Player X or Player Y

[DB10]

Higgins/Bartel/$$ -> Prestia. Chapman's got some big injury clouds over him going into the season. I would avoid.

Zaharakis + more expensive 5th forward vs. Higgins + Rohan?

 

[cfx_1]

Higgins/Bartel/$$ -> Prestia. Chapman's got some big injury clouds over him going into the season. I would avoid.

Zaharakis + more expensive 5th forward vs. Higgins + Rohan?

Still not sold on Zaha, but Rohan is unpredictable... lol I would wait to invest in Zaha and go Higgins and Rohan.

Goodes V Pavlich

 

[cfx_1]

Anthony V Kennedy

 

[carn_freo]

dangerfield vs mitch duncan.

goodes over pav. pav will get stuck playing midfield too much early this year... he tends to score more when playing forward.

 

[cfx_1]

dangerfield vs mitch duncan.

I think there is too much rookie value this year in the forwards to use a mid price strategy there but if you must i think it depends which of the two gets a gig in the midfield. Both have potential to be great DTers but without increased time in midfield they are both likely to hang between 60-70

 

[Lazarus]

Anthony V Kennedy

Anthony

Goodes V Pavlich

 

[Noobz0r]

Goodes V Pavlich

Pavlich!

A Swallow v L Hayes

 

[castro]

Upgraded to Swallow last season and seems to be more popular as a starting mid this season going by this forum. Scores plenty from tackles but does not accumulate a high disposal tally on a consistent basis, especially with Anthony back in the side this year. Having said that he can get monster scores to balance out a decent average. Hayes for mine.

Franklin and Anthony OR

Jetta/Morton and Montagna

 

[major tom]

Upgraded to Swallow last season and seems to be more popular as a starting mid this season going by this forum. Scores plenty from tackles but does not accumulate a high disposal tally on a consistent basis, especially with Anthony back in the side this year. Having said that he can get monster scores to balance out a decent average. Hayes for mine.

Franklin and Anthony OR

Jetta/Morton and Montagna

Castro I think Franklin and Anthony as I think there is a fair amount of douby around Morton and Jetta. Those 2 could go either way while both Franklin and Anthony look pretty reliable if they are on the park


FRANKLIN, BOAK and DUIGAN

V

RIOLI, BARTEL and D.STANLEY

 

[cats81]

I would go the first option major tom...franklin could be top forward scorer this year and if boak stays on the park he will average around 100.

Higgins, Morton, Knights VS Sylvia, Riewoldt, McKernan?

 

[Sw3Et]

Dbl post

 

[Sw3Et]

I would go the first option major tom...franklin could be top forward scorer this year and if boak stays on the park he will average around 100.

Higgins, Morton, Knights VS Sylvia, Riewoldt, McKernan?

I think both options will average very close but I believe option 1 will be more consistent plus it will make you more money

I need a cheap ruck to line up next to Cox, can't choose between Warnock and Seaby. Or maybe there's another cheapy who will outscore them both?

 

[RBW_007]

I think both options will average very close but I believe option 1 will be more consistent plus it will make you more money

I need a cheap ruck to line up next to Cox, can't choose between Warnock and Seaby. Or maybe there's another cheapy who will outscore them both?

Cox and Seaby share a bye so if your playing for league it won't matter but if you're going for overall you might struggle that round.

 

[cats81]

Warnock looked good in the ruck yesterday in the NAB challenge, both of them will play second fiddle to their first ruck teammates though when they return from injury (Kruezer and Mumford who I think will both be played ruck this year still)...have you thought of picking Jacobs from Adelaide or Ottens from Geelong? bit more expensive but I feel they have more JS when fully fit. Fraser is another one to look at.

If I had to choose between those two I would get Seaby he seems more comfotable around the ground and I feel has a much higher ceiling

 

[IFBB]

Scott Thompson (ADE).

What do you think of him this year? My fav player, and really picked it up after getting over some knee tendinitis last year.

Here is his second half of the year, with the 27 when he got poked in the eye and had to go off during the 2nd quarter.

143, 27, 70, 146, 93, 97, 112, 122, 127, 72, 107, 105

Thomspon vs Anthony is probably the bet. I have $60k left, so going the cheaper option wont let me upgrade anyone else because i swapped Chappy for Didak to free it up... dont have much faith in Chappy atm.

 

[Lazarus]

DOn't have much faith in Chappy...yet you pick up Didak who has had a worse pre-season injury wise? and averages less........interesting choice

anyway, Anthony and Thompson are pretty even. I'd go Thompson

 

[yogibbear]

Leroy Jetta vs. Travis Cloke? (Ignore the price difference)

 

[Godzke]

Probably Jetta ... although I don't see either improving their 2010 value by more than $40k-$50k, which for midpricers is no man's land.

 

[yogibbear]

Probably Jetta ... although I don't see either improving their 2010 value by more than $40k-$50k, which for midpricers is no man's land.

Oh I'm not picking them in DT at all. Just wanting to see how people see them going this year. Thanks for your response

 

[JDavey]

Scott Thompson (ADE).

What do you think of him this year? My fav player, and really picked it up after getting over some knee tendinitis last year.

Here is his second half of the year, with the 27 when he got poked in the eye and had to go off during the 2nd quarter.

143, 27, 70, 146, 93, 97, 112, 122, 127, 72, 107, 105

Thomspon vs Anthony is probably the bet. I have $60k left, so going the cheaper option wont let me upgrade anyone else because i swapped Chappy for Didak to free it up... dont have much faith in Chappy atm.

He also had his second baby at the start of last year - only reason I know is because his wife is the older sister of my best mate. Thompson averaged just shy of 110 in the final half of the year if you exclude the 27 - I was thinking about picking him up but I don't know if I have the guts to pull the trigger - might have to though to free up some cash for rookies due to Callinan.

 

[Prem87]

Duffield v. Grimes

Gwilt v. Myers

Masten v. L Jetta

 

[Scootyb]

Grimes, Gwilt, Jetta

 

[Prem87]

Heppell v. Cheney

 

[Lazarus]

Heppell

Jeremy Laidler or Brad Sheppard?

 

[Godzke]

Duffield v. Grimes

Gwilt v. Myers

Masten v. L Jetta

Is keeping Myers position warm. May make it his own in his own right. With Slattery injured, who despite playing more up the ground this preseason, we have another vacancy in the backline. Should get regular game time now.