1. Tip the first round of the 2014 AFL National Draft and you win a share of $2500!

    Click for the full details and entry thread.

Varcoe or Garlett

Discussion in 'Polls Board' started by toeknee2, Feb 28, 2012.

Put it out there
  1. toeknee2

    toeknee2 Senior List

    Carlton
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    Jan 08
    Posts:
    224
    Location:
    northcote
    I'm Carlton so I won't vote.
     

    (Log in to remove this ad.)

  2. StringyDog

    StringyDog Party Pieman

    Western Bulldogs
    Other teams:
    Van Canucks, Cin Bengals
    Joined:
    Oct 07
    Posts:
    6,109
    Location:
    The Church of Honey
    Varcoe is certainly more talented but have a feeling Garlett will produce more consistently come the end of their careers.
     
  3. barmyarmy

    barmyarmy Debutant

    Carlton
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    Dec 10
    Posts:
    100
    I will take buddy's cousin any day of the week :)
     
  4. donbooger

    donbooger Club Legend

    Geelong
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    Sep 07
    Posts:
    1,148
    Location:
    werribee
    I think Varcoe should be the better player but he has kept teasing for a few years now, playing like dynamite a few weeks and then fading away.

    While he stagnates Garlett kicked 17 more goals while playing 24 games apiece. I am not giving up hope on Varcoe's potential in the years to come but for now I have to be honest and side with those 17 additional goals, so Garlett for me.
     
  5. a_fighting_fury

    a_fighting_fury Club Legend

    Richmond
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    May 07
    Posts:
    2,114
    Location:
    Yarra Park
    Garlett has an x-factor that I havent seen in Varcoe.
     
  6. Hodgepodge

    Hodgepodge Hall of Famer

    Hawthorn
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    Apr 08
    Posts:
    45,918
    Location:
    Erin Riley's air mattress
    Varcoe gets a lot of cheap stats that flatter his actual performances. Garlett easily.
     
  7. Jeremias

    Jeremias Moderator

    Carlton
    Other teams:
    MUFC, LAL, PSG, Cameroon
    Joined:
    Sep 04
    Posts:
    26,549
    Location:
    Top 4
    I really rate Varcoe, but I'd take Garlett.

    Certainly more talented? :confused:

    That's a baffling statement.
     
  8. ManOfClay

    ManOfClay Premium Platinum

    Western Bulldogs
    Other teams:
    Memphis Grizzlies
    Joined:
    Jan 12
    Posts:
    7,414
    Location:
    On the couch
    Garlett doesn't do anything in big games. Or even games where things don't go Carlton's way.

    Will never see him put in a Varcoe-like grand final performance.
     
  9. Monkey King

    Monkey King Brownlow Medallist

    Carlton
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    Jan 07
    Posts:
    20,082
    Location:
    Melbourne
    What do you base this on exactly? Garlett scored 5.3 & had 3 goal assists in his two finals last year - both above his H&A average. The year before he had four shots on goal for 2.2 in Carlton's only final and had his last kick in the dying seconds been half a metre to the left, it would have been the match winning goal. Furthermore, from Garlett's top 10 performances according to Champion Data last season, 3 of them came in losses out of a total 7 Carlton lost matches, so ...

    There are cliches in footy - goes missing in big games, doesn't win enough hardball, has poor disposal - and some posters it seems, just rattle these off in hope, or are you just basing your comment on last year's WB Carlton match?


    As for the OP, I'm going with Garlett on output. I think Varcoe has greater potential to impact around the ground, which could well elevate him above Jeffy; but as at right now, Garlett has been delivering more consistently on the scoreboard in a structurally challenged forward-line, he's a better mark and provides more defensive pressure on the ball coming out. Hard to go past him.
     
  10. HyperAgressiveDonk

    HyperAgressiveDonk Account Cancelled by User

    Hawthorn
    Other teams:
    City Middle & Angela Surf City
    Joined:
    Aug 08
    Posts:
    7,614
    Location:
    Red Moon
    I don't know if I agree entirely with this, but all the same Garlett is easily the better player like HP has stated.
     
  11. Hump 17

    Hump 17 Account Cancelled by User

    St Kilda
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    Jun 10
    Posts:
    2,361
    Location:
    Yarra Valley

    Varcoe by a fair way. Anyone who watched the GF last year will agree. Garletts not a bad player but not in the same class as Varcoe.
     

    (Log in to remove this ad.)

  12. Monkey King

    Monkey King Brownlow Medallist

    Carlton
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    Jan 07
    Posts:
    20,082
    Location:
    Melbourne
    And for those who watched all the other games too??? :cool:

    Fair enough anyone preferring Varcoe, but damn if I don't find some posters' reasoning just ridiculous. I think most of those who voted so far watched last years GF and quite a few don't agree with you yeah?
     
  13. Hump 17

    Hump 17 Account Cancelled by User

    St Kilda
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    Jun 10
    Posts:
    2,361
    Location:
    Yarra Valley
    Varcoe does it both ways can play midfield well and is more than your simple goal sneak. I dont mind Garlett just think Varcoe offers far more.

    As for the posters that dont agree a coulple of them are Hawthorn posters who dont rate Bartal.:eek:
     
  14. Monkey King

    Monkey King Brownlow Medallist

    Carlton
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    Jan 07
    Posts:
    20,082
    Location:
    Melbourne
    I'd say Jeffy is more than "your simple goal sneak" as well, but I don't disagree with your point of Varcoe's up the ground ability and have addressed that in an earlier post in this thread. It's consistency that brings Varcoe back into it IMO.

