Competitions St Kilda 2014 Dream Team/Supercoach Discussion

[karaoke]

If Hickey worth taking as a cheap ruck man? Do you think he will increase well in price. My other ruck is Sandilands.

He will only be a 'stepping stone' anyway to getting a premium ruck, should play enough early to make some coin, I wouldn't be anticipating holding him any longer than bye rounds, FWIW

His scores could fluctuate a fair bit (ie 50-110 SC pts) IMO

 

[cooperrules]

hickey seems to thrive on taking on the rucking responsibility himself. if he can prove that hes up to shouldering the load he will be one to keep.

 

[SwanBet]

To follow on from the Hickey question... is Longer going to play round 1? Hickeys scoring looks a lot better in the preseason when he rucked on his own compared to when he rucked with Longer.

 

[Mindtraveller]

To follow on from the Hickey question... is Longer going to play round 1? Hickeys scoring looks a lot better in the preseason when he rucked on his own compared to when he rucked with Longer.

Doesn't look like longer will play rd 1 at this stage, but it is still open between Stanley and Longer. I would assume Hickey and Longer will play 10-15 games each this year sharing the load with Hickey atm our no.1 ruckman. It is as krk004 said. Varied scores.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

To follow on from the Hickey question... is Longer going to play round 1? Hickeys scoring looks a lot better in the preseason when he rucked on his own compared to when he rucked with Longer.

Neither of them are going to break records as a forward ( at this stage ), so if they both play, whatever time Longer ( or Stanley for that matter ) gets in the ruck comes off Hickey's potential score.

 

[raymagoo]

Thoughts on billings please guys? Think I need better fwd depth with Rohan average

 

[God Save Max King]

Thoughts on billings please guys? Think I need better fwd depth with Rohan average

Don't go there, not worth it at that price. Markworth would be a better buy.

 

[cooperrules]

I made a last minute change i brought in mcveigh for swallow in the backline. I hate that.

 

[joop]

How good is Travis cloke?

 

[karaoke]

How good is Travis cloke?

1 game, vs Freo, BTW

by years end you'll get what you paid for -> 95 ave,

Scoring anywhere between 40-170 week to week,

 

[karaoke]

Thoughts on billings please guys? Think I need better fwd depth with Rohan average

Awkward price, vest risk, NAB scoring was ordinary, look elsewhere IMO

 

[Axe]

Hi guys,

Can you confirm what happened to Billy Longer in yesterday's game at all?
Went off with blurred vision apparently?

 

[joop]

1 game, vs Freo, BTW

by years end you'll get what you paid for -> 95 ave,

Scoring anywhere between 40-170 week to week,

Yeh I'm talking about that game btw

 

[Zach Package]

Markworth as a bench forward?

Is he in the frame for regular games?

 

[SaintsSeptember]

I took Rohan and McDonough as bench forwards, both will probably make money but weren't that flash on the ground.
I'd have preferred Menzel but I don't know if he will be sub.

The only Saints rookies I have are Dunstan and rookie priced Webster.

I'll have an eye on Markworth.

 

[Tom12]

I took Rohan and McDonough as bench forwards, both will probably make money but weren't that flash on the ground.
I'd have preferred Menzel but I don't know if he will be sub.

The only Saints rookies I have are Dunstan and rookie priced Webster.

I'll have an eye on Markworth.

Webster could score well this season, worth a look IMO!

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Webster could score well this season, worth a look IMO!

Yeah he'd have to be just as likely to do well as McDonald, at a lower price.

 

[Determinant]

Yeah he'd have to be just as likely to do well as McDonald, at a lower price.

Webster 240k, McDonald 182k

 

[Manimal_Dunstan]

Webster 240k, McDonald 182k

He may be talking about AFL Fantasy?

Webster $235k - McDonald $243k

 

[Determinant]

He may be talking about AFL Fantasy?

Webster $235k - McDonald $243k

Ah sorry, completely ignorant to that one

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Whatever I've got him and McDonald in all my teams. The price difference doesn't amount to much.

 

[Tom12]

I think Joey will fly under the radar when he returns, but if one of your mids goes down early he's always a viable option, and will probably be somewhat unique!

 

[the push up king]

hickeys proj. avg. please, would be happy with 85+. simply a stepping stone to the byes.
Or do you think h mac being a better same price option?

 

[Manimal_Dunstan]

hickeys proj. avg. please, would be happy with 85+. simply a stepping stone to the byes.
Or do you think h mac being a better same price option?

Is this a Supercoach or DreamTeam/AFL Fantasy questions?

In the NAB Challenge without Longer he scored twice over 90, if Longer is named tomorrow i don't think Hickey will be a good option as he only scored 40 odd with Billy in the side.

I'd say 85+ is good in Supercoach without Longer and maybe 80-85 in DT/AF.

 

[okeydoke7]

hickeys proj. avg. please, would be happy with 85+. simply a stepping stone to the byes.
Or do you think h mac being a better same price option?

Hard to project but an average of 80 odd IMO if he stays number 1 ruck which I think he will.

I am taking him over H Mac for sure.