Team of the Week: Round 23

Remove this Banner Ad

Aug 13, 2012
6,349
12,277
Waiting for Josh Kelly #2020
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Welcome to the final Team of the Week for the Home and Away Season in 2014! Thanks for your continual feedback throughout the year.

The team

DEFENCE

Back Pocket
Josh Gibson (Hawthorn)
Was at his patrolling best in the backline on Friday night against Collingwood, taking on the resting ruckman in Brodie Grundy and Jarrod Witts. Both big guys failed to trouble the scoreboard, while Gibson accumulated 36 possessions and took 11 marks. Primed for a big September.

Full Back
Alex Rance (Richmond)
His inclusion to the team on the back of injury has, along with Ivan Maric, kickstarted this incredible run to an unlikely finals berth in 2014. Was immense on Saturday evening and was a major reason why Richmond will play this weekend. Kept Kurt Tippett to six touches and one goal while racking up 16 disposals, taking seven marks and laying three tackles. So desperate in the contest.

Back Pocket
Heath Shaw (Greater Western Sydney)
Can only call his move to Greater Western Sydney a resounding success. Finished the year with a superb game, tallying 29 touches from 12 marks against the Bulldogs. Has given a lot of his younger teammates, especially in the backline, confidence to take the game on.

Half Back
Brodie Smith (Adelaide)
Might have sewn up a spot in the All Australian team with another sensational performance on the weekend. Gathered 34 disposals, took five marks and slotted a goal. In terms of metres gained, he's the most valuable player in the league.

Centre Half Back
Daniel Talia (Adelaide)
Like his teammate Smith, another strong game from Talia against St Kilda could cement his first All Australian berth. Kept fellow Rising Star winner Nick Riewoldt to 10 touches and no score, just the second time this season he hasn't kicked a goal. Talia grabbed eight marks and collected 15 touches.

Half Back
Shaun Atley (North Melbourne)
Finished the year strongly with a top performance against Melbourne on Saturday night, collecting 21 possessions, taking five marks, laying three tackles and showing his trademark burst to get forward and slot a goal.

MIDFIELD

Wing
Brett Deledio (Richmond)
Has been maligned in the past for not standing up in the big games, but put those claims to bed with an outstanding game against Sydney. Won 29 disposals, took five marks, laid five tackles and kicked three goals, willing his side into the finals.

Centre
Ryan Griffen (Western Bulldogs)
Did everything he could in the final game of the season to get his side one more win, but alas it wasn't enough. Amassed 38 touches, took six marks, laid five tackles and kicked a goal on rising star Dylan Shiel. Will be even better next year with a proper pre-season.

Wing
Dan Hannebery (Sydney)
Like Griffen, he tried his hardest in what was a dead-rubber for the Swans. Gathered 33 possessions, took five marks, laid 10 tackles and booted a goal. Loves the big stage, so watch out for him in the next month of footy.

FORWARD

Half Forward
Josh Caddy (Geelong)
His past month could be viewed as a bit of a breakout period for Caddy, who has well and truly cemented his spot in Geelong's best 21. Was great against Brisbane on Saturday night, collecting 24 touches, taking five marks, laying three tackles and booting three majors.

Centre Half Forward
Josh Kennedy (West Coast)
Finished what could be viewed as a disappointing year strongly, beating up on the Gold Coast Suns with 12 disposals, seven marks, three tackles and eight goals on Rory Thompson. Has 26.2 from three matches against the Giants and Suns in 2014.

Half Forward
Mark LeCras (West Coast)
His rise in form has coincided with West Coast's strong finish to the year, and was great again against the Suns. Collected 20 touches, took four marks, laid three tackles and slotted four majors. If he kicks 50 or more next year, Eagles are pushing the top four.

Forward Pocket
Jack Gunston (Hawthorn)
Brought up the half century on Friday night with five majors on Lachie Keeffe, picking up 23 disposals from nine marks. He, Roughead and Breust have made a mockery of the claims that the goalkicking would dry up with no Buddy.

