]

Third bout of surgery.....key word being third

Cooked. Simply not a good enough footballer to be bound down to the ground with persistent injuries like this.

 

[TheBeardedEagle]

Cooked. Simply not a good enough footballer to be bound down to the ground with persistent injuries like this.

I'll take Hurn's opinion over yours.

Bad analysis

 

[TheBeardedEagle]

Wow Cool! i took the kids for a drive past StJonOfGod once on me way to the emergency room to get me Gout pills. I drunk to many red cans that month and she blew up. Anyways you must have been lucky to go there.
I had to go to armadale and share a room of 4 blokes when i broke me toe. Shouldnt have been ridin me dirt bike with double pluggers tho.

You missed an H, but in reality you're probably missing a lot more than that.

 

[ChampRevesby]

I'll take Hurn's opinion over yours.

Bad analysis

Fact is he was an emergency on the weekend for a reason and the club have not pushed for his signature. Speaks volumes.

 

[TheBeardedEagle]

Fact is he was an emergency on the weekend for a reason and the club have not pushed for his signature. Speaks volumes.

Are you kidding me?

West Coast list manager Craig Vozzo on Tuesday told the Herald Sun: “We will seriously consider that (matching the Cats’ free agency offer) at the appropriate time”.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...549526209?sv=1ed6b1f6aab3a6bfeb1c76e06c396328
Craig is pushing!

 

[ChampRevesby]

Are you kidding me?


http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...549526209?sv=1ed6b1f6aab3a6bfeb1c76e06c396328
Craig is pushing!

He was an emergency in the PF and GF i.e. not best 22.
Crazy Vozzo says a lot of things.

 

[TheBeardedEagle]

He was an emergency in the PF and GF i.e. not best 22.
Crazy Vozzo says a lot of things.

I'll be listening to Voz over you.
Yeah and the team played so much better than they did in the QF when he was in it.
The PF wasn't a great performance from the Eagles. (not like the QF) And lets forget about the GF.

So your point is that they sent the wrong team out on the weekend? I agree.

 

[ChampRevesby]

I'll be listening to Voz.

You must be new here.

Yeah and the team played so much better than they did in the QF when he was in it.
The PF wasn't a great performance from the Eagles. (not like the QF) And lets forget about the GF.

So your point is that they sent the wrong team out on the weekend? I agree.

No I back Simmo and the match committee over anything you have to say.

 

[TheBeardedEagle]

You must be new here.


No I back Simmo and the match committee over anything you have to say.

Fair enough! But they didn't bring home the silverware did they. So there is an open discussion about what could change.

 

[ChampRevesby]

Fair enough! But they didn't bring home the silverware did they. So there is an open discussion about what could change.

Agreed but if you think Selwood is the answer then I have some bad news for you.

 

[BigBirdz]

You missed an H, but in reality you're probably missing a lot more than that.

You talking about my missing toe nail?

 

[TheBeardedEagle]

You talking about my missing toe nail?

I can see your Mum dropped you on your head a few times. She should of tried another method earlier. Maybe taking a trip down some stairs at 10 weeks?

 

[Eastern Rangers]

I'll take Hurn's opinion over yours.

Bad analysis

Sure. Captain slags off vice captains ability to return to best football after chronic injury problems. When that becomes a thing then Hurn's public opinion on his team mates becomes informative.

You're new so I'll forgive your ignorance. I've defended Scooter's form given his injuries, but he's never been that good and his peak wasn't over any great stretch of time. Was a slow burn up to two very good years in 11/12.

He's been injured longer than he played his best football. His injuries carved a near three year slice through the prime of his career and there is some serious danger that if he requires more surgery that this becomes a four year thing.

Throw in his brother, Geelong and the midfielders improving in his absence and things get interesting.

s**t analysis indeed.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[Double the Fist]

We need a silly fellow emoticon.

I just squirted hot coffee through my ****en nose!




Then I laughed again!

 

[BigBirdz]

I can see your Mum dropped you on your head a few times. She should of tried another method earlier. Maybe taking a trip down some stairs at 10 weeks?

Ill ask her this morning if she dropped me, but she neva said if she did. She taking me in to gef me workers comp forms. We usually share a block of red cans tuesday arvos.

 

[Tiff]

I can see your Mum dropped you on your head a few times. She should of tried another method earlier. Maybe taking a trip down some stairs at 10 weeks?

While you're parading your intelligence around, let's try and get our grammar right first hey?

 

[Dark Sharks]

What's telling, is that clearly TheBeardedEagle has never played football.

 

[kerrazy]

Why do people see us getting an end of first round compo pick? Well get end of second round at most. He is stuffed.

 

[Woutizmoo]

apparently Geelongs offer is significantly less than what WC offerred,
so I think Vozzo has sort of 'by default' matched the offer

just depends on what we think we can get more from - a compo pick or what geelong could possibly offer us (Not much seeing as they'll be spending all their goods on danger), hopefully we can just get the compo pick whatever that may be

 

[Boohemian]

What's telling, is that clearly TheBeardedEagle has never played football.

The only thing that separates him from Eagles87.

 

[The Magenius]

Why do people see us getting an end of first round compo pick? Well get end of second round at most. He is stuffed.

Club champion, club vice-captain, pick 20, is worth pick 20.

 

[Double the Fist]

The bearded eagle is ruffling a few feathers. Lets all just chill and talk footy without getting shirty.

Its the off season now, we relax and be nicer to each other while we try and solve Simmos problems.











Yeah, I know. I'll show myself out....