St Kilda v Adelaide rd 4, 2014

[SilenceOz]

As poor as St.Kilda were today, they're still below Brisbane in the race for the #1 pick. Those wins over Melbourne and GWS may prove costly at the end of the year.

Carlton sure are throwing in some effort to get the #1 though.
Dont count them out.

 

[Klaus]

Jeremy Cameron only kicked 3 against us when we were missing our three best key defenders, obviously a spud. He took 4 marks.
Not a good argument is it?

I actually think Cameron has been disappointing so far this season and may have got ahead of himself after being hyped up so much. He's become a somewhat lazy footballer who relies on silver service from the midfielders, rather than working insanely hard for his goals (ala Riewoldt).

 

[Adam H]

Cordy and Stanley are both VFL standard at this stage.

The Dogs were also in the game for 3 qtrs against North - a better team than Adelaide

Stanley nine marks today. Not bad for a bloke that cant play hey.

 

[ManOfClay]

Stanley nine marks today. Not bad for a bloke that cant play hey.

And an objective view below:

Stanley was for the most part woeful today.

I don't care what the stats say, I saw a bloke whose efforts would be considered soft in basketball.

He's got the skills and the pace but he doesn't have the mindset for either to be useful at AFL level.

 

[Klaus]

Carlton sure are throwing in some effort to get the #1 though.
Dont count them out.

It will be interesting to see if Malthouse drops Murphy and Gibbs to sure up the losses. He will start his A-Grade s***trucks in Kane Lucas, Robbie Warnock and Andrew Walker for the rest of the year.

 

[Adam H]

And an objective view below:

Hes a third tall up forward that pinch hits in the ruck. Nine marks a goal with limited supply us a great effort.

 

[ManOfClay]

Hes a third tall up forward that pinch hits in the ruck. Nine marks a goal with limited supply us a great effort.

No he's not.

 

[Adam H]

No he's not.

stats say otherwise.

 

[Rise_up_Stiffy]

St Kilda were really bad today and made us look really good. It was nice to see the other team fumbling and bumbling for a change.

 

[Stan_Darsh72]

We looked slow and kicked like s**t,

 

[ManOfClay]

stats say otherwise.

The game says otherwise.

 

[Adam H]

The game says otherwise.

Amazing that you throw up Jones kicking 3 even though his impact otherwise was minimal. Yet ignore Stanleys numbers.

 

[ManOfClay]

Amazing that you throw up Jones kicking 3 even though his impact otherwise was minimal. Yet ignore Stanleys numbers.

Because last time I checked the team with the most goals wins the game more often than the team with the most marks.

Stanley's impact was minimal regardless while Jones has now kicked 3 goals two weeks in a row in wins.

 

[Adam H]

Because last time I checked the team with the most goals wins the game more often than the team with the most marks.

Stanley's impact was minimal regardless while Jones has now kicked 3 goals two weeks in a row in wins.

Wow just amazing he has strung two games in a row when his minimal impact was close enough to score.

 

[ManOfClay]

Wow just amazing he has strung two games in a row when his minimal impact was close enough to score.

As opposed to Stanley whose minimal impact does what?

He had three hitouts tonight. Some pinch-hitting ruckman he is.

 

[Adam H]

As opposed to Stanley whose minimal impact does what?

He had three hitouts tonight. Some pinch-hitting ruckman he is.

Jones 5 marks some key forward he is.

 

[Ravenous Crow]

You know a game sucks when the matchday thread gets derailed by a Rhys Stanley vs Ayce Cordy argument.

 

[Chopperdave]

You know a game sucks when the matchday thread gets derailed by a Rhys Stanley vs Ayce Cordy argument.

Especially when its not even a who's better argument but more of a who's less s**t argument...

 

[ManOfClay]

You know a game sucks when the matchday thread gets derailed by a Rhys Stanley vs Ayce Cordy argument.

Match is over, I'm just humouring the fool.

PS it's Rhys Stanley vs Liam Jones. Cordy is a VFL player.

 

[Nutsngum]

Match is over, I'm just humouring the fool.

PS it's Rhys Stanley vs Liam Jones. Cordy is a VFL player.

I understand that a shitfight about which average players are better then other average players is a super important aspect to your life for some god forsaken reason but how about you keep it civil and debate like an adult rather then being a dick about it?

 

[ManOfClay]

I understand that a shitfight about which average players are better then other average players is a super important aspect to your life for some god forsaken reason but how about you keep it civil and debate like an adult rather then being a dick about it?

I'm sorry, I just can't hack blatant stupidity, I get sucked in by trolling too easily.