MVP Carlton v Richmond Round One 2011

[jj1978]

5. Scotland - good use of the ball, hardness, hunger and leadership
4. Murphy - dominant for 3 quarters.. had the 3rd quarter lapse.
3. Warnock - will be number 2 ruckman in the comp come end of the season behind Sandilands
2. Robinson - is becoming a very reliable complete player.
1. Judd - for looking a bit underdone and as usual being heavily tagged... 25 good possessions, a captains goal and leadership.

Special mentions to: Simspon, Russell, Curnow and Diagan and Betts.

Best young player - White: had the hardest job on the ground with not enough support from the other defenders.

 

[GordonBlue]

5 Warnock
4 Gibbs
3 Murphy
2 Judd
1 Curnow <-- Best young player

Unlucky: Simmo, Betts

About to get murdered for this, however I thought Robbo was poor... YES POOR... he got 28 possies or whatever, and they were hard contested type... however, he just gets it and bombs it... again... and again... and again...

I love Robbo and don't want him out... but by gee... needs to cut back on that quickly

 

[Stamos]

5. Scotland - good use of the ball, hardness, hunger and leadership

Scotland really stood up in the last quarter to help win the game, but he was hopeless in the first 3.

 

[Artie Bucco]

5. Murphy
4. Gibbs
3. Betts
2. Robinson
1. Judd

Curnow unlucky

 

[Jeremias]

5. Murphy
4. Gibbs
3. Robinson
2. Warnock
1. Curnow

Best young player - Curnow

Simpson, Betts & Judd unlucky.

 

[Aphrodite]

5. Murphy
4. Judd
3. Gibbs
2. Curnow
1. Robinson

Best Young Player : Curnow

 

[Salaryman]

5. Murph
4. Gibbs
3. Judd
2. Robbo
1. Betts

BYP - Curnow

 

[Sublime]

5. Gibbs
4. Murphy
3. Warnock
2. Judd
1. Robinson

BYP - Curnow

 

[blue_boys]

5. Murphy
4. Gibbs
3. Judd
2. Curnow
1. Warnock

best young player = curnow

 

[DarkTint]

5 - Marc Murphy
4 - Bryce Gibbs
3 - Robbie Warnock
2 - Mitch Robinson
1 - Chris Judd

BYP - Ed Curnow

 

[NAUGHT5]

5. Murphy
4. Gibbs
3. Judd
2. Curnow
1. Betts

B.Y.P - Curnow.

 

[Alpha1]

5. Murphy
4. Gibbs
3. Eddie
2. Judd
1. Curnow

 

[james Dean]

5 - Gibbs (he will win our B&F and be AA this year)
4 - Murphy
3 - Warnock
2 - Betts
1 - Judd

Best young player - Ed Curnow

 

[Juddrockz]

1.The Messiah (carried us back over the line again.)
2.Murph
3.Warnock
4.Gibbs.
4.Fast Eddie

Curnow.....pick up of the year.

 

[Deep Blue]

5. Murphy - consistently good and in for a very big year
4. Gibbs - real polish with disposals that are more than a mere stat
3. Judd - lead the way in clearances again and won us the game in the last
2. Robinson - looks really good in the middle
1. Warnock/Eddie - couldn't split little and large

Curnow

 

[The Toad]

5. Murphy
4. Judd
3. Gibbs
2. Curnow
1. Robinson

Curnow best newbie

 

[KruZin]

5. Murphy
4. Gibbs
3. Judd
2. Robinson
1. Curnow

Curnow

 

[Warsaw]

5. Murphy
4. Judd
3. Gibbs
2. Curnow
1. Betts

Curnow

 

[Iremember95]

5 murphy
4 gibbs
3 eddie
2 judd
1 robinson

 

[The Big Sticks]

I completely forgot about giving my votes.

5. Gibbs
4. Murphy
3. Judd
2. Robinson
1. Curnow

BYP - Curnow

 

[Claypigeon]

So many people have given Curnow BYP, yet given Robinson more votes. ..

 

[blues4flag]

Think we'll decrease the games tally. Robinson is too experienced a player to be included, I think. Will make up my mind later on in the week but of the rest Curnow was the clear best.

 

[michael69]

1. Murphy
2. Gibbs
3. Judd
4. Warnock
5. Robinson

 

[Stamos]

Think we'll decrease the games tally. Robinson is too experienced a player to be included, I think. Will make up my mind later on in the week but of the rest Curnow was the clear best.

Agree, the cut off should be at about Yarran

 

[Silvagnis]

5. Marc Murphy
4. Bryce Gibbs
3. Chris Judd
2. Mitch Robinson
1. Eddie Betts

Best young player: Jeremy Laidler.