Size up the trade value of your list

[AlibiMonday]

Banded in the following

> Pick 1
Picks 1-3
Picks 4-10
Picks 11-20
Picks 21-35
Picks 36-60
Picks 60-90
Picks 90 +

Here's my go for Sydney

> Pick 1
None

Picks 1-3
None

Picks 4-10
J. McVeigh
A. Goodes

Picks 11-20
D. Currie
D. Hanneberry
L. Johnston
D. Jolly
R. O'Keefe
P. Vezpremi
J. White

Picks 21-35
C. Bird
C. Bolton
K. Jack
B. Meredith

Picks 36-60
E. Barlow
J. Bolton
A. Buchanan
H. Grundy
N. Malceski
M. Mattner
J. Moore
T. Richards

Picks 61-90
L. Ablett
P. Bevan
R. Brabazon
B. Kirk
LRT
T. Schmidt
R. Shaw
N. Smith
K. Thornton

Picks 90+
M. Laidlaw
M. O'Dwyer
M. Pyke

No Value
L. Barry
J. Crouch
M. O'Loughlin
H. Playfair

 

[bellzy]

Um, Kirk between 61-90?

I'd give my left nut for Kirk...

 

[AlibiMonday]

Um, Kirk between 61-90?

I'd give my left nut for Kirk...

At this age? Not that he'd ever be traded, but I can't imagine a club putting anything higher than a 4th rounder on offer for a 32yr old midfielder. Then again, maybe I'm wrong.

 

[kreuze_missile]

> Pick 1
C. Judd
M. Murphy
B. Gibbs
M. Kreuzer

Picks 1-3
J. Waite

Picks 4-10
B. Fevola

Picks 11-20
E. Betts
P. Bower
S. Hampson
M. Jamison
B. Thornton

Picks 21-35
S. Grigg
R. Warnock
J. Russell

Picks 36-60
A. Carrazzo
K. Simpson
D. Armfield
M. Austin
B. Fisher
M. Robinson
A. Walker
C. Yarran

Picks 61-90
J. Anderson
R. Houlihan
C. Johnson
H. Scotland
N. Stevens
S. Wiggins

Picks 90+
None

No Value
J. Bannister
A. Bentick
S. Browne
C. Cloke
J. Edwards
R. O'Keefe
S. O'hAilpin
C. Tiller
R. Hadley
A. Hartlett


Of this list, I would say that the following would not be traded for draft picks unless another club massively overrated their value:

Judd, Murphy, Gibbs, Kreuzer, Waite, Jamison, Thornton, Bower, Yarran, Walker, Fevola

 

[rgauci]

> Pick 1
Aaron Sandilands

Picks 1-3
Matthew Pavlich

Picks 4-10
Stephen Hill
Rhys Palmer
Garrick Ibbotson

Picks 11-20
Michael Johnson
Chris Tarrant
Luke McPharlin
Byron Schammer
Paul Duffield
Nick Suban
Hayden Ballantyne

Picks 21-35
Greg Broughton
Zac Clarke
Chris Mayne
Paul Hasleby
Matt DeBoer
David Mundy
Ryan Crowley

Picks 36-60
Michael Walters
Des Headland
Roger Hayden
Tim Ruffles

Picks 61-90
Antoni Grover
Keplar Bradley
Clancee Pearce
Brett Peake
Clayton Hinkley
Chris Hall
Dean Solomon
Scott Thornton
Ben Bucovaz


Picks 90+
Ryan Murphy
Adam Campbell
Andrew Foster
Casey Sibosado
Hamish Shepheard
Jay Van Berlo
Brent Connelly
Marcus Drum
Brock O'Brien

No Value
Andrew Browne
Daniel Gilmore
Josh Head

 

[james Dean]

Top 10 pick for Ibbotson!!

 

[markr]

Picks 1-3
J. Waite

Picks 4-10
B. Fevola

If a club like the Dogs got Fevola for pick 10 it would be the greatest trading raid of all time. Do you rate him down here for his age or his off-field and attitude issues?

On the other hand I can't see clubs offering 1-3 for Waite?

> Pick 1
Aaron Sandilands

Picks 1-3
Matthew Pavlich

As good as Sandi is, I'd be willing to offer miles more for Pav.

 

[Furn]

> Pick 1
Franklin
Roughhead

Picks 1-3
Hodge
Rioli

Picks 4-10
Mitchell
Sewell
Lewis
Ellis
Birchall
Bateman


Picks 11-20
Brown
Williams
Croad
Young
Thorp
Schoenmakers
Osbourne

Picks 21-35
Gilham
Dowler
Tuck
Campbell
Kennedy
Muston
Renouf
Whitecross
Ladson

Picks 36-60
Murphy
Bailey
Sheils
Savage
Lisle
Morton'
Guerra
Mcglynn


Picks 61-90
Lowden



Picks 90+
Dew
Boyle

No Value
Taylor

 

[celtic_pride]

LOL at picks 4-10 for Goodes and Jarrod Mcveigh ...

 

[brettman135]

LOL at picks 4-10 for Goodes and Jarrod Mcveigh ...

i would say goodes would be number 1 pick material at mcveigh a top 3 pick

 

[year of the cat]

LOL at picks 4-10 for Goodes and Jarrod Mcveigh ...

