Nostradamus Lives Tom Boyd Wants Out

[Colonial]

Way to torpedo their hopes and dreams.

So we should be bent over?
If and its a big IF he wants to go, fair enough. But why should the giants take it in the deal? We should get and will get a decent paycheque wether it be a player or picks.

 

[Cynic]

So we should be bent over?
If and its a big IF he wants to go, fair enough. But why should the giants take it in the deal? We should get and will get a decent paycheque wether it be a player or picks.

So what would be reasonable? Pick 5 and...wow Carlton don't really have a lot of trade bait do they looking at their list...

 

[The 747]

So what would be reasonable? Pick 5 and...wow Carlton don't really have a lot of trade bait do they looking at their list...

Apparently pick 5 + Andrew Walker + Andrew Walker's hat is reasonable, say CFC fans.

 

[Cynic]

Apparently pick 5 + Andrew Walker + Andrew Walker's hat is reasonable, say CFC fans.

It is a good hat...

 

[pinot]

So we should be bent over?
If and its a big IF he wants to go, fair enough. But why should the giants take it in the deal? We should get and will get a decent paycheque wether it be a player or picks.

Boyd will refuse to go to any other club and he will refuse to sign another GWS contract I am quietly confident Boyd is a Carlton player in principle it depends if GWS wish to trade for him this season or lose him for nothing next season.

 

[Colonial]

Boyd will refuse to go to any other club and he will refuse to sign another GWS contract I am quietly confident Boyd is a Carlton player in principle it depends if GWS wish to trade for him this season or lose him for nothing next season.

Was under the impression if you go to psd you cant refuse jackshit.

 

[dazbroncos]

Carlton will make a play for him (not sure what) but Boyd definitely wants to be a Carlton player he is desperate. If GWS and Carlton can strike a deal based on players preference then that's fine but Carlton will definitely make a big play for Boyd..maybe pick 5 + Garlett.

You do understand that trading is a get to give principle. I reckon that GWS are WAY overvaluing some of their picks but Garlett and #5 for Boyd is , well dreaming….

Go Catters

 

[etsal1]

You do understand that trading is a get to give principle. I reckon that GWS are WAY overvaluing some of their picks but Garlett and #5 for Boyd is , well dreaming….

Go Catters

Ignore pinot. Even I think he's trolling by suggesting Garlett + pick 5 will get GWS to even pick up the phone.

 

[dazbroncos]

Sounds like umm..... Jack Watts yeah? The overrating of draft picks is incredible. Name 1 number 1 pick currently preforming better than Dayne Beams.

Joel Selwood - and he was #7.

Go Catters

 

[pinot]

Was under the impression if you go to psd you cant refuse jackshit.

Players have a choice - Judd is a good example. All it takes is a fair deal

 

[The 747]

Players have a choice - Judd is a good example. All it takes is a fair deal

As others have pointed out, you dont really have the currency to offer a fair deal.

 

[pinot]

You do understand that trading is a get to give principle. I reckon that GWS are WAY overvaluing some of their picks but Garlett and #5 for Boyd is , well dreaming….

Go Catters

I don't think so - Garlett is a 50 goal a season small forward per year + pick 5. Ignore etsal1 he just likes bending over.

 

[etsal1]

I don't think so - Garlett is a 50 goal a season small forward per year + pick 5. Ignore etsal1 he just likes bending over.

Firstly, Garlett's never kicked 50 goals in a season before.

Secondly, I'm no he.

 

[dazbroncos]

I don't think so - Garlett is a 50 goal a season small forward per year + pick 5. Ignore etsal1 he just likes bending over.

That is awesome then. My assessment of what Cats players will get on the market based on that will skyrocket.
Boyd to Geelong next!

Go Catters

 

[pinot]

As others have pointed out, you dont really have the currency to offer a fair deal.

Then we get him for nothing.

 

[The 747]

Then we get him for nothing.

Dreams are nice

 

[pinot]

Firstly, Garlett's never kicked 50 goals in a season before.

Secondly, I'm no he.

Pedantics...he's kicked 48, 43, 39 per year in four full seasons/

 

[dazbroncos]

Firstly, Garlett's never kicked 50 goals in a season before.

Secondly, I'm no he.

but is that Garlett before or after the Whack last week…..

Go Catters

 

[pinot]

Dreams are nice

That's what everyone said when we were going after Judd

 

[etsal1]

but is that Garlett before or after the Whack last week…..

Go Catters

Either.

 

[The 747]

That's what everyone said when we were going after Judd

Mmm yep and you paid pick 3, pick 20 and a promising KPF for him.

 

[etsal1]

Pedantics...he's kicked 48, 43, 39 per year in four full seasons/

and how many games has he played this year for a pretty crap team?

 

[etsal1]

Mmm yep and you paid pick 3, pick 20 and a promising KPF for him.

to be fair, WCE did burn pick 20. So it's more like pick 3 & Kennedy

 

[pinot]

Mmm yep and you paid pick 3, pick 20 and a promising KPF for him.

Judd was the best player in the competition - Boyd is far from that. Logic not much of a strength?

 

[The 747]

Judd was the best player in the competition - Boyd is far from that. Logic not much of a strength?

Nevermind mate. You'll get him for nothing, in fact he will play for nothing so you dont even incur salary cap. Blues gonna be awesome.