MVP Voting R22 vs Collingwood

[Scully2Folau]

5-4-3-2-1

 

[_GT_]

5 Greene
4 Kelly
3 Smith
2 Mumford
1 Treloar

 

[Colonial]

5 Kelly
4 Greene
3 Mumford
2 Smith
1 Treloar

 

[Determinant]

5 Mumford
4 Greene
3 Kelly
2 Treloar
1 Palmer

Hon mentions for Shiel, Smith, Bugg, Whiley & Kennedy

 

[The Giant]

5. Mumford
4. Toby
3. Smith
2. Kelly
1. Treloar

Really wanted to give some points to Whiley and Buntine, because I've been super impressed with both of them since they came into the side. I'm hoping Bunts can stay in the Best 22 from now on, but for Whiley, I just want his career to kick off - whether that's here or elsewhere...I'll be happy for the guy.

 

[Bogan Juniors]

5 Mumford
4 Greene
3 Kelly
2 Treloar
1 Sheil

Agree with Buntine, showing why he was pick 5 and definately a best 22 defender contender.

 

[Ichabod Noodle]

5: Mumford - was immense
4: Smith - was everywhere
3: Greene - was unstoppable
2: WHE - was class
1: Kelly - was smooth

 

[Ellie Aquitaine]

Since I still haven't seen the game, I'm not doing a traditional vote. I'm sick of all the "brave Collingwood" with their injuries and am awarding my shadow votes to those injured players, based on their standing at Round 20 in our BF Giants' MVP:

5 - Ward - who has been unstoppable.
4 - Haynes (7th) - who cemented a top 22 spot and would have really helped our defence in close games
3 - Patton (equal 8th) - former No. 1 draft pick who was demonstrating why he will be a superstar in a few years (knees permitting)
3 - Whitfield (equal 8th) - another No. 1 draft pick
1 - Scully (equal 12th) - who was coming into his own this year.

Honourable mention - Phil Davis (13th)

 

[GreaterWeStener]

5 - Palmer
4 - Mumford
3 - Greene
2 - Hunt
1 - Buntine

 

[fridgeman]

5 - Greene, still dodgy disposal but less frequent
4 - Mumford, immense, 2nd best recruit to the club after Ward?
3 - Smith
2 - Kelly
1 - Treloar