Blues Squad to take on Hawthorn

[Silvagnis]

 

[Bluebear]

yes true but at training avoids all the body contact stuff. trust me guys, his shoulders are rubbish atm

Then it makes no sense to play him in SA.

 

[Salaryman]

Don't play dumb

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

Then it makes no sense to play him in SA.

SA???

 

[Pamam]

SA???

South Africa!!!

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

South Africa!!!

yeah very true but he needs game time. there is a problem but its in the position whereby surgery is not needed just yet, but they are well below 70%

 

[kirbatron]

keen to see how Murphy goes...

It'll be a big game for the youngsters of both sides, should be great!

 

[Bluebear]

yeah very true but he needs game time. there is a problem but its in the position whereby surgery is not needed just yet, but they are well below 70%

This isn't making any sense Shmurf.

Setanta needs no more game time than Walker, Judd, Bentick.....and needs a lot less than Aisake..........and if he needs the time and can play a bit why not play some of the game vs Port..............lack of logic in what you are saying.

If his shoulders are "stuffed" as you say, then pull the pin as with Ackland and Walker, take the op and he'll miss maybe 2-3 weeks at the start of the season (depending on the surgery), if not then play him.

Didn't I spot a bandage around his knee at training in the pics on Wednesday......someone with some more time might dig it up (damn patients......).

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

This isn't making any sense Shmurf.

Setanta needs no more game time than Walker, Judd, Bentick.....and needs a lot less than Aisake..........and if he needs the time and can play a bit why not play some of the game vs Port..............lack of logic in what you are saying.

If his shoulders are "stuffed" as you say, then pull the pin as with Ackland and Walker, take the op and he'll miss maybe 2-3 weeks at the start of the season (depending on the surgery), if not then play him.

Didn't I spot a bandage around his knee at training in the pics on Wednesday......someone with some more time might dig it up (damn patients......).

i have a very good mate of mine who is training with the bullants/carlton atm and said to me that his shoulders were giving him heaps of problems to the point where he is almost not involved in contact work at training, thats all i can report on atm. your message makes sense but thats what ive been told. like i said i think its like the dreaded O.P where its not too bad to have an operation just yet but is hampering his ability.

confusing... i know

 

[Bluebear]

i have a very good mate of mine who is training with the bullants/carlton atm and said to me that his shoulders were giving him heaps of problems to the point where he is almost not involved in contact work at training, thats all i can report on atm. your message makes sense but thats what ive been told. like i said i think its like the dreaded O.P where its not too bad to have an operation just yet but is hampering his ability.

confusing... i know

Cheers.

I appreciate the info.

I hope this isn't another "Lance-gate" where the cross training that he ended up doing to get fit SHOULD have been his pre-season program from the start............late shoulder ops for Ackland and Walker............my concerns about our medical management have not been appeased.

 

[Beloved]

keen to see how Murphy goes...

It'll be a big game for the youngsters of both sides, should be great!

Too right, hopefully the Port Adelaide was just a case of the jitters.

The guy had one bad week, and already people are on his a*se. It makes me sick.