Lol at Jarrod Waite being at picks 1-3.

 

[King Of The Hille]

> Pick 1
Picks 1-3
Ryder
Picks 4-10
Pears
HurleyWatsonStanton
Picks 11-20
GumbletonDaveyMcveighWelshLovettWinderlichHille
Picks 21-35
Myers
Lloyd
Neagle
Monfries
Jetta
Prismall
Lonergan
Zaharakis
Reimers
Dempsey
Picks 36-60
Mcphee
Hooker
Daniher
Still
Houli
Hocking
Dyson
Picks 61-90Slattery
Nash
SlatterySkipworthLaycock
Picks 90+
QuinnNo Value
Lovett-Murray
Fletcher
Atinson
Lucas

 

[pieman123]

> Pick 1
Scott Pendlebury

Picks 1-3
Dale Thomas

Picks 4-10
Alan Didak
Dane Swan
Harry Obrien
Nathan Brown

Picks 11-20
Josh Fraser
Leon Davis
Paul Medhurst
Travis Cloke
Heath Shaw
John Anthony
Brad Dick
Dayne Beams
Steele Sidebottom
Ben Reid
Chris Dawes
John Mccarthy
Sharrod Wellingham
Martin Clarke
Nick Maxwell

Picks 21-35
Tarkyn Lockyer
Tyson Goldsack
Cameron Wood
Shannon Cox

Picks 36-60
Alan Toovey
Jaxson Barham
Brent Macaffer
Shane Obree

Picks 61-90
Simon Prestigiacomo
Ben Johnson
Sean Rusling
Ryan Cook
Danny Stanley

Picks 90+
Anthony Corrie

No Value
Anthony Rocca
Leigh Brown
Chris Bryan

 

[Carlton135]

> Pick 1
Scott Pendlebury

Picks 1-3
Dale Thomas

Picks 4-10
Alan Didak
Dane Swan
Harry Obrien
Nathan Brown

You having a laugh? Is he having a laugh?

 

[TimeFor11]

Pieman you have to be kidding. Dale Thomas is a long long long way of 1-3. He is borderline 11-20 if he wasn't selected at Pick 2 by Collingwood he would be in that 21-35 bracket.

Dawes McCarthy Wellingham Cox... seriously no chance at those picks.

 

[Slander]

> Pick 1
No-one

Picks 1-3
Watts

Picks 4-10
Morton

Picks 11-20
McLean
Frawley
Grimes
Davey

Picks 21-35
Jurrah
Jones
Green
Bruce
Bate
Sylvia
Maric
Garland
Moloney
Rivers
Wonaeamirri
Martin
Bennell
Blease
Strauss

Picks 36-60
Petterd
Jamar

Picks 61-90
Buckley
Meesen
Spencer
Cheney
Jetta
Warnock

Picks 90+
Dunn
Bartram
Miller
Johnson
Valenti
Bail

No Value
Bell
Robertson
Wheatley
McDonald
Whelan
McNamara
Hughes
Zomer
Healey
McKenzie
Newton

 

[TimeFor11]

> Pick 1
Trent Cotchin
Matthew Richardson

Picks 1-3
Brett Deledio
Tyrone Vickery

Picks 4-10
Jack Riewoldt
Alex Rance
Richard Tambling

Picks 11-20
Luke McGuane
Mitch Morton
Jaydyn Post
Robin Nahas
Nathan Foley

Picks 21-35
Chris Newman
Will Thursfield
Shane Edwards
Shane Tuck
Daniel Jackson
Adam Pattison
Ben Cousins
Kelvin Moore
Andrew Collins

Picks 36-60
Andrew Raines
Dean Polo
Tom Hislop
Matt White
Daniel Connors
Andrew Browne
Angus Graham

Picks 61-90
Graham Polak
Nathan Brown
Joel Bowden
Jordan McMahon
Dean Putt
Mark Coughlan
Adam Thomson
Cleve Hughes

Picks 90+
Kayne Pettifer
JON
Jay Schulz
Alroy Gilligan

No Value
Troy Simmonds
David Gourdis
Jarrad Silvester


Jake King

 

[Lions1024]

> Pick 1
Trent Cotchin
Matthew Richardson

Picks 1-3
Brett Deledio
Tyrone Vickery

Picks 4-10
Jack Riewoldt
Alex Rance
Richard Tambling

Picks 11-20
Luke McGuane
Mitch Morton
Jaydyn Post
Robin Nahas
Nathan Foley

Picks 21-35
Chris Newman
Will Thursfield
Shane Edwards
Shane Tuck
Daniel Jackson
Adam Pattison
Ben Cousins
Kelvin Moore
Andrew Collins

Picks 36-60
Andrew Raines
Dean Polo
Tom Hislop
Matt White
Daniel Connors
Andrew Browne
Angus Graham

Picks 61-90
Graham Polak
Nathan Brown
Joel Bowden
Jordan McMahon
Dean Putt
Mark Coughlan
Adam Thomson
Cleve Hughes

Picks 90+
Kayne Pettifer
JON
Jay Schulz
Alroy Gilligan

No Value
Troy Simmonds
David Gourdis
Jarrad Silvester


Jake King

hahaha. LOL. ROFL .

