Who are our most important 5 players?

[ghost]

The most important 5 players at our club are as follows as far as I am concerned:

1 - M Voss
2 - J Leppitch
3 - D White
4 - N Lappin
5 - C Scott

What do you think? Do you agree with ghost or has ghost got it all wrong? Have your say. Tell ghost who you think are our most valuable players. Has ghost got the order right, or is Lappin more important than White to our team?

 

[lioness]

ghost, I think you have it all pretty right!!!!! My list is:

* Michael Voss
* Chris Scott
* Beau McDonald (still young but shows so much talent already)
* Darryl White
* Simon Black

Just my thoughts.

Jacs

 

[Dodongo]

I would think the 5 most important players are!

Vossy
Leppitsch
White
Lynch
Scott

Dodongo!!!!

 

[joshhem]

Id say these:

* Michael Voss
* Shaun Hart
* Beau McDonald
* Darryl White
* Simon Black
(and i'd like to add bradshaw, but there is no room)

 

[InTheBack!]

Voss
Leppa
White
Lynch
Lappin

I think Black is up there as is Keating & Bradshaw. I wish I could have listed a true CHF, as this is the position we are weak on - although I really like Brown he is not yet in my top 5.

 

[John Howard]

Michael Voss
Darryl White
Justin Leppitsch
Chris Scott
Nigel Lappin

 

[SpecialBruce]

Michael Voss
SHAUN HART
Nigel Lappin
Justin Leppitsch
Simon Black

Ghost - Why the hell isn't Hart in your top 5?

Watch out in a few years. CUPIDO will be in the top 5.

 

[Mr Ripper]

SpecialBruce advises:
Watch out in a few years. CUPIDO will be in the top 5.

Yeah, but for which club?

 

[golions]

1. M. Voss
2. J. Leppistch
3. S. Black
4. D. White
5. S. Hart

 

[ghost]

SpecialBruce, you are just one of 3 who have said Hart is in our best 5 players. He is a handy player, but not in the best 5 unfortunately.

 

[Denno]

1. Voss
2. Leppitsch
3. White
4. Black
5. Power

 

[Tom FC]

Voss- cause he's a god
Leppitsch- holds the backline together
Black- wins the ball out of the centre probably even better than Voss
Power- worth about three goals a game
Lappin- best ball carrier

Apologies to Chris Scott and Clark Keating

 

[mud n blood]

I know the question was "players" ... but I put their whole success of recent down to lethal - solely!

Without him, I don't reckon our "stars" would sparkle (bad joke!)

------------------
Anyway, that's what I reckon ........

mud n blood

 

[pia daley]

Well, i agree with most of those too ... M.Voss is definetely our number 1, he is amazing, and we're very lucky to have him ... then the rest kinda are the same, all replaceable as such .... thats may sound harsh, but basically everyone is replaceable really .......I think that Black is really important too and so is Leppa. Its unfortuante though that we've lost Steve Lawrence and Jarrod Molloy ... get ready for me to bitch about that later, i'm soo mad that we lost those too, its going to be so awful seeing them in their different jumpers

 

[lioness]

Tom FC - damn right you should apologise to Chris Scott!!!!!!!!!

hehehe he's a damn legend, lol

 

[sandie]

Lioness if you are still there come into chat

------------------
Mantis

 

[acuguy]

my top 5
1.M.Voss
2.C.Keating
3.J.Leppitsch
4.N.Lappin
5.S.Black

 

[WCE2000]

I noticed a lot of you where saying Daryl White was in your top 5.

I haven't seen a lot of Brisbane in 2000, but whenever i saw them, Daryl White never seemed to make much of an impact.

Can someone just tell me if he was really playing that well in 2000. I've always considered him quite a good footballer, but now he seems to be getting on.

------------------
Good luck at the Athens Olympics Mags, go for gold in Taekwondo.

For all your footballing needs be sure to visit my AFL web-site at http://www.geocities.com/eastsydney5/index.html

 

[Tom FC]

Darryl White was very close to our most consistent player in 2000.

He didn't get fantastic statistics, but he rarely got beaten at full-back (just against Lloyd, who kicked five on him), and his best skill this year was spoiling forwards; he was able to use his ruck skills to knock it to our small defenders, particularly Johnson and Akermanis. Nobody would really notice it by watching one or two games, but anyone who saw him all through the year would see it.

 

[richo]

Originally posted by SpecialBruce:
Michael Voss
SHAUN HART
Nigel Lappin
Justin Leppitsch
Simon Black

Ghost - Why the hell isn't Hart in your top 5?

Watch out in a few years. CUPIDO will be in the top 5.

 

[M Malice]

1. p hanley
2. d beams
3. s martin
4. t rockliff
5. d merrett

15 years on these are the players i would least like to see injured in 2016. lets hope the next 3 years are half as good as the 3 after this original thread.

 

[BangyBangy]

1. p hanley
2. d beams
3. s martin
4. t rockliff
5. d merrett

15 years on these are the players i would least like to see injured in 2016. lets hope the next 3 years are half as good as the 3 after this original thread.

Again, not about the best players, just the ones I want to see a full season from.

1. S Martin (Coz without him we're in a world of hurt, no disrespect to West)
2. D Beams
3. P Hanley
4. T Rockliff
5. D Rich, C Beams & J McGrath (cheating a little but i'll call that a three way tie).

 

[Ironmonger]

Darryl White was very close to our most consistent player in 2000.

He didn't get fantastic statistics, but he rarely got beaten at full-back (just against Lloyd, who kicked five on him), and his best skill this year was spoiling forwards; he was able to use his ruck skills to knock it to our small defenders, particularly Johnson and Akermanis. Nobody would really notice it by watching one or two games, but anyone who saw him all through the year would see it.

Geez, get a load of this clown. 'Nobody would really notice it by watching one or two games'. Patronising BS.

 

[Haso]

Geez, get a load of this clown. 'Nobody would really notice it by watching one or two games'. Patronising BS.

I bet that guy relishes the contrarian role.

 

[Skoob]

Geez, get a load of this clown. 'Nobody would really notice it by watching one or two games'. Patronising BS.

I wonder what ever happened to Tom. Bet he's still the same smug prick, where ever he is.