Would you be happy if your club pulled the trigger and traded for Carlisle on a $750K a year Deal?

[King Bont]

This is a debate that has been going on for a while on a hand full off AFL teams boards, including the Bulldogs. I've come to the conclusion that a deal to pry Carlisle away from Essendon would take a 1st rounder and a good player (at the minimum) and about a deal around $750K a year over 4.
Is he worth it? And would you want him at your club?

 

[Latro]

To play in the backline yes.

 

[Righteo]

Absolutely yes.

 

[Magma]

at fb or chb absolutely.

 

[HoneyBadger35]

No, West Coast has an incredible spine (when healthy), and tons of other areas to improve. Would rather throw that cash at a gun mid.

 

[MightyHawks]

I wouldn't want my club to do that

But Port might be keen to collect a group of players who might not play a game in 2016 & 2017

Trigg also would be all over a deal like that

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

If we can get a gun mid in return I'll be happy to trade Carlise.

 

[estibador]

The salary doesn't worry me, Essendon's demands at the trade table probably would though.

 

[billy fragos]

In defence yes

 

[manboob]

Don't need him so no. But he could be the missing puzzle piece for a few clubs.

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

The salary doesn't worry me, Essendon's demands at the trade table probably would though.

To get quality you have to give quality.

 

[Crankyhawk]

If we can get a gun mid in return I'll be happy to trade Carlise.

Could be worth looking at some of GWS/Gold coast mids perhaps.

 

[mike123]

If the team needs an intercept marking CHB, then maybe. Seems the right trade prive but not sure he is worth taking that much salary. A bit much for a defender and I think he's next to useless as a forward.

Would I be happy if my club was paying Carlisle 750k a year? No.

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Could be worth looking at some of GWS/Gold coast mids perhaps.

Yep

Some one like a Dylan Sheil or Adam Treloar would do.

 

[manboob]

Yep

Some one like a Dylan Sheil or Adam Treloar would do.

And your first?

 

[Jones2ByrneJones]

Yes. Absolutely.

Ryder and Monfries isn't enough. We need more - MORE - players with uncertain futures on our list.

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

And your first?

I would.

 

[Ambrosia]

Don't need him so no. But he could be the missing puzzle piece for a few clubs.

Who's playing FB for Geelong when Lonergan retires?

 

[SeaWind]

He hasn't even played in defence since 2013. He's no certainty to instantly re-capture his best form.

 

[raffrox]

He's the kind of guy who with the right coach and team he could be a gun.

At the moment though he is looking pretty fragile mentally.

 

[HFF]

Not a penny more than 600k- max to lure him away and even then it's a stretch when you watch him on exposed form.

Sure, he has the odd strong mark but he hasn't actually achieved anything of note.

He is also a CHB not a forward.

 

[Schache It Off]

I would. Pick 5 + Untouchable.

 

[The King!]

Sure

Wait not allowed

 

[Richo83]

Eh, he'd be replacing someone like Grimes and Chaplin and as much as he'd be an improvement, I'm not sure the improvement would be that stark to justify the price tag. He's not great up forward, I'd rather a GWS midfielder instead, and 750k is the kind of money you'd need to lure the likes of Shiel.

 

[Rack Watts]

He's kicked 2 bags of 8 goals. Rofl