Full Forward
Jay Schulz (Port Adelaide)
Finished the year strongly after a lean patch recently, kicking six majors on Zac Dawson from 15 touches, eight marks and two tackles. If he keeps games like this up in the finals, Port could push deep.

Forward Pocket
Will Hoskin-Elliott (Greater Western Sydney)
Ended a promising season on a high note with an equal career-high five majors against the Western Bulldogs from 15 disposals and six marks on Dale Morris. Is fast, agile and can leap. He could be the one the Giants are most excited about.

FOLLOWERS

Ruckman
Nic Naitanui (West Coast)
Showed on Sunday what the tandem of Naitanui and Lycett could bring in the post-Cox generation. Naitanui had 12 touches, took three marks, laid six tackles, won 28 hitouts, 12 of them to advantage, and kicked three goals. West Coast's ruck stocks are perhaps the healthiest in the competition.

Ruck Rover
Joel Selwood (Geelong)
Amazingly, is gearing up for an eighth finals campaign since his debut in 2007. Was arguably best afield on Saturday night, amassing 29 possessions against the Lions, taking six marks, laying nine tackles and booting two goals.

Rover
Rory Sloane (Adelaide)
Two of the most likeable players in the league went head-to-head on Sunday afternoon at the Adelaide Oval, with Rory Sloane and Jack Steven going against each other. Both collected 30 disposals, with Sloane laying nine tackles and kicking three goals to lay claims for best on ground honours.

INTERCHANGE

Dean Kent (Melbourne)
A small shining light for the Demons in 2014 has been Kent's form. At times has shown he is a bundle of energy, zipping around the field and providing plenty of scoring options while being able to slot fantastic, classy goals. On Saturday night against the Roos, Kent collected 14 touches, took five marks, laid three tackles and kicked three majors, setting up two in the last quarter to defender Tom McDonald. Dees would have lost by 10 goals without him.

Lachie Neale (Fremantle)
Stood up in the absence of Nathan Fyfe, winning 34 disposals, taking seven marks and laying five tackles. Does he perform better without his champion teammate in the same side?

Brock McLean (Carlton)
A major reason why the Blues got off to a brilliant start against the Bombers on Saturday, collecting 11 touches in the first quarter. Ended with 32 possessions, seven marks, five tackles and a goal.

Substitute
Reece Conca (Richmond)
Started with the subs vest and was into the action late in the third quarter for Ricky Petterd. Did well to find plenty of the ball in his game time, collecting 12 possessions and taking two marks. Probably earns his spot in the best 21 on the back of this next week.

On paper


FB: Josh Gibson (Hawthorn), Alex Rance (Richmond), Heath Shaw (Greater Western Sydney)
HB: Brodie Smith (Adelaide), Daniel Talia (Adelaide), Shaun Atley (North Melbourne)
C: Brett Deledio (Richmond), Ryan Griffen (Western Bulldogs), Dan Hannebery (Sydney)
HF: Josh Caddy (Geelong), Josh Kennedy (West Coast), Mark LeCras (West Coast)
FF: Jack Gunston (Hawthorn), Jay Schulz (Port Adelaide), Will Hoskin-Elliott (Greater Western Sydney)
R: Nic Naitanui (West Coast), Joel Selwood (Geelong), Rory Sloane (Adelaide)
I/C: Dean Kent (Melbourne), Lachie Neale (Fremantle), Brock McLean (Carlton)
SUB: Reece Conca (Richmond)

By team

Adelaide: Smith, Talia, Sloane (3)
Brisbane: Nil (0)
Carlton: McLean (1)
Collingwood: Nil (0)
Essendon: Nil (0)
Fremantle: Neale (1)
Geelong: Caddy, Selwood (2)
Gold Coast: Nil (0)
Greater Western Sydney: Shaw, Hoskin-Elliott (2)
Hawthorn: Gibson, Gunston (2)
Melbourne: Kent (1)
North Melbourne: Atley (1)
Port Adelaide: Schulz (1)
Richmond: Rance, Deledio, Conca (3)
St Kilda: Nil (0)
Sydney: Hannebery (1)
West Coast: Kennedy, LeCras, Naitanui (3)
Western Bulldogs: Griffen (1)
 
Last edited:
Billy Hartung could also make a claim for the sub role. Only played the last quarter, but picked up 10 disposals at 100% efficiency, 6 marks and a goal
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Billy Hartung could also make a claim for the sub role. Only played the last quarter, but picked up 10 disposals at 100% efficiency, 6 marks and a goal

The game was well and truly over by that stage. Conca came on and was effective in a cut throat game for his club which got them into the finals.
 
