MRP / Trib. Come on MRP, do us a favour

[NUFC Tiger]

Mods, please remove this thread if inappropriate or merge it elsewhere.

After watching tonight's game.

Hoping that

• Ziebull gets at least 1 week for his heavy hit on Joseph (who didn't come back on) &
• Judd gets at least 2 for his weird chicken wing arm twister on Adams.

Our next 2 are against North and Carlton respectively - both are 8 pointer games, would be good to face both without these guys in their respective teams
Come on MRP and unleash the Giesch on these 2!!!

 

[Tzatziki_Man]

Yep, both 1 week and 2 are certainly reasonable! Swallow in doubt too? It's what I heard I'm not sure. Rance needs to ******* slaughter Petrie next week. I'm already nervous.

 

[Bird Man]

this is judd were talking here ? he would have needed to brake the guys arm to get two weeks

 

[The Dice Man]

You gotta be kidding... That game just won Judd a Brownlow.

 

[Spluff]

You gotta be kidding... That game just won Judd a Brownlow.

Can't win a brownlow when you're suspended.

 

[The Dice Man]

Its Judd we are talking about here.

 

[Dustin Credible]

Judd's act IMO was disgraceful. A premeditated attempt to injure a prostrate opponent. Brings the game into disrepute.

But as has been pointed out he may be in contention for the brownlow and as such will get off scott free.

 

[mcuzzy]

bloke won a brownlow after elbowing pav in the face so that was probably a 3 vote game and no suspension

 

[SteveRFC]

Hahah, would be the first bit of luck we've had in ages. We always seem to vs teams when either A. A huge milestone game or B. A player is just coming back from Suspension or injury. When was the last time a teams "Poster Boy" was out when we played them i.e.. Ablett/Judd?

 

[mark73]

Hahah, would be the first bit of luck we've had in ages. We always seem to vs teams when either A. A huge milestone game or B. A player is just coming back from Suspension or injury. When was the last time a teams "Poster Boy" was out when we played them i.e.. Ablett/Judd?

It's funny you say that because I've often thought the same way about us. Judd doesn't get suspended. Surely you must know that by now? He gets "spoken to".

 

[tigerfan1961]

I think Jamieson is in the most trouble with his knees into the back of Petrie

 

[Damo80]

Judd has AFL immunity. The only guys in the AFL who can eye gouge, elbow to the head, chicken wing tackle... and is allowed to handball using one hand.

 

[richmond_14]

Ziebell will probably get a week, even though he was going for the ball. I think his late tuck will hurt him.

 

[The Dice Man]

What's everyone's thoughts on our chances against nth next week? They're playing awesome and were down some key players.

 

[SunshineBoy]

Can't win a brownlow when you're suspended.

Didn't he win one after splitting pavs face open?

 

[RichoLedio]

Yep, both 1 week and 2 are certainly reasonable! Swallow in doubt too? It's what I heard I'm not sure. Rance needs to ******* slaughter Petrie next week. I'm already nervous.

Maybe Griff on Petrie would be better, Rance doesn't seem to play him well, he was subbed out with a groin wasn't he?

 

[CoggaRules]

the vision aint good and if he dont go then the radiowaves will light up and the AFL will be stamped as an embarrassment..the dudes shoulder popped out and here is Judd holding the gun...now FFS how ******* gaaaaaaaaaaawn is that? The elbow s**t from last year he had an out with I didnt know, I was trying to this...and that and all that BS that gets sold ....this one is thuggery without any get outs..

 

[RichoLedio]

Judd's act IMO was disgraceful. A premeditated attempt to injure a prostrate opponent. Brings the game into disrepute.

But as has been pointed out he may be in contention for the brownlow and as such will get off scott free.

Took me a while to realise what he was doing, absolutely low act, can't imagine why anyone would do something like that especially these days

 

[LBBenny]

Nice outcome from last nights game, hopefully all four wont play us now.. We also now have a better % than Carlton and if we beat suns will be ahead of north because of %. Go tiges

 

[Punt_Road_Roar]

what happened to Petrie?

 

[Groupie_]

Petrie will play.

 

[Punt_Road_Roar]

What's everyone's thoughts on our chances against nth next week? They're playing awesome and were down some key players.

They are up and about and think they will beat us, it will be a close one and think the game will be similiar to last years when they beat us to 9th.

 

[Punt_Road_Roar]

the vision aint good and if he dont go then the radiowaves will light up and the AFL will be stamped as an embarrassment..the dudes shoulder popped out and here is Judd holding the gun...now FFS how ******* gaaaaaaaaaaawn is that? The elbow s**t from last year he had an out with I didnt know, I was trying to this...and that and all that BS that gets sold ....this one is thuggery without any get outs..

All true Cogs but its Judd, he will say he held the arm up to stop him from handballing the ball out and honestly didnt realise he was pinned to the ground at the time. Juddy's QC will be flipping his gold coin while all this is being heard and the tribunal will get distracted and say ... no case to answer, we are sorry Mr Judd.

 

[Heisenberg_]

They are up and about and think they will beat us, it will be a close one and think the game will be similiar to last years when they beat us to 9th.

Being at the G is a big advantage to us.

 

[Groupie_]

Hahah, would be the first bit of luck we've had in ages. We always seem to vs teams when either A. A huge milestone game or B. A player is just coming back from Suspension or injury. When was the last time a teams "Poster Boy" was out when we played them i.e.. Ablett/Judd?

The Jason McCartney comeback game still haunts me.