kane249
Wibble
- Oct 27, 2006
- 52,157
- 68,899
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Sth Freo, Liverpool, Chicago Bulls
Disect the corpse here
Analysis The Good, the Bad and the Fugly Vs Shemantle round 3
- Thread starter kane249
- Start date
- Tagged users None
HoneyBadger35
The Big Kahuna
- Aug 11, 2011
- 26,515
- 72,105
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Moderator
- #2
Good: it's over
Bad: we made the margin seem like it was almost a professional standard game, which is disgraceful and will have some patting themselves on the back. * this team, harden up, show some heart or * off.
Bad: we made the margin seem like it was almost a professional standard game, which is disgraceful and will have some patting themselves on the back. * this team, harden up, show some heart or * off.
- Apr 19, 2015
- 21
- 17
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Banned
- #3
Same s**t midfield for years.
Lots to be excited about.
Shuey is a 4th best midfielder at best. Soft.
The rest are real poo.
Lots to be excited about.
Shuey is a 4th best midfielder at best. Soft.
The rest are real poo.
Dagger5
Norm Smith Medallist
The fans at the game cheering on the events that occurred during junk time were nearly just as damning to me as the first half performance. Looks like a very flattering 30 point loss is very acceptable to them and now the club can wheel out the excuses with some justification. Eg. we were good in the second half, outscored Freo after quarter time, LeCras kicked 5 etc.
Positives:
- Nelson, the kid is something we lack in spades: talented and hungry for the contest. Going to be a keeper.
- Sheed, coming along very well and fought all day.
- LeCras and Kennedy - worked tirelessly despite utter dreck being served up from the midfield.
- Wellingham and Hill both came good as the game went on - it shows effort if not anything else.
- Gov - we love you. That is all.
Negatives:
- Masten shirks contact constantly. It's embarrassing.
- Priddis was nowhere to be seen, despite the stat sheet.
- I feel like I'll watch Shuey's whole career waiting for him to stand up in a clutch game, only for it never to happen.
- Lycett is down on confidence. I'm failing him as a sponsor clearly
- McGinnity, Butler, Rosa - all three of you are completely done.
- Nelson, the kid is something we lack in spades: talented and hungry for the contest. Going to be a keeper.
- Sheed, coming along very well and fought all day.
- LeCras and Kennedy - worked tirelessly despite utter dreck being served up from the midfield.
- Wellingham and Hill both came good as the game went on - it shows effort if not anything else.
- Gov - we love you. That is all.
Negatives:
- Masten shirks contact constantly. It's embarrassing.
- Priddis was nowhere to be seen, despite the stat sheet.
- I feel like I'll watch Shuey's whole career waiting for him to stand up in a clutch game, only for it never to happen.
- Lycett is down on confidence. I'm failing him as a sponsor clearly
- McGinnity, Butler, Rosa - all three of you are completely done.
West Coast Weasel
Club Legend
Good:
We can be flat track bullies next weekend
Sheed developing nicely
Nelson as well
Bad:
1st quarter, 2nd, 3rd, showing up to play in the 4th
That midfield, no accountability
Turbo injured
We can be flat track bullies next weekend
Sheed developing nicely
Nelson as well
Bad:
1st quarter, 2nd, 3rd, showing up to play in the 4th
That midfield, no accountability
Turbo injured
- Sep 28, 2009
- 23,169
- 32,547
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Reading FC
A serious question did Shuey play in the guts today? I only ever noticed him at HF or HB.
Shupe
Brownlow Medallist
- Jun 21, 2011
- 13,335
- 10,396
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Indianapolis Colts
We lined up with McGinnity and Priddis at a centre bounce. Are we tanking already?
The main concern for me was a complete and utter lack of aggression. Freo were hunting our ball carriers in numbers. We were throwing out the most lazy arm tackles I've seen in some time. And when we did get there in numbers, somehow the Freo players are superhuman and able to get through three tacklers. Put pressure in the ball carrier in you will always be in the game.
We certainly didn't come prepared for the contest today.
The main concern for me was a complete and utter lack of aggression. Freo were hunting our ball carriers in numbers. We were throwing out the most lazy arm tackles I've seen in some time. And when we did get there in numbers, somehow the Freo players are superhuman and able to get through three tacklers. Put pressure in the ball carrier in you will always be in the game.
We certainly didn't come prepared for the contest today.
- Apr 10, 2012
- 1,222
- 1,440
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Dat 1st Quarter.
- Aug 22, 2009
- 24,445
- 28,080
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Good: Sheed was ok and we only lost by 5 goals.
Bad: everything else.
Bad: everything else.
You know you have problems when Kennedy gets the most inside 50's
The Good:
- I didn't get to see the game.
- I am drunk
The Bad
- At some point I will sober up.
- I didn't get to see the game.
- I am drunk
The Bad
- At some point I will sober up.
I think Kennedy should be played at CHF if we use 2 ruckmen.
Good - ummmm
Bad - how much time you got?
Bad - how much time you got?
HoneyBadger35
The Big Kahuna
- Aug 11, 2011
- 26,515
- 72,105
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Moderator
- #15
Not necessarily.
- Mar 20, 2007
- 28,259
- 24,781
- AFL Club
- West Coast
I got 9/9 footy tips, and was 2 points off potentially winning a share of 10k
Negatives:
That game was so much worse than the final score line suggests. Was essentially a 100 flogging to me.
Shuey was pretty crap looked like he lacked effort.
Yeo hasn't looked to have improved from last year, we need him too.
