Selwood incident

[Jtree]

I think a jury of Hawks fans given their show of independent unbiased thinking would deliver a quality result

Firing squad it is then !

 

[JUBJUB]

Onya Joel

So where's the outrage over Swallow doing the same on Walker the next qtr ?


Gee I missed the Bigfooty outrage when Geelong didn't play last week.

 

[Wil79]

Cyril never gets suspended for it why should selwood

You Dill. Cyril did get suspended for it.

 

[Whiskers]

Let's not pretend Selwood is Judd. He's no dirtier than most tough inside players. Can be s**t to watch but by and large not dirty.

Oh god, you saved me from a rant.
Not sure what this gets but unlike your hawk mates, he is not a dirty player.
Never got suspended in junior footy and has been suspended once in how many AFL games.
Also the only player to get punished for a push.
Unbelievable comments around here.

 

[Bardo State]

Oh god, you saved me from a rant.
Not sure what this gets but unlike your hawk mates, he is not a dirty player.
Never got suspended in junior footy and has been suspended once in how many AFL games.
Also the only player to get punished for a push.
Unbelievable comments around here.

Let's not pretend the reverse wouldn't be true for a Mitchell incident

 

[TW Sherrin]

Intentional, medium force, in play.

No idea how that equals but seeing how the north player had that shoulder taped Selwood did it for a reason.

 

[SA HAWK]

Oh god, you saved me from a rant.
Not sure what this gets but unlike your hawk mates, he is not a dirty player.
Never got suspended in junior footy and has been suspended once in how many AFL games.
Also the only player to get punished for a push.
Unbelievable comments around here.

Only once?

You sure about that?

 

[Suma Magic]

Gone.

What a dirty campaigner.

He is sitting on his head while chicken winging.

Weak.

 

[Boxhead_31]

Looked pretty average.

Reportable?

Similar to Judd?

How many do you think Andrew Swallow will get for doing the same action Judd did to Adams on Josh Walker?

Selwood will get a week I think but will be interesting to see if Swallow gets similar

 

[Boxhead_31]

The only thing he was attempting to do there was cause injury. Deserves 3+. What a rat

Who do you play next week?

 

[RegHickeyStand]

Swallow on Walker should be weeks. Clearly two motions: he grabs Walker's arm back, pauses, then twists. In Selwood's case, it was all one motion. So Selwood should get off.

 

[Thewlis Dish]

Can we get some more opinions from Geelong fans in here?

 

[dumb]

judd went straight to the tribunal for intentional misconduct, did not go through the points procedure.

 

[Whiskers]

Let's not pretend the reverse wouldn't be true for a Mitchell incident

I actually kept saying Mitchell should get off even though I think he meant to knee him.
Check history if you can be bothered.
Hawk fans just astound me, although with Selwood a lot more opposition would love to hang him.

 

[spudmaster]

Swallow on Walker should be weeks. Clearly two motions: he grabs Walker's arm back, pauses, then twists. In Selwood's case, it was all one motion. So Selwood should get off.

 

[indy nile]

Onya Joel

So where's the outrage over Swallow doing the same on Walker the next qtr ?


Gee I missed the Bigfooty outrage when Geelong didn't play last week.

How many do you think Andrew Swallow will get for doing the same action Judd did to Adams on Josh Walker?

Selwood will get a week I think but will be interesting to see if Swallow gets similar

Swallow on Walker should be weeks. Clearly two motions: he grabs Walker's arm back, pauses, then twists. In Selwood's case, it was all one motion. So Selwood should get off.

Anyone want to provide vision of this alleged incident?

 

[Whiskers]

Only once?

You sure about that?

Guerra, which is a debateable incident with unclear footage. Guerra engages in wrestle and unfortunately cops an injury, could've been a push that slipped. Who knows?
Then he got 1 down to 0 on a push to his brother. Ridiculous.
Any others?

 

[spudmaster]

I think a jury of Hawks fans given their show of independent unbiased thinking would deliver a quality result

On this incident or your 2015 finals chances?

 

[spudmaster]

Guerra, which is a debateable incident with unclear footage. Guerra engages in wrestle and unfortunately cops an injury, could've been a push that slipped. Who knows?
Then he got 1 down to 0 on a push to his brother. Ridiculous.
Any others?

 

[Boxhead_31]

Anyone want to provide vision of this alleged incident?

Channel 7 only gave the one replay of it.
Strange really given how much focus they put on the Selwood incident

 

[Lester Burnham]

Selwood merely stretched Wright's shoulder, like a remedial therapist would. Any damage would have been caused by the other North Melbourne player coming in and violently pushing Selwood backwards as he held his arm.

 

[power09]

Captain Courageous is not really doing himself any favours with the dirty dog acts behind play in 2015.

He gave Ben Howlett's eyeball a nice bit of acu-pressure

Then he kicked Tom Jonas twice in the back of the head and followed that up with a slap in the back of the head
http://www.portadelaidefc.com.au/video/2015-06-12/ptv-high-contact-on-jonas-results-in-goal
(1st kick @ 0:34, 2nd kick @ 0:35, slap in the head @ 0:47)


I suppose you can't blame him for acting like a knob every week.
The MRP have pretty much given him the green light to do whatever he wants.


Eye-gouging, kicking, jiu-jitsu… What next? Spitting? Head butting?

thank god someone else is paying attention, It seems like nobody wants to know what a dirty prick this guy is when the game isnt going his way.

I feel like Im taking crazy pills here

 

[CakeButcher]

Personally thought of this as soon as I saw it:

Deserves a holiday, and given the way he's been playing this year, probably needs one too.

 

[RedLegs#5]

Dog act. How is this guy seen as a role model?

Truly letting himself down in recent times.

 

[Ry009]

Along with Adams fine work, must be UFC week in the AFL.