Lots of big forwards kicked bags this weekend, he did it against the weakest opposition. Them's the breaks.

Yeah that's a good point. I thought Tomahawks performance was excellent but six goals against Freo and 8 goals against the Suns is a better return than 7 against Brisbane :oops:

Great work on these threads this year as well Spitta2Azza. Always a great read. :)
 
Any plans of putting out the Team of the Season Spitta2Azza ??

Go back and see who made the team the most number of times and try to put together a best 22.
 
Perhaps your selection of players for the team of the week needs some context?

Picking Ryan Griffin in the midfield and Mark Le Cras and Will Hoskin-Elliott in the forward line on the basis of their performances in what were meaningless games is not of the same merit as players who performed in big games that actually meant something in the context of the H&A season.

As an example, Walters and Ballantyne belong in the forward line for their outstanding performance against Port Adelaide, which was a battle for the last spot in the top 4. Neale also deserves to be on the field ahead of Griffin as he was the engine room for Freo that engineered a significant win over Port.
 
Perhaps your selection of players for the team of the week needs some context?

Picking Ryan Griffin in the midfield and Mark Le Cras and Will Hoskin-Elliott in the forward line on the basis of their performances in what were meaningless games is not of the same merit as players who performed in big games that actually meant something in the context of the H&A season.

As an example, Walters and Ballantyne belong in the forward line for their outstanding performance against Port Adelaide, which was a battle for the last spot in the top 4. Neale also deserves to be on the field ahead of Griffin as he was the engine room for Freo that engineered a significant win over Port.

Nah.
 
Perhaps your selection of players for the team of the week needs some context?

Picking Ryan Griffin in the midfield and Mark Le Cras and Will Hoskin-Elliott in the forward line on the basis of their performances in what were meaningless games is not of the same merit as players who performed in big games that actually meant something in the context of the H&A season.

As an example, Walters and Ballantyne belong in the forward line for their outstanding performance against Port Adelaide, which was a battle for the last spot in the top 4. Neale also deserves to be on the field ahead of Griffin as he was the engine room for Freo that engineered a significant win over Port.

So going by that you'd have to exclude every single player playing in a dead rubber on the weekend. No point.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Perhaps your selection of players for the team of the week needs some context?

Picking Ryan Griffin in the midfield and Mark Le Cras and Will Hoskin-Elliott in the forward line on the basis of their performances in what were meaningless games is not of the same merit as players who performed in big games that actually meant something in the context of the H&A season.

As an example, Walters and Ballantyne belong in the forward line for their outstanding performance against Port Adelaide, which was a battle for the last spot in the top 4. Neale also deserves to be on the field ahead of Griffin as he was the engine room for Freo that engineered a significant win over Port.

Can't wait to see your proposal to the Afl to bring in weighting to the Brownlow voting (does playing against a team suspected of tanking give you .25 of a vote or .3333 recurring.

Also see merit in adjusting the Coleman to the following formula:

Kennedy's 8 should be recalculated as (8 x .8 representing playing a team outside the 8) x (.5 for not being in finals contention) plus (1 for being a hot day) plus (1 for having to fly and then get on a bus to get to the game) plus (.8 for having a below par midfield kicking to him) = 6 goals.

I like it!
 
Last edited:
Perhaps your selection of players for the team of the week needs some context?

Picking Ryan Griffin in the midfield and Mark Le Cras and Will Hoskin-Elliott in the forward line on the basis of their performances in what were meaningless games is not of the same merit as players who performed in big games that actually meant something in the context of the H&A season.

As an example, Walters and Ballantyne belong in the forward line for their outstanding performance against Port Adelaide, which was a battle for the last spot in the top 4. Neale also deserves to be on the field ahead of Griffin as he was the engine room for Freo that engineered a significant win over Port.

