Not-a-cluey StKilda to give up pick 1 to hawthorn

[Tragic sainter]

and O'Brien.

Now your just being greedy.

 

[Heisenberg_]

That was my first reaction
Makes sense though, if the saints are looking for players to fast track their rise up the ladder

No, it doesn't make sense at all. 4 bit part players never has and never will get you pick 1.

Not 1 of those guys would land a first round pick, packaging them all up won't get close to pick 1.

 

[Halloween Jack]

This is why I love trade time.

s**t + s**t + s**t + s**t = Gold!

 

[Stan The Caddy]

Hahahahahahaha! Please...

 

[grouse mate]

Hearing its a straight swap for Ben McEvoy.

 

[Crankyhawk]

Heard from an unreliable source (who is involved at the saints tough)
Apparently the saints are in. Negotiations with the hawks to exchange pick 1 (and an exchange of later picks) for Cheney, Lowden, grimley and schoenmakers

At first I laughed, but having a deeper look, those four would actually help the saints, so will be interesting to see whether it occurs

I think you've been riding the wave of everything going right for hawthorn since the start of the grand final. Just because we wish it doesn't make it true. It only seems that way recently.

 

[HawkMongrel]

As ridiculous as this rumour is, gawd could you imagine the collective footy community meltdown if St Kilda were THAT stupid.

 

[Howard Littlejohn]

As ridiculous as this rumour is, gawd could you imagine the collective footy community meltdown if St Kilda were THAT stupid.

Well, St Kilda haven't got themselves into trouble this off-season. Getting the whole football department sacked on the back of one trade would be a new way to get into the news.

 

[Stratton_Gun]

If this happens I will be first to believe in the religion of Graham Wright

 

[captain cotch 9]

It may fast track their climb but they would fall as quickly as they rose if they did that trade.
Petracca will be a superstar.

 

[KennyHunter9]

Heard from an unreliable source (who is involved at the saints tough)
Apparently the saints are in. Negotiations with the hawks to exchange pick 1 (and an exchange of later picks) for Cheney, Lowden, grimley and schoenmakers

At first I laughed, but having a deeper look, those four would actually help the saints, so will be interesting to see whether it occurs

If you want pick #1 you'll have to send Gunston & Hill their way ... no? Didn't think so.

 

[De Iulio2Wiggins]

Why would you want Cheney, Lowden, Grimley and Schoenmakers

when you could have Warnock, Watson, Robinson, McLean ... and Lucas.

Get on it Saints, deals don't come much sweeter than this.

 

[TheJaegerBomb]

If someone I knew told me something like that I would punch them in the nose and tell them to never repeat it again.

 

[MinerBoy]

That was my first reaction
Makes sense though, if the saints are looking for players to fast track their rise up the ladder

It makes no sense and everyone involved in such a decision would have to sack themselves immediately for stupidity.

 

[Skeppersap]

Mitchell Madness, the best poster on Big Footy, strikes again!

 

[Stratton_Gun]

If you want pick #1 you'll have to send Gunston & Hill their way ... no? Didn't think so.

Which is why pick one is so overrated! Wouldn't be surprised if whoever is pick#1 isn't as good as either of Hill or Gunston let alone both.

 

[Mitchell Madness]

Mitchell Madness, the best poster on Big Footy, strikes again!

It does seem no one can contain themselves when I post, it is quite amusing

Note, even it said it's unlikely

 

[Upgrayedd]

Would rightfully declare that Chris Pelchin is hawthorns greatest list manager of all time if this happens, But i think we also need to chuck in Dayle Garlett in there as well

 

[melbournemartin]

Heard from an unreliable source (who is involved at the saints tough)
Apparently the saints are in. Negotiations with the hawks to exchange pick 1 (and an exchange of later picks) for Cheney, Lowden, grimley and schoenmakers

At first I laughed, but having a deeper look, those four would actually help the saints, so will be interesting to see whether it occurs

That's the sort of trade you could make on AFL Live 2006.

 

[Rors]

How about we just trade picks 1 & 41 to GWS for picks 4,6 & 7?

 

[Adelaide Hawk]

Hawthorn cant just trade a bunch of duds to St Kilda for the number 1 draft pick.... again.

1988 National Draft

St Kilda's Pick 1 traded to Hawthorn for Robert Handley, Paul Harding & Peter Russo.

Yep, my thoughts precisely. Sounds good for Hawthorn on the surface, but the guy we picked up at No.1 turned out to be a lemon. Number 1 draft picks in the 80s weren't as well researched as they are in the year 2014.

 

[Jimmy Yamazaki]

GWS will get pick 1, now they will look to get another KPF in the draft.

They have 3 picks in the top 10 and will swap 2 for Saints 1st pick...

 

[AM]

Heard from an unreliable source (who is involved at the saints tough)
Apparently the saints are in. Negotiations with the hawks to exchange pick 1 (and an exchange of later picks) for Cheney, Lowden, grimley and schoenmakers

At first I laughed, but having a deeper look, those four would actually help the saints, so will be interesting to see whether it occurs

Pelchen said today the Saints priority was picks. Said he'd already had two offers that would have given them 3 picks in the top 10 for pick one and rejected both. If true that is not something the Hawks could offer.

 

[Hens Hall]

Dogshit remains dogshit, no matter how many pieces of it you add to the pile....

So you are saying St Kilda are dog s**t?

 

[SdKfz 181]

Flogs who start bullshit threads like this should be permanently banned

this