Mcgovern possibly injured - Legit kill me if he's out.
First half pressure was non existent countless freo players just jogging in open space.
Our clearance work was abysmal even though NN was good.
Lycett had some poor efforts
Hurn had a bit of a stinker.
Sheppard and Masten are continuously weak at the contest and lose pivotal CP's or slip tackles.
Felt like Simpson made some bad calls tonight.
So many more I won't mention.
Positives:
Nelson, kid definitely has what it takes but we already knew that.
McGovern really is god.
Our fowardline effort was actually good from all players and as a unit. They just weren't given s**t by our midfield. Cripps and hill were actually quite good I thought and will be underrated. Even mginnity was better than normal. Lecras obviously with his 5 was the best.
Schofield tried manfully I thought, and kept pav goaless when we got thumped.
Can't think of anyone in the midfield today who was above average.
That game was so much worse than the final score line suggests. Was essentially a 100 flogging to me.
Shuey was pretty crap looked like he lacked effort.
Yeo hasn't looked to have improved from last year, we need him too.
Mcgovern possibly injured - Legit kill me if he's out.
First half pressure was non existent countless freo players just jogging in open space.
Our clearance work was abysmal even though NN was good.
Lycett had some poor efforts
Hurn had a bit of a stinker.
Sheppard and Masten are continuously weak at the contest and lose pivotal CP's or slip tackles.
Felt like Simpson made some bad calls tonight.
So many more I won't mention.
Positives:
Nelson, kid definitely has what it takes but we already knew that.
McGovern really is god.
Our fowardline effort was actually good from all players and as a unit. They just weren't given s**t by our midfield. Cripps and hill were actually quite good I thought and will be underrated. Even mginnity was better than normal. Lecras obviously with his 5 was the best.
Schofield tried manfully I thought, and kept pav goaless when we got thumped.
Can't think of anyone in the midfield today who was above average.
Tom Kerrigan
Cancelled
A weird positive for me was Josh Hill kicking his 2 goals in the second and third quarters, not in the 4th where all the eagles players joined in the 'respectability goals'. If he can do his occasional good things when we actually need it instead of before or after like usual I'd like him in instead of McGinnity, yes he's soft but he can kick.
Oh and McGovern can have my babies
Oh and McGovern can have my babies
Bottom line: Fremantle have superior players, superior coaches and a superior gameplan. Outside the lack of height in defense, we lost clearances 44 to 26 with most of ours coming in junk time. Basically we need three new inside midfielders who can actually win the ball because right now we don't have a single one who can compete with the best. We were spoiled for years with Judd and Kerr - who were never replaced.
Carbine Chaos
The Gaff-er
- Apr 1, 2009
- 63,939
- 94,249
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth FC, Everton, Delhi
The only big positive is because of Geelong holding on and this, I am $133 richer. Not bad for a first time betting.
Sheed was okay. I actually thought Wellingham played one of his better games for the club. Nelson looked at home as well. McGovern played well until he went down. Le Cras is a good finisher. Hill showed a bit and he's certainly handy depth, I wouldn't be delisting him.
The negatives have been covered already.
Sheed was okay. I actually thought Wellingham played one of his better games for the club. Nelson looked at home as well. McGovern played well until he went down. Le Cras is a good finisher. Hill showed a bit and he's certainly handy depth, I wouldn't be delisting him.
The negatives have been covered already.
- Oct 8, 2007
- 13,374
- 9,051
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- FLO-RIDA , PITBULL ,SEAN PAUL
The good : Not giving up and rolling over
The bad : Bringing no intensity to a derby ,foot skills , turnovers , Dumb football
The ugly : Magovern injury
The bad : Bringing no intensity to a derby ,foot skills , turnovers , Dumb football
The ugly : Magovern injury
HoneyBadger35
The Big Kahuna
- Aug 11, 2011
- 26,515
- 72,105
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Moderator
- #22
First thing we covered all day.
- Banned
- #23
Kids were good.
Lecras and a few others were OK.
The rest was s**t. Mcginnity, Rosa, wellingham, priddis, shephard, masten all poor, slow, s**t disposal, s**t decision making. Drop all of them.
Lycett needs a rocket or the threat of delisting.
Duggan doesn't count.
Lecras and a few others were OK.
The rest was s**t. Mcginnity, Rosa, wellingham, priddis, shephard, masten all poor, slow, s**t disposal, s**t decision making. Drop all of them.
Lycett needs a rocket or the threat of delisting.
Duggan doesn't count.
- Aug 27, 2014
- 1,610
- 1,918
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Masten is just as big a problem for our midfield development as Priddis. Even when masten plays a 'good' game i hardly notice him. Might be a little reactionary put fck he's bad. No heart, no pace, no size ffs
+
josh hill chased Stephan hill at one stage,got there just as he kicked,bloody good chase tho.he kept trying throughout the match
McGovern still standing tall
the last half.we kept plugging away,it got real ugly early on
_
we didn't draft to cover our deficiencies-speed and skill
constantly missing the target by foot
the first half,mostly the first quarter-total shell shock,no leg speed,no skill
josh hill chased Stephan hill at one stage,got there just as he kicked,bloody good chase tho.he kept trying throughout the match
McGovern still standing tall
the last half.we kept plugging away,it got real ugly early on
_
we didn't draft to cover our deficiencies-speed and skill
constantly missing the target by foot
the first half,mostly the first quarter-total shell shock,no leg speed,no skill
Similar threads
