Injury Injury list Rnd 23 (latest Davoren is safe)

[rustyg70]

Yep

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk

Thought so.
Looks like we will be eating Waguu Steak for a while.

 

[PepperFace]

Thought so.
Looks like we will be eating Waguu Steak for a while.

Ironic that krak probably got delisted because he was overtaken as our small forward by Elliot

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk

 

[Kilmo]

Wasn't Elliott the steak knives in the Krakouer deal??

No, that was Ceglar who was traded from the Suns.
We traded pick 25 to GWS for Marty Clarke and Elliott, who they had pre-listed with their weird pre-listing ability of that off season.

 

[PepperFace]

No, that was Ceglar who was traded from the Suns.
We traded pick 25 to GWS for Marty Clarke and Elliott, who they had pre-listed with their weird pre-listing ability of that off season.

That is in fact right....my mistake in the earlier posts

Sent from my GT-I9300T using Tapatalk

 

[Number 10]

Didn't Brown and Dwyer both play in the VFL on Saturday? Not sure how their names can be on the injury list if they actually both played a couple of days ago.

As for Reid, I'd nearly put money on it that he doesn't come back until after the bye. No point rushing him back for the Blues in round 7. Therefore he might have a run in the VFL in early May and then come back into AFL for round 9, May 15 vs Crows.

Broomhead, never heard of shin splints keeping a player out from playing. I've actually played with shin splints for nearly half a season years ago, so it's possible. I would question the validity of shin splints as the actual reason/injury as to why he's not playing.

I think you are misguided, you obviously had very minor shin splints as it can vary a lot.

I have had shin splints and was out for most the season as it caused stress fractures. Similar to josh Thomas'.

It can vary but the more you push it the worse it gets and it can turn into a major problem. Best to be safe

 

[Manic Magpie]

You think its a plan?

How else do you explain it?

 

[blaze036]

How else do you explain it?

I don't think we planned for Freeman to tear his hamstring tendon or Grundy to develop a stress fracture, or broomhead to get glandular ect.

Scharenberg is really the only one and that was a unique case

 

[3kicks3goals]

Broomhead, never heard of shin splints keeping a player out from playing. I've actually played with shin splints for nearly half a season years ago, so it's possible. I would question the validity of shin splints as the actual reason/injury as to why he's not playing.

Shin splints can actually refer to a number of different injuries in the same area. Like you I've had a manageable version of it, but it can be very severe from what I understand.

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk

 

[Collingwood HQ]

Broomhead, never heard of shin splints keeping a player out from playing. I've actually played with shin splints for nearly half a season years ago, so it's possible. I would question the validity of shin splints as the actual reason/injury as to why he's not playing.

The pain of shin splints may vary from person to person, I played with it last year and had to take a few weeks off mid season as I was struggling to run it was extremely uncomfortable. hopefully Broomheads aren't to bad because even when I came back they gave me grief for the rest of the season.

 

[esc0bar]

the curse continues at Carlton while our injury woes are improving... While i will not blame Buffient, I think a fresh fitness coach was needed at the Pies.

 

[piedpiper32]

COLLINGWOOD

Marley Williams available

 

[peter9789]

Things are looking up for a change - and great to see players having to earn their place via the VFL


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Kilmo]

How else do you explain it?

Explain what? Disease?
A broken hand in a high intensity football match?
An enormous 18 year old with growing pains?

 

[DaVe86]

I'm not concerned about Freeman and Scharenberg. They are first year players and i hope we go very slowly with them.

Really looking forwrd to Reid, Seedsman, Sinclair and Marley Williams been available. Sinclair isn't best 22, but he is a gutsy little defender and is good depth.

Also looking forward to Broomhead getting stuck into it and Karnezis keeping on getting fitter.

Really starting to look good for the pies now.

 

[BringbackHarry]

I'm not concerned about Freeman and Scharenberg. They are first year players and i hope we go very slowly with them.

Really looking forwrd to Reid, Seedsman, Sinclair and Marley Williams been available. Sinclair isn't best 22, but he is a gutsy little defender and is good depth.

Sinclair looks to have turned the corner, I'd use him as the super sub where his speed could be really damaging with the heat off the game.. he's also got the flexibility to play back forward or midfield

 

[DaicosianMarvels]

Our depth goes much deeper this year then it did in 10/11 except we don't have the oldish experienced guys pushed outside of the team to use as depth.

In 2010/11 we had Lockeyer, Fraser, Obree and Medhurst all playing 2s footy but that was all our depth basically but this year our depth is much more even and goes a lot more deeper. We have two top 10 picks whohaven't played a game yet and we are fine with out of them at most other clubs their two top 10 picks would be playing every game that year and here we are thinking that once they are fit and ready they are still going to find it tough to get a game for us with a full and fit list to choose from.

It's exciting times down at the Westpac Center, it's really going to be an exciting year as long as that injury list stays small.

 

[Manic Magpie]

Explain what? Disease?
A broken hand in a high intensity football match?
An enormous 18 year old with growing pains?

It seems I need to make more use of emoticons.

 

[Seedsfan]

Ben Reid has been 1-2 weeks all year FFS.

 

[BringbackHarry]

As of Tuesday 22 April 2014

Tim Broomhead - Shin splints - Test
Paul Seedsman - Hip - Test
Adam Oxley - Ankle - 1 week
Ben Reid - Calf - 1/2 weeks
Ben Sinclair - Hamstring - 1/2 weeks
Nathan Freeman - Hamstring - 3 weeks
Matthew Scharenberg - Feet - Indefinite

http://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/season/injury-list

 

[piedpiper32]

Ben Reid has been 1-2 weeks all year FFS.

Didn't you previously tell Reid to "harden the f*ck up"? LOL

 

[MyManLynch]

Ben Reid has been 1-2 weeks all year FFS.

I think they will rest Reid until after the bye.

 

[Baird]

Nathan Freeman 3 weeks? See you in 2019, Nat.

 

[Old Spice]

We seem to be making a habit of drafting with our first selections players who spend a large slice of their first season sidelined with injury.

We took Scharenberg in full knowledge of his foot condition. In fact we might be thanking Jebus that he had them in two years time because that was what allowed him to slide to us. Don't know about Grundy's back issues last year but may be another case of the same.

That's what having a stable club allows you. To take a short-term hit for the longer term benefit. Thank God the club isn't run by week-to-week panic merchants.

 

[motr]

Wasn't Elliott the steak knives in the Krakouer deal??

Part of the deal with GWS to get Marty Clarke back on the list. Elliot was never the steak knives.

 

[Kilmo]

Ben Reid has been 1-2 weeks all year FFS.

I think for a while it has been clear that they won't risk him playing any footy until after the bye, no point bringing him back for the Carlton game, he already hurt them enough last year.