You seem like the type of pedantic twit that would have a whinge if Pearce Hanley was named All-Australian "because he's Irish".

Some things you can just let go.
 
So I have gone back over all 23 rounds.

Times named in the starting 21 -

8
Lance Franklin

7
Joel Selwood

6
Eric MacKenzie
Robbie Gray
Tom Rockliff

5
Alex Rance
Brent Harvey
Brodie Smith
Daniel Talia
Gary Ablett
Harry Taylor
Hayden Ballantyne
Jordan Lewis
Josh Kennedy (SYD)
Josh Kennedy (WCE)
Luke Parker
Nat Fyfe
Nick Riewoldt
Steele Sidebottom

4
Ben McGlynn
Bryce Gibbs
Cale Hooker
Dayne Beams
Devon Smith
Dom Tyson
Dyson Heppell
Eddie Betts
Jack Gunston
Jay Schulz
Josh Gibson
Kade Simpson
Luke Bruest
Mark Lecras
Nick Malceski
Steve Johnson
Travis Boak
Trent Cotchin

3
Aaron Sandilands
Ben Cunnington
Brandon Ellis
Dan Hannebery
David Swallow
Heath Shaw
Jamie Elliott
Jarryd Roughead
Jeremy Howe
Jimmy Bartel
Luke McPharlin
Lynden Dunn
Mark Baguley
Matthew Pavlich
Mitch Duncan
Patrick Dangerfield
Paul Duffield
Rory Sloane
Sam Jacobs
Shane Mumford
Stephen Hill
Tom Lynch (GC)
Travis Cloke

2
Adam Treloar
Andrew Carrazzo
Angus Litherland
Brad Ebert
Brendon Goddard
Callan Ward
Cam Pederson
Chad Wingard
Chris Masten
Chris Yarran
David Zaharakis
Dayne Zorko
Dean Kent
Dion Prestia
Dustin Fletcher
Hamish Hartlett
Heath Grundy
Jackson Macrae
Jackson Trengove
Jaeger O'Meara
Jake Carlisle
Jake Stringer
Jarmen Impey
Jarrad McVeigh
Jarrod Harbrow
Jason Winderlich
Jobe Watson
Joel Patfull
Josh Caddy
Josh Jenkins
Justin Westhoff
Lachie Neale
Levi Greenwood
Luke Shuey
Marc Murphy
Mathew Stokes
Matt Priddis
Michael Firrito
Nic Naitanui
Ollie Wines
Patty Ryder
Paul Chapman
Pearce Hanley
Phil Davis
Ricky Petterd
Sam Gibson
Sam Mitchell
Sam Rowe
Sam Wright
Scott Pendlebury
Scott Thompson (NM)
Shaun Burgoyne
Stefan Martin
Steven May
Stewart Crameri
Taylor Walker
Todd Goldstein
Tom Hawkins
Tom Jonas
Tom Liberatore