    My point regarding your post is that giving such hefty weightings to one game is just ridiculous and that there are plenty who would have watched that same game, but rate Garlett higher based on all the other games they've seen too.
     
  15. toeknee2

    toeknee2 Senior List

    Carlton
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    Jan 08
    Posts:
    224
    Location:
    northcote
    Turns out you have to vote in order to see the results even if you are the op.
     
  16. jonoman89

    jonoman89 Brownlow Medallist

    Carlton
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    Aug 07
    Posts:
    10,213
    Pretty stunning statement.

    2011 Semi v WCE: 9 touches, 2.1, 5 tackles
    2011 Elimination v Essendon: 16 touches, 3.2, 4 tackles
    2010 Elimination v Sydney: 16 touches, 2.2, 2 tackles
    2009 Elimination v Brisbane: 6 touches, 1 goal, 2 tackles

    Only one average game there (which was his first year). Small forwards don't get 30 touches a game....

    Jeff will continue improving. Best true small forward in the AFL.
     
  17. The Finger

    The Finger Premiership Player

    Melbourne
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    Sep 10
    Posts:
    4,423
    Location:
    Upwey
    Garlet isn't even the best small forward at Carlton let alone the league.
     
  18. pacman

    pacman Premiership Player

    Hawthorn
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    Mar 06
    Posts:
    3,135
    Location:
    Sunny Gold Coast
    Garlett for me, Varcoe is to wishywashy.
    Garlett might not be the best small fwd in the comp at the moment but he'll give it a good shake this year.
     
  19. muttweed

    muttweed Account Cancelled by User

    Geelong
    Other teams:
    Josh Caddy
    Joined:
    May 11
    Posts:
    3,399
    Location:
    Western VIC
    [youtube]kGASMeHhLKw[/youtube]

    Varcoe is such an important player to us. He may not kick too many goals or get too many touches, but he does so much running and he contests almost everything. He's always there to kick to.

    The above video is an example. I'm fascinated. I never rated him too highly, but after analysing some videos (including the above) I adore him.

    Garlett's super, never needed an explanation, and I don't think I can split them
     
  20. jonoman89

    jonoman89 Brownlow Medallist

    Carlton
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    Aug 07
    Posts:
    10,213
    Garlett is a better player than Betts. More consistent.
     
  21. neroblack

    neroblack Premiership Player

    Collingwood
    Other teams:
    Liverpool, Chicago Bulls
    Joined:
    Jul 11
    Posts:
    3,169
    Location:
    Berwick
    Garlett doesn't come close right now. Potential means little once you get to the top level, and right now Varcoe is a long way ahead..
     
  22. Son of God

    Son of God PREMIERS 07,09,'11

    Geelong
    Other teams:
    Canterbury Bulldogs, Royals , Crocs
    Joined:
    Feb 07
    Posts:
    23,463
    Location:
    On Top Of The World
    I think there fairly even at this stage of there careers, but i'd give the nod to Varcoe because he's played some decent games in the midfield and half back. Garlett is the better forward though. Probably too close to call in all seriousness but i think Varcoe will end up the better player when there careers are over.
     
  23. Hodgepodge

    Hodgepodge Hall of Famer

    Hawthorn
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    Apr 08
    Posts:
    45,918
    Location:
    Erin Riley's air mattress
    Garlett - double the tackles, almost double the goals. Varcoe doesn't work hard enough and relies on uncontested ball too often to ever become as consistent as Garlett.
     
  24. STC

    STC Norm Smith Medallist

    Geelong
    Other teams:
    Joined:
    Aug 04
    Posts:
    9,448
    Location:
    Melbourne
    Varcoe's workrate is as phenomenal as it is underrated - haven't seen Garlett run end to end, touching the ball several times to kick a crucial goal - and I'm not only talking about his GF goal either, he did pretty much the same thing in round 5 against Hawthorn. Still doesn't have the consistency I'll admit but not sure Garlett quite has it either.

    Maybe I'm biased, I rate both but I'm surprised anyone would honestly think Garlett is better. Varcoe is fitter, stronger and more versatile without a doubt, and they're both very skilled but I'd think Trav is a bit ahead. Garlett is more deadly in front of goals. If Varcoe was as confident as he is skilled, he'd be an elite midfielder. But I can't remember him ever lasting a whole preseason and I suspect that hurts a guy's confidence and consistency - it just makes it more surprising his gut running in 2011.
     
  25. muttweed

    muttweed Account Cancelled by User

    Geelong
    Other teams:
    Josh Caddy
    Joined:
    May 11
    Posts:
    3,399
    Location:
    Western VIC


    As opposed to Varcoe's last 4 finals.

    2010 preliminary final v Collingwood (we were thrashed, most of our players were crap):19 touches, 4 marks, *2 goals, 3 tackles, 5 inside 50s

    2011 qualifying final v Hawthorn:
    7 touches, 1 behind, 1 tackle, 1 goal assist, 5 inside 50s

    2011 preliminary final v WC: 12 touches, 3 marks, 2 goals, 2 behinds, 1 tackle, 1 inside 50


    2011 GF v Collingwood: 21 touches, 3 marks, 3 goals, 1 tackle, 2 inside 50s

    All that and a whole lot of hard running.

    PS, I'd consider Garlett's last final to be pretty average.

    And since when are Milne or Chapman not "true small forwards"? There is no such term. Selective much?