Remove this Banner Ad

SpecialBruce's top 50

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

SpecialBruce

SpecialBruce

Norm Smith Medallist
Veteran Roys FFC - Sweet F.A.
Feb 7, 2000
5,673
2,225
Horsham
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Other Teams
Lions
I did 3, 2, 1 voting during the year, not only to work out who to put money on for the brownlow, but also to compare against Sheehans.

This was Sheehans:

1. M Voss
2. A Mcleod
3. M Lloyd
4. B Ratten
5. J Akermanis
6. S Black
7. B Cousins
8. N Buckley
9. D Gasper
10. J Hird
11. M Primus
12. J Johnson
13. L Darcy
14. N Lappin
15. B Harvey
16. S Silvangi
17. J Hay
18. A Koutoufides
19. J Barker
20. S Wellman
21. B Ottens
22. J Smith
23. W Treadrea
24. M Richardson
25. N Brown
26. S Grant
27. G Wanganeen
28. M Lappin
29. S Goodwin
30. L Cameron
31. A McKay
32. S Crawford
33. A Yze
34. C Grant
35. D Chick
36. D King
37. J Francou
38. B Johnson
39. J Brown
40. S Paxman
41. C Johnson
42. M Stevens
43. S Camporeale
44. S Maxfield
45. C Cockatoo-Collins
46. W Campbell
47. D WHite
48. N Stevens
49. S Beaumont
50. N Thompson

This is mine. Votes are in the brackets.

1. B Cousins (23)
2. A Mcleod (23)
3. M Primus (21)
4. J Johnson (21)
5. J Bowden (21)
6. M Voss (20)
7. J Akermanis (19)
8. S Black (18)
9. N Buckley (18)
10. B Ratten (18)
11. S Crawford (18)
12. M Ricciuto (17)
13. N Brown (16)
14. S Camporeale (16)
15. S Goodwin (15)
16. B Ottens (15)
17. N Stevens (15)
18. S O'Bree (15)
19. J Francou (14)
20. W Campbell (14)
21. B Harvey (13)
22. S West (13)
23. N Lappin (12)
24. J Hird (11)
25. A Koutoufides (11)
26. P Bell (10)
27. S Maxfield (10)
28. A Yze (10)
29. D Cresswell (10)
30. S Grant (10)
31. M Porter (10)
32. M Lloyd (9)
33. J Smith (9)
34. D Bradshaw (9)
35. D Jarman (9)
36. J Murphy (9)
37. L Whitnall (9)
38. S Febey (9)
39. G Tivendale (8)
40. J Misiti (8)
41. J Ball (8)
42. S Beaumont (8)
43. C Bradley (8)
44. L Darcy (7)
45. G Wanganeen (7)
46. W Treadrea (7)
47. S Wellman (7)
48. J Fraser (7)
49. B Johnson (7)
50. J Brown (6)

My list looks much better than Sheehan's. I was suprised he didn't have Bell in the top 50. Comparing Sheehan's to mine, we both had 14 different players.
 
Originally posted by SpecialBruce
I did 3, 2, 1 voting during the year, not only to work out who to put money on for the brownlow, but also to compare against Sheehans.

This was Sheehans:

1. M Voss
2. A Mcleod
3. M Lloyd
4. B Ratten
5. J Akermanis
6. S Black
7. B Cousins
8. N Buckley
9. D Gasper
10. J Hird
11. M Primus
12. J Johnson
13. L Darcy
14. N Lappin
15. B Harvey
16. S Silvangi
17. J Hay
18. A Koutoufides
19. J Barker
20. S Wellman
21. B Ottens
22. J Smith
23. W Treadrea
24. M Richardson
25. N Brown
26. S Grant
27. G Wanganeen
28. M Lappin
29. S Goodwin
30. L Cameron
31. A McKay
32. S Crawford
33. A Yze
34. C Grant
35. D Chick
36. D King
37. J Francou
38. B Johnson
39. J Brown
40. S Paxman
41. C Johnson
42. M Stevens
43. S Camporeale
44. S Maxfield
45. C Cockatoo-Collins
46. W Campbell
47. D WHite
48. N Stevens
49. S Beaumont
50. N Thompson

This is mine. Votes are in the brackets.

1. B Cousins (23)
2. A Mcleod (23)
3. M Primus (21)
4. J Johnson (21)
5. J Bowden (21)
6. M Voss (20)
7. J Akermanis (19)
8. S Black (18)
9. N Buckley (18)
10. B Ratten (18)
11. S Crawford (18)
12. M Ricciuto (17)
13. N Brown (16)
14. S Camporeale (16)
15. S Goodwin (15)
16. B Ottens (15)
17. N Stevens (15)
18. S O'Bree (15)
19. J Francou (14)
20. W Campbell (14)
21. B Harvey (13)
22. S West (13)
23. N Lappin (12)
24. J Hird (11)
25. A Koutoufides (11)
26. P Bell (10)
27. S Maxfield (10)
28. A Yze (10)
29. D Cresswell (10)
30. S Grant (10)
31. M Porter (10)
32. M Lloyd (9)
33. J Smith (9)
34. D Bradshaw (9)
35. D Jarman (9)
36. J Murphy (9)
37. L Whitnall (9)
38. S Febey (9)
39. G Tivendale (8)
40. J Misiti (8)
41. J Ball (8)
42. S Beaumont (8)
43. C Bradley (8)
44. L Darcy (7)
45. G Wanganeen (7)
46. W Treadrea (7)
47. S Wellman (7)
48. J Fraser (7)
49. B Johnson (7)
50. J Brown (6)

My list looks much better than Sheehan's. I was suprised he didn't have Bell in the top 50. Comparing Sheehan's to mine, we both had 14 different players.
Click to expand...
Your top 50 is foobar(sorry im watching saving private ryan).Why is Darcy so low besides thaat it is a good list.
 
