Tom Mitchell or Jaeger O'Meara

[raffrox]

Not me. Judd was standout in our side far sooner (in my view and even not having regard to GAJ).

There's been nothing I've seen like early Judd as far as just crapping yourself as an opposition supporter when he got the ball.

Judd was very good, very quickly.

 

[raffrox]

haha....
Yes he is... only better

Dreamin'.

 

[jimmy35]

These guys are easily the hottest young property going around in the AFL at the moment. Jaeger has had a great first AFL season, slotted in well with the GCS and played pretty good. He racks them up, plays hard and disposes the ball well. Tom Mitchell played his second game tonight against the Crows, was amazing, should pick up 2 brownlow votes. Finished with 31, a goal, 10 tackles & 2nd in DT points.

They'll both be around for a long time, club leaders and potential club champions. I can't pick which one will win the rising star. Jaeger has an 8-9 game advantage over Mitchell, but Mitchell has been excellent in his 2 afl games.

Haha. O'Meara comfortably.

 

[Debris]

Need Mitchell to play more than a game and 3 quarters to make an intelligent prediction.

 

[Byron_Clanger]

Jaeger O'Meara hands down, done it longer in a much worse team, no comparison

 

[volders]

I don't have time at the moment, maybe if there's anyone that is interested and can be bothered , it would be interesting to see how Mitchell's game today or even first 2 stack up against anyone else's debut or first couple of games ??

Barlow had 67 possessions and kicked three goals in his first two games, doubt anyone will be able to match that.

 

[Jack2Jack]

So "This player vs this player".....next post.... "but you forgot player from my team, he goes way better"

Why does everything on this forum have to be a pissing contest?

 

[Wallaby]

So "This player vs this player".....next post.... "but you forgot player from my team, he goes way better"

Why does everything on this forum have to be a pissing contest?

Because I can piss higher up the wall than you can.

 

[tazhawk]

Just like we were 10% better than you last year

Yep and 10% better than everyone else this year.

OOPS 9.8 %

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Yep and 10% better than everyone else this year.

OOPS 9.8 %

 

[Rayklienig]

Yep and 10% better than everyone else this year.

OOPS 9.8 %

Seriously how bad are the hawks going to be in 2 years time can see you being like Melbourne

 

[Dalphonso]

Wines> Both

Up to a couple of Weeks ago Wines was right up there. But like the rest of his cronies he has come back to Earth with thud.

 

[Tedeski]

I'd take O'Meara any day of the week. Mitchell could be a top 10 player in the future. O'Meara will be a top 10 player.

OK. You Hawks take O'Meara...................us Swans will keep Tommy!

 

[Rayklienig]

As much as I hate to say it O'Meara is better. They really are two different players O'Meara is a Judd like player and I can't stop mistaking Mitchell for ROK still very happy with Mitchell tho

 

[Kwality]

Mitchell has played 1.5 games. As excited as I am watching him play, let's wait until he's played a few more before we start trying to make predictions like this.

Mitchell is a year older than O'Meara, & thats relevant at this time IF you want to compare.

 

[Rayklienig]

Mitchell is a year older than O'Meara, & thats relevant at this time IF you want to compare.

We should do Mitchell vs your whole list

 

[Swanhotels]

Possessions mean nothing these days, Judd tore games open. Not saying O'Meara won't, but he's not doing what Judd did in 2002.

I think you will find possession means something.

 

[Swanhotels]

Yep and 10% better than everyone else this year.

OOPS 9.8 %

You can lick 9.8% of my ass. Never seen such a bitter supporter base. Have you seen the GF replay yet? Its a ripper.

 

[Ichabod Noodle]

Jaeger O'Meara or Tom Mitchell? Hmmm.

I'll take Lachie Whitfield thanks.

highest disposal efficiency in the competition among mid-fielders (including a number of brownlow medallists) not only can he get the ball, he can do something with it too.

 

[Lach72]

Hottest young property going around in the AFL at the moment?

Jeremy Cameron.

Pretty much. If we had Cameron now look the hell out!!!

 

[Rayklienig]

I think you will find possession means something.

O'Meara is ahead Judd at this stage but Judd really ramped up in his 3rd year which I'm sure O'Meara will.

 

[Rayklienig]

Jaeger O'Meara or Tom Mitchell? Hmmm.

I'll take Lachie Whitfield thanks.

highest disposal efficiency in the competition among mid-fielders (including a number of brownlow medallists) not only can he get the ball, he can do something with it too.

Mitchell is way behind Whitfield

 

[QS]

We should do Mitchell vs your whole list

Pretty bold post after 1.5 games ...

O'Meara is ahead Judd at this stage but Judd really ramped up in his 3rd year which I'm sure O'Meara will.

Interesting theory, how did you conclude that? Do you recall Judd's game in 2003 against the Lions? One of the best games I've seen him play in his career let alone for a second year player.

 

[Green Eggs]

Oh is this one of those threads where we just nominate a young player who's better than everyone elses young players?

In that case Paul Seedsman is the bestest out of everyone.

In all honesty though, give these kids a break and stop comparing them to Judd or Ablett or any other gun midfielder you can find. These kids will create their own legacy in due course and nobody wants egg on their face like what was created by the over-hype of Scully/Trengove/Watts.

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Oh is this one of those threads where we just nominate a young player who's better than everyone elses young players?

No, it's about the two young men in the title. Why anyone is talking about Cameron, Whitfield etc. is beyond me.