 

[brettman135]

a 30+ guy going for the number 1 pick lol.

Tambling is at least a level below top 10...

Wouldnt give up a top 20 pick for a player like Nahas or Morton. 21-35 is where they belong as there are plenty of there types in the AFL

 

[saintgary]

> Pick 1
Nick Riewoldt

Picks 1-3
Sam Gilbert
Brendon Goddard

Picks 4-10
Nick Dal Santo
Sam Fisher
Leigh Montagna
Lenny Hayes

Picks 11-20
David Armitage
Luke Ball
Zac Dawson
Jason Gram
Justin Kosichitzke
Tom Lynch
Ben McEvoy
Farren Ray
Rhys Stanley
Jack Steven

Picks 21-35
Sean Dempster
Michael Gardiner
Jarryn Geary
Clinton Jones
Matt Maguire
Andrew McQualter
Adam Schnieder
Stephen Milne

Picks 36-60
Raphael Clarke
Xavier Clarke
Robert Eddy
Nick Heyne
Steven King
Luke Miles
Alistair Smith
Jason Blake

Picks 61-90
Jarryd Allen
Paul Cahill
Eljay Connors
James Gwilt
Max Hudghton

Picks 90+
Steven Baker
Leigh Fisher

No Value
Colm Begley

 

[jakethesnake]

very funny thread

 

[Blitzkrieg Boy]

Port Adelaide:
Realistically...

> Pick 1: (Superstar)
No One

Pick 1-3: (Young Guns)
Travis Boak (20)
Alipate Carlile (23)
Troy Chaplin (24)

Pick 4-10: (Standout Performers and Bright Youngsters)
Shaun Burgoyne (26)
Dominic Cassisi (26)
Kane Cornes (26)
Robbie Gray (21)
Hamish Hartlett (18)
Daniel Motlop (27)
David Rodan (25)
Steven Salopek (24)

Pick 11-20: (Consistant Performers and Promising Youngsters)
Brett Ebert
Nathan Krakouer
Danyle Pearce
Jacob Surjan
Justin Westhoff

Pick 21-35: (Reasonable Performers)
Matthew Broadbent
Dean Brogan
Chad Cornes
Jason Davenport
Tom Logan
Michael Pettigrew
Paul Stewart
Matt Thomas
Warren Tredrea

Pick 36-60: (Fringe)
Nick Lower
Danny Meyer
Marlon Motlop
Nick Salter
Toby Thurstans
Matthew Westhoff

Pick 61+: (Struggler/Veteran)
Peter Burgoyne
Mitch Farmer
Jonathan Giles
Brendan Lade

No Value:
Josh Carr - Ironic isn't it?

 

[King Of The Hille]

> Pick 1
Nick Riewoldt

Picks 1-3
Sam Gilbert
Brendon Goddard

Picks 4-10
Nick Dal Santo
Sam Fisher
Leigh Montagna
Lenny Hayes

Picks 11-20
David Armitage
Luke Ball
Zac Dawson
Jason Gram
Justin Kosichitzke
Tom Lynch
Ben McEvoy
Farren Ray
Rhys Stanley
Jack Steven

Picks 21-35
Sean Dempster
Michael Gardiner
Jarryn Geary
Clinton Jones
Matt Maguire
Andrew McQualter
Adam Schnieder
Stephen Milne

Picks 36-60
Raphael Clarke
Xavier Clarke
Robert Eddy
Nick Heyne
Steven King
Luke Miles
Alistair Smith
Jason Blake

Picks 61-90
Jarryd Allen
Paul Cahill
Eljay Connors
James Gwilt
Max Hudghton

Picks 90+
Steven Baker
Leigh Fisher

No Value
Colm Begley

Not 1-3....more like 11-20

the clarkes have NO trade value whatsoever

 

[Big Bad Buddy]

> Pick 1
Trent Cotchin
Brett Deledio

Picks 1-3
Tyrone Vickery

Picks 4-10
Jack Riewoldt
Alex Rance
Richard Tambling
Jayden Post

Picks 11-20
Luke McGuane
Mitch Morton
Robin Nahas
Nathan Foley
Will Thursfield
Matthew Richardson

Picks 21-35
Chris Newman
Shane Edwards
Shane Tuck
Daniel Jackson
Ben Cousins
Kelvin Moore
Andrew Collins
Angus Graham

Picks 36-60
Adam Pattison
Andrew Raines
Dean Polo
Tom Hislop
Matt White
Daniel Connors
Andrew Browne

Picks 61-90
Graham Polak
Nathan Brown
Joel Bowden
Jordan McMahon
Dean Putt
Mark Coughlan
Adam Thomson
Cleve Hughes

Picks 90+
Kayne Pettifer
JON
Jay Schulz
Alroy Gilligan

No Value
Troy Simmonds
David Gourdis
Jarrad Silvester

 

[Stifler's mom]

This is becoming the funniest thread ever.

Seriously, this is why you can't have a serious footy chat on here.