Heres some of the ones in yours I don't think deserve to be there or were too high

5. J Bowden (21) - In there but not at number 5

11. S Crawford (18) - Same story here

18. S O'Bree (15) - Top twenty players???

34. D Bradshaw (9) - How can Lloyd be only two spots ahead of him?

35. D Jarman (9) - Sentimental reasons??

36. J Murphy (9) - Wasn't a great year, just a good one

38. S Febey (9) - Good year by his standards, still not top 50

39. G Tivendale (8) - Same goes for him

40. J Misiti (8) - Thats why Essendon want to get rid of him?

The rest were pretty good!

Yours was better than Sheehans just a couple of mistakes
 
Re: Re: SpecialBruce's top 50

Originally posted by dogboy23
Your top 50 is foobar(sorry im watching saving private ryan).Why is Darcy so low besides thaat it is a good list.
Click to expand...

Darcy is so low because he got 7 votes. He had a better year than Wanganeen, Treadrea, Wellman, Fraser and Johnson so I put him 44th in front of them.

BTW, I'm taping Saving Private Ryan.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Re: Re: Re: SpecialBruce's top 50

Originally posted by SpecialBruce


Darcy is so low because he got 7 votes. He had a better year than Wanganeen, Treadrea, Wellman, Fraser and Johnson so I put him 44th in front of them.

BTW, I'm taping Saving Private Ryan.
Click to expand...

So then you put Cousins ahead McLeod because Cousins had a better year?? Hmmmm.....

I don't mind your system, but how did you do the votes, did you watch every game?? :confused:
 
Originally posted by McCartney5
Heres some of the ones in yours I don't think deserve to be there or were too high

5. J Bowden (21) - In there but not at number 5

11. S Crawford (18) - Same story here

18. S O'Bree (15) - Top twenty players???

34. D Bradshaw (9) - How can Lloyd be only two spots ahead of him?

35. D Jarman (9) - Sentimental reasons??

36. J Murphy (9) - Wasn't a great year, just a good one

38. S Febey (9) - Good year by his standards, still not top 50

39. G Tivendale (8) - Same goes for him

40. J Misiti (8) - Thats why Essendon want to get rid of him?

The rest were pretty good!

Yours was better than Sheehans just a couple of mistakes
Click to expand...

Ta, I could have rigged the votes to change it around, but decided not to.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: SpecialBruce's top 50

Originally posted by ant


So then you put Cousins ahead McLeod because Cousins had a better year?? Hmmmm.....

I don't mind your system, but how did you do the votes, did you watch every game?? :confused:
Click to expand...

Na, I didn't watch every game. I watched replays of some and the ones I didn't see enough of, I used best players and votes and worked out from there. So that doesn't make it that accurate which would probably mean why some players are in those positions. But who cares.
 
Re: Re: SpecialBruce's top 50

Originally posted by dogboy23
Your top 50 is foobar(sorry im watching saving private ryan).Why is Darcy so low besides thaat it is a good list.
Click to expand...

Its fubar mate not foobar :)..
F *cked
U p
B eyond
A ll
R ecognition

anyway..good effore specialbruce,
you don't deserve the criticism, you went to the effort of doing a top 50, unlike the ppl here that are just criticising.

Cheers mate...
 
I don't know about the Coleman Medalist coming in at No.32!! :rolleyes:

But apart from that...it's a good list! :)
 
Your 50 is a joke. Wheres CHRIS GRANT?????? You should feel embarrased not having him in. Im gonna give you the benefit of the doubt and hope it was just an oversight, but if not, you've got no idea. You should repost one with Chris Grant in at the worste, top 20.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

I like yours Joel Bowden was a great player and not even in Mikes Top 50 aswell they had Che-Cockatoo Collins in there Mike aswell as Paxman, He was injured for about 3 weeks and I think Goodwin was better then what he was voted


JAMES HIRD SHOULD NOT BE CAPTIN OF THE ALL AUSTRALIAN SIDE! HE IS SO OVER RATED :mad:

Go Tigers
 
Another Thing have u heard of DARREN GASPER (I dont think hes in there I had a look 3 times)


If hes NOT There sorry, But DARREN GASPER HAS TO BE IN THERE

Go tigers and who do u go 4?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

SpecialBruce's top 50

Similar threads

PowerfulPies2023
Top 3 players ever from each club
2 3
Replies
61
Views
2K
PowerfulPies2023
PowerfulPies2023

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top