Competitions Vote for the 2015 Whipping Boy!

[FAITH]

all of the above

 

[Hank93]

It's gotta be Mackay, the one with the most potential on that list and most likely to disappoint. And also probably going to have his fair share of game time as well.

 

[JPetro83]

Matty Jaench

 

[Bacon8]

It's gotta be Mackay, the one with the most potential on that list and most likely to disappoint. And also probably going to have his fair share of game time as well.

He's our 7th most experienced player. He should be getting game time. I hope he plays with 150th this year. (Edit: no I don't - 149 would be better)

I agree it will be Mackay, because he's unfairly judged on here.

 

[Pugsley]

Matty Jaensch

That's better

 

[GROTTO]

 

[little graham]

There's to many options on that poll that hold thier own and make the decision hard.

Pleased delete thread.

 

[hippyhippy]

Reilly can't be it.. He won't get a game...

 

[crow4life]

Matthew Wright

 

[Deaneus!]

Nah, I wouldn't think so. After all, he left us in great shape, by his own admission.

Funnily enough, I think we can attribute lots of the things that go bad on 2015 to decisions he's made previously, absolving the golden children Roo and Fagan from criticism while they right the ship. He is truly the gift that keeps on giving. In other news, I want Carlton to go 0-23 this season.

 

[Pugsley]

That's his face after a Malthouse roasting.

 

[Brenton Davy]

Nah, everyone will come down hard on Brodie Martin if he doesn't get at least 25 possies at 100% DE and at least 4 goals, while Brodie Smith will be universally gooed over even with 5 direct turnovers a game...

 

[Paladin]

Nah, everyone will come down hard on Brodie Martin if he doesn't get at least 25 possies at 100% DE and at least 4 goals, while Brodie Smith will be universally gooed over even with 5 direct turnovers a game...

I'm not sure I have ever seen Smith turn the ball over let alone 5 times in one game

 

[Paladin]

I like to keep some constants in my like so if Radar is gifted a game or 2 I will be riding him hard.

 

[GROTTO]

I wonder if fans will turn on Danger, if the season goes pear shaped and the obvious likelihood of him staying is akin to us moving back to West Lakes.​

 

[GROTTO]

I like to keep some constants in my like so if Radar is gifted a game or 2 I will be riding him hard.

But Radar makes every poster in here believe that they are a chance of playing AFL for the Crows.

 

[footy4ever]

I miss Stevo

I miss Dogga

 

[dylan123]

Far too hard to select just one option, I guess it will also depend on which of these guys are playing in the 22 to determine which one will be the biggest whipping boy.

 

[Bailey01]

Nah, everyone will come down hard on Brodie Martin if he doesn't get at least 25 possies at 100% DE and at least 4 goals, while Brodie Smith will be universally gooed over even with 5 direct turnovers a game...

Isn't Brodie Smith getting the 25 disposals at 100% efficiency?

 

[Brenton Davy]

I'm not sure I have ever seen Smith turn the ball over let alone 5 times in one game

Isn't Brodie Smith getting the 25 disposals at 100% efficiency?

Smithers has turned it over by foot numerous time. 5 times a game is overstating the situation, but he isn't as elite by foot as some believe. sure he hits a lot of long range targets, but he also turns a few over, nearly always in the back half, often leading to opposition scores. Now I am a Smithers fan, but he gets away with a lot more on this board than the whipping boys do.

And yes, I can see the sarcasm dripping...

 

[Pugsley]

I miss Dogga

So does the yiros shop down at Glenelg.

 

[Pugsley]

Smithers has turned it over by foot numerous time. 5 times a game is overstating the situation, but he isn't as elite by foot as some believe. sure he hits a lot of long range targets, but he also turns a few over, nearly always in the back half, often leading to opposition scores. Now I am a Smithers fan, but he gets away with a lot more on this board than the whipping boys do.

And yes, I can see the sarcasm dripping...

You don't become an AA if you're a whipping boy.

 

[Paladin]

Smithers has turned it over by foot numerous time. 5 times a game is overstating the situation, but he isn't as elite by foot as some believe. sure he hits a lot of long range targets, but he also turns a few over, nearly always in the back half, often leading to opposition scores. Now I am a Smithers fan, but he gets away with a lot more on this board than the whipping boys do.

And yes, I can see the sarcasm dripping...

Gee if B.Smith turnovers get you going how did you cope with a decade of Brent Reilly?

 

[Pugsley]

Gee if B.Smith turnovers get you going how did you cope with a decade of Brent Reilly?

I got the blood pressure tested weekly.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Gee if B.Smith turnovers get you going how did you cope with a decade of Brent Reilly?

To be fair, Reilly rarely kicks it directly to an opposition player.

It usually goes straight into the crowd.