1
Adam Cooney
Alan Toovey
Alex Fasolo
Allen Christensen
Andrejs Everitt
Andrew Gaff
Andrew Swallow
Bachar Houli
Ben Howlett
Bernie Vince
Bob Murphy
Brad Sewell
Brandon Matera
Brent Macaffer
Brett Deledio
Brock McLean
Chris Dawes
Chris Judd
Clinton Jones
Craig Bird
Cyril Rioli
Dane Rampe
Dane Swan
Darcy Gardiner
Darren Glass
David Armitage
David Hale
David Mackay
David Mundy
David Myers
Dean Cox
Drew Petrie
Grant Birchill
Harley Bennell
Heath Hocking
Isaac Smith
Ivan Maric
Jack Billings
Jack Frost
Jack Newnes
Jack Redden
Jack Riewoldt
Jack Ziebell
Jackson Merrett
Jake Batchelor
James Aish
James Frawley
James Kelly
Jamie Bennell
Jared Polec
Jared Rivers
Jarrad Waite
Jason Johanissen
Jed Adcock
Jeff Garlett
Jimmy Gwilt
Joe Daniher
Josh Thomas
Kade Kolodjashnij
Kane Mitchell
Lachie Hansen
Lachie Henderson
Lee Spurr
Leigh Montagna
Lenny Hayes
Lewis Taylor
Liam Picken
Lindsay Thomas
Luke Brown
Luke Dahlhaus
Luke Hodge
Matt Rosa
Matt Spangher
Matt Suckling
Matthew Boyd
Matthew Broadbent
Matthew Lobbe
Matthew White
Michael Barlow
Michael Hibberd
Michael Hurley
Michael Johnson
Nathan Foley
Nathan Grima
Nathan Jones
Neville Jetta
Nick Dal Santo
Nick Maxwell
Nick Smith
Nick Suban
Robbie Warnock
Rohan Bail
Rohan Bewick
Rory Laird
Ryan Griffen
Ryan Harwood
Sam Butler
Sam Frost
Scott Thompson (ADEL)
Shane Edwards
Shane Savage
Shannon Hurn
Shaun Atley
Shaun Hampson
Stephen Coniglio
Tendai Mzungu
Tom Bell
Tom Bugg
Tom Curren
Tom Hickey
Tom Langdon
Tom Lonergan
Tom Lynch (ADEL)
Tom McDonald
Troy Chaplin
Will Hoskin-Elliott
Will Langford
Zac Clarke

Number of times named as SUB -

3
Daniel Giansiracusa

1
Anthony Morabito
Ben Kennedy
Ben Lennon
Ben Newton
Billy Hartung
Jackson Macrae
Josh Saunders
Leigh Adams
Levi Greenwood
Liam Anthony
Luke Ball
Luke Russell
Max Duffy
Nathan Foley
Nathan Gordon
Nick Graham
Reece Conca
Tony Armstrong
Troy Menzel
Zac O'Brien
 
Last edited:
Spitta2Azza, thanks very much for your hard work in these threads. We do appreciate the time and effort that goes into them and they certainly make the main board a better place.

Have a rainbow. :rainbow:
 
FB: A.Rance - D.Talia - H.Taylor
HB: B.Smith - E.Mackenzie - ???
C: J.Lewis - J.Selwood - J.Kennedy (SYD)
HF: R.Gray - L.Franklin - B.Harvey
FF: H.Ballantyne - J.Kennedy (WCE) - L.Parker
R: ??? - T.Rockliff - G.Ablett
I: N.Riewoldt - N.Fyfe - S.Sidebottom
S: D.Giansiracusa

That's everyone who made 5 Teams of the Week or more as well as Gia who was the only multiple SUB with 3.

Blanks to be filled from the groups named 4 times or less as you see fit. 3 Rucks tied on 3 games - Sandi, Mummy and Jacobs. Plenty of HBF options in the 4 game group.
 
Last edited:
Rating Selwood and Sloane for their 'performances' against Brisbane and St.Kilda - games that were meaningless against mediocre opposition - above Robbie Gray, who had 33 possesions, 4 marks, 9 clearances and 2 goals in a cut throat game for 4th against Fremantle in Perth is absolutely ludicrous. Like mind boggling bad.
 
Rating Selwood and Sloane for their 'performances' against Brisbane and St.Kilda - games that were meaningless against mediocre opposition - above Robbie Gray, who had 33 possesions, 4 marks, 9 clearances and 2 goals in a cut throat game for 4th against Fremantle in Perth is absolutely ludicrous. Like mind boggling bad.
It is one mans opinion and he has eliminated as much bias as possible.
 
Rating Selwood and Sloane for their 'performances' against Brisbane and St.Kilda - games that were meaningless against mediocre opposition - above Robbie Gray, who had 33 possesions, 4 marks, 9 clearances and 2 goals in a cut throat game for 4th against Fremantle in Perth is absolutely ludicrous. Like mind boggling bad.

The problem is where does it end?

Once you start taking account 'intangibles' it becomes very confusing. Where are the 'good team' cutoffs? How does a fight for top 4 game compared to a top 8 game numerically? Do milestone games count? Is Lenny Hayes milestone game more important then a Chris Newman milestone game?

Before you know it you end up like Rory.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top