Training Report - 12/02

[TradeDraft]

Which is why I said Propably intra club and most likely nab 3, he won't need a lot to get his eye back in

But him doing a Full Match Simulation makes it sound he is Closer then some people might think he is

 

[Hardas]

But him doing a Full Match Simulation makes it sound he is Closer then some people might think he is

It's definitely reassuring that he's clearly progressing.

 

[TradeDraft]

It's definitely reassuring that he's clearly progressing.

Sure Is and Glad to hear he is not just Running. Hopefully he has no Set-Backs

 

[Soaring Magpie]

But him doing a Full Match Simulation makes it sound he is Closer then some people might think he is

No doubt it's a great sign, and I'm confident he'll be right to go Rd1 but don't think he'll be pushed much during nab. Match simulation is totally different to match practice against genuine opposition

 

[Jelly Bean]

Which is why I said Propably intra club and most likely nab 3, he won't need a lot to get his eye back in

I'd be surprised if he didn't play all three NAB Cup games based on what I saw today.

 

[ClaytonM]

Asking who we'd like for the Half-time entertainment at the Grand Final, obviously

Redgum

 

[TradeDraft]

No doubt it's a great sign, and I'm confident he'll be right to go Rd1 but don't think he'll be pushed much during nab. Match simulation is totally different to match practice against genuine opposition

That is why I said for at least the 1st 1 he play a Half then Subbed or just play the 2nd Half

 

[lyfsux]

Why would Gil be at our Training Session?

The hand over worked so well between MM and Bucks they are preparing for the Gil, Eddie change over

 

[Buckley is my hero]

Asking who we'd like for the Half-time entertainment at the Grand Final, obviously

Or lining up his next job if the coaching gig at Collingwood doesn't work out.

 

[Soaring Magpie]

I'd be surprised if he didn't play all three NAB Cup games based on what I saw today.

I just wouldn't be surprised if the club are quite cautious with him, no matter how well he is doing on the training track

 

[TradeDraft]

I just wouldn't be surprised if the club are quite cautious with him

They can be Cautious and still play NAB Challenge but playing him in 1 Half

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

I just wouldn't be surprised if the club are quite cautious with him, no matter how well he is doing on the training track

If they've been cautious with him until now, holding him back from match practice or full training until his injury is 100% healed, why would they need to be cautious with him from here?

If he was 100%, then he'd be as likely to play the whole NAB Cup as any other healthy player on our list.

 

[Soaring Magpie]

If they've been cautious with him until now, holding him back from match practice or full training until his injury is 100% healed, why would they need to be cautious with him from here?

If he was 100%, then he'd be as likely to play the whole NAB Cup as any other healthy player on our list.

Because he has had a modified preseason, I'd expect that to continue whilst easing him into full competition.

 

[Soaring Magpie]

They can be Cautious and still play NAB Challenge but playing him in 1 Half

It is what I'm saying, he will play a nab game, I just don't expect it to be till the 3rd game. At the earliest it will be for a 1/2 of nab 2.
I'd put money on him not lining up nab 1.

 

[TradeDraft]

It is what I'm saying, he will play a nab game, I just don't expect it to be till the 3rd game. At the earliest it will be for a 1/2 of nab 2.
I'd put money on him not lining up nab 1.

Then why are they have him doing Full Match Simulation now?

 

[Soaring Magpie]

Then why are they have him doing Full Match Simulation now?

For the first time today!!!!!
Bit easier to work his way into full fitness during intra club stuff than against opposition.
Can you imagine to outcry from supporters if Treloar was to injury a groin during nab 1??
Seriously not worth risking him in early nab games

 

[Soaring Magpie]

Then why are they have him doing Full Match Simulation now?

Sounds like you are getting very anxious and excited to seeing him run out in the B&W

 

[TradeDraft]

Sounds like you are getting very anxious and excited to seeing him run out in the B&W

I expect I am not the only One

 

[TradeDraft]

For the first time today!!!!!
Bit easier to work his way into full fitness during intra club stuff than against opposition.
Can you imagine to outcry from supporters if Treloar was to injury a groin during nab 1??
Seriously not worth risking him in early nab games

He played a bit last week

 

[Mkcaptain]

I can't see Treloar playing against Geelong. He could play a bit in the intraclub but even that is a big step up from match practice at training.

 

[Smoky]

Hey Jelly Bean...

What percentage of time did Swan play forward?

 

[rand corp]

Thanks for the great report much appreciated

 

[Soaring Magpie]

I expect I am not the only One

And I'm guessing you won't be happy if he does a groin in nab1?
He has only just got back to joining main training group, it's not about nab1 it's about being ready to go against the swans

 

[NT.Thunder]

I just wouldn't be surprised if the club are quite cautious with him, no matter how well he is doing on the training track

I think he needs game time in a new team. If he was here for 12 months already, fine, rest him but I'd think he may need a few runs with more for team cohesion and understanding than fitness

 

[Apex36]

And I'm guessing you won't be happy if he does a groin in nab1?
He has only just got back to joining main training group, it's not about nab1 it's about being ready to go against the swans

Generally if a player starts participating in full training it means they're good to go in matches. It may be that he's under instruction to only go at 75% if he plays NAB just to be safe, but given the amount of preseason match drills etc he's missed, I'd be surprised if they kept him out of NAB cup, purely on the basis that he needs all the match practice he can get to gel with his new team mates through the midfield.