Carlton need much more than one high draft pick. They would be better off trading their first round for multiple picks and possibly using one of these on Aish. Carlton have already gone the pick 1 route and wound up with Murphy, Gibbs and Kruezer (what a cringworthy list for pick 1s). They really should go the scatter gun approach to improve their chances.
Trade hypotheticals (2015 version)
- Thread starter thetradesman
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Carlton need much more than one high draft pick. They would be better off trading their first round for multiple picks and possibly using one of these on Aish. Carlton have already gone the pick 1 route and wound up with Murphy, Gibbs and Kruezer (what a cringworthy list for pick 1s). They really should go the scatter gun approach to improve their chances.
- Aug 3, 2014
- 16,559
- 24,072
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- New England Patriots, Man City
- Banned
- #727
We're not going to get pick 1, way its going, we'll end up with pick 4 or 5.
Also those 3 number 1 picks you listed aren't exactly no 1 duds like Clive Waterhouse, Drew Banfield or Jack Watts ..
They're not duds at all but they're not worth winning a spoon, having a dreadful season and putting all your hopes onto those players. Carlton should trade in their first round for 2 first round picks and really have a go at the draft. Everyone wants to have the highest pick possible but history shows that the whole first round is a gamble as they haven't physically matured.
Aish = talented player , has question marks over application and desire , few injuries over the season , hasn't shown any progress over this season.
I would not expect a similar return on what bris paid for him. There is more question marks over him now then there was as a draftee.
Still would be a bargain for a team who thinks that maybe he can stay fit , change his attitude , and build on his form.
No team outside the 8 is going to part with their first round pick for him when they would probably consider him closer in value to their early 2nd rounder. A team like that may push for that rather than a first round pick. Bris would hope he chooses a team in the eight , whose 2nd round pick is quite late , and his value is worth closer to their first , but even Collingwood may be hesitant to part with their first im not sure.
It all depends on who he chooses , but you imagine bris would be pretty steadfast about it being a top 25 pick. If they can may be able to sway two mid picks ie , rather than one high pick , and for the first time that has value to a team bidding on a player or players.
I would not expect a similar return on what bris paid for him. There is more question marks over him now then there was as a draftee.
Still would be a bargain for a team who thinks that maybe he can stay fit , change his attitude , and build on his form.
No team outside the 8 is going to part with their first round pick for him when they would probably consider him closer in value to their early 2nd rounder. A team like that may push for that rather than a first round pick. Bris would hope he chooses a team in the eight , whose 2nd round pick is quite late , and his value is worth closer to their first , but even Collingwood may be hesitant to part with their first im not sure.
It all depends on who he chooses , but you imagine bris would be pretty steadfast about it being a top 25 pick. If they can may be able to sway two mid picks ie , rather than one high pick , and for the first time that has value to a team bidding on a player or players.
yaco55
Hall of Famer
There will no discount because of CAS - Clubs will only trade for a player if they are confident player will be available in 2016 - Finally if players are found guilty there will be no 2 year penalties - Two years is the maximum and once you factor in discounts,players having already served provisional suspensions of over 4 months, and players likely to do the same in the off-season.
yaco55
Hall of Famer
Absolutely true - But worth it as a FA.
- Sep 13, 2013
- 31,411
- 28,204
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Juventus
Or height
- Aug 20, 2013
- 2,551
- 3,256
Aish will become an elite AFL footballer. If (when) he leaves Brisbane, I hope they get compensated accordingly.
Sent from my HTC_0PJA10 using Tapatalk
Sent from my HTC_0PJA10 using Tapatalk
- Aug 20, 2013
- 2,551
- 3,256
Unfortunately for Lions fans, his current value is significantly less than what his future value will prove to be.
Last edited:
- May 16, 2013
- 5,172
- 7,165
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Don't mind this idea. He's being wasted as a lock down type up there right now and Eade clearly doesn't value him over muchly, having dropped him after Round 1, so a second or third is probably about right. He would be great for us on a wing or half back. Someone email Bryce Lewis, we're on a winner here.
North fans suggesting we could get a first round pick for Black - even a late first rounder - need a reality check. As a general rule, you are never going to get a first round pick for a player who is stuck in the twos. We'd be looking at a second rounder more than likely and yes, that's probably less than what Black is worth, but it's not about what a player is worth, it's about what you can get for them.
The reality is we won't trade Black unless he asks for it. And if he asks for it, we will pretty much have to take what we can get.
Lol they've played since provisional suspensions so they wont count.
Also pretty sure there wont be any discounts as the players have offered 0 support to the investigation.
These players trade value is less - you have to come to terms with this.
yaco55
Hall of Famer
Mate
I have suggested that no clubs should look at trading in players from Essendon - Who as a list manager would trade in a player who will CERTAINLY get a two year ban from WADA - Reckon the list managers need to seek your counsel.
Agreed ,
Could make Carlisle via the PSD possible ?
No trade outlay , so if he cops a ban you can just treat it as a LTI .
Brad McKenzie for Trent McKenzie? Prob need to chuck in a 3rd rounder?
eth-dog
Tier 1 WW Player
Yeah, something like that. Don't see North's need for someone like McKenzie though tbh.
Super Hans
marcus proudson
10k Posts
Pokemon is Life
SuperCoach Club Board Championship League Member
- Apr 27, 2009
- 23,370
- 28,292
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- TrailBlazers, Juventus, Raiders
Adelaide get: Aish
Adelaide lose: First pick
Brisbane get: Talia, Adelaide's first round pick
Brisbane lose: Aish, second round pick
Bulldogs get: Brisbane's second round pick
Bulldogs lose: Talia
Thoughts?
Adelaide lose: First pick
Brisbane get: Talia, Adelaide's first round pick
Brisbane lose: Aish, second round pick
Bulldogs get: Brisbane's second round pick
Bulldogs lose: Talia
Thoughts?
- Aug 16, 2010
- 10,057
- 6,940
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
We have enough young defenders in Clarke Paparone Andrews and Gardiner we also have Hipwood coming this year
Why would Crows trade Talia?
- Aug 16, 2010
- 10,057
- 6,940
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
I think he means Michael Talia Bulldogs defender and Daniel's brother
Oh right. My mistake
Seems fair to me but might be overs for Talia. Perhaps a swap of 3rd rounders as well?
thetradesman
Norm Smith Medallist
- Sep 15, 2013
- 7,503
- 3,165
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Browns, Clips, Renegades
- Thread starter
- #747
Motlop is an interesting one, wouldn't give up our first pick for him tbh.
Lizard Lukin
Debutant
- Jun 21, 2015
- 68
- 43
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Will probably end up at Hawthorn for their first rder.
Would gladly give up 1st rd for Motlop
thetradesman
Norm Smith Medallist
- Sep 15, 2013
- 7,503
- 3,165
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Browns, Clips, Renegades
- Thread starter
- #750
Your first round will probably be a top 8 pick, no way North would trade that for Motlop.
Similar threads
- Locked
- Poll
