Remove this Banner Ad

Chapman gone

  • Thread starter Thread starter The GOAT
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

The GOAT said:
Very similar to Buddy's, closer to the play but then again he left the ground. Will get a week IMO
Click to expand...
No head contact. Nothing to see
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I dont have a dog in this fight and i dont like to see any star player out of the game. From what i have seen this year he will get a week or 2 unfortunately. He left the ground and gave high contact. Only if they can argue he was going to smother and pulled out he may get off.
 
ChunkyDuckling said:
Chappy left the ground too. Buddy didnt.
Click to expand...


Yep. And he did get him high. My first reaction was it was maybe slightly worse than the Buddy one, not a lot of force it must be said, but I think deserves a week? No idea of his carryover points situation?
 
Purple Suit said:
Did you think Buddy deserved a week? It's the same, if not slightly worse since he leaves the ground.
Click to expand...

Considering Malceski went off the ground and was seen having his jaw looked at by the doctors on the sideline, and was later subbed out, then yes, he deserved a week.

Robbie Gray got straight back up and played the game out.

If Dawson got off for basically hitting Selwood in the head with his hip last week, then Chapman should get off this.
 
He is pretty much guaranteed to get 120 points.
 
winty said:
Considering Malceski went off the ground and was seen having his jaw looked at by the doctors on the sideline, and was later subbed out, then yes, he deserved a week.

Robbie Gray got straight back up and played the game out.

If Dawson got off for basically hitting Selwood in the head with his hip last week, then Chapman should get off this.
Click to expand...

Malceski was subbed with an ankle.
 
winty said:
Considering Malceski went off the ground and was seen having his jaw looked at by the doctors on the sideline, and was later subbed out, then yes, he deserved a week.

Robbie Gray got straight back up and played the game out.

If Dawson got off for basically hitting Selwood in the head with his hip last week, then Chapman should get off this.
Click to expand...
Dawson didn't have an alternative way of contesting the ball. Chappy was late and could have tackled. These are important factors and the injury isn't the only thing considered. Injury potential is and Chappy is lucky that Gray doesn't have a glass jaw.
 
Purple Suit said:
Dawson didn't have an alternative way of contesting the ball. Chappy was late and could have tackled. These are important factors and the injury isn't the only thing considered. Injury potential is and Chappy is lucky that Gray doesn't have a glass jaw.
Click to expand...

Chapman hit Gray on his shoulder, not his head. Gray just threw his head back looking for a free, just like he dived in front of goal when he felt contact to his back by Josh Hunt earlier in the game.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

winty said:
Chapman hit Gray on his shoulder, not his head. Gray just threw his head back looking for a free, just like he dived in front of goal when he felt contact to his back by Josh Hunt earlier in the game.
Click to expand...
Ha ha. You believe he hit him on the shoulder. Flush on the jaw. I'll go steal a photo from another thread and bring it back.
 
winty said:
Chapman hit Gray on his shoulder, not his head. Gray just threw his head back looking for a free, just like he dived in front of goal when he felt contact to his back by Josh Hunt earlier in the game.
Click to expand...
That was my take on the incident 100%. No head contact
 
Purple Suit said:
Ha ha. You believe he hit him on the shoulder. Flush on the jaw. I'll go steal a photo from another thread and bring it back.
Click to expand...

Oh goody, a photo. Can't wait.

I've seen photos that supposedly prove the existence of Bigfoot and the Loch Ness Monster too. Must be true if there's photos of them!
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

winty said:
Oh goody, a photo. Can't wait.

I've seen photos that supposedly prove the existence of Bigfoot and the Loch Ness Monster too. Must be true if there's photos of them!
Click to expand...

Here you go.

Looks like a head hit to me.

Only diff between the two is chaps feet are off the ground.

72SuXI8.jpg


But who knows who the wheel will spin
 
Purple Suit said:
Ha ha. You believe he hit him on the shoulder. Flush on the jaw. I'll go steal a photo from another thread and bring it back.
Click to expand...

Knowing my old pal winty he'll accuse me of doctoring that photo.
 
I'll agree the photo does seem to suggest there was contact to the head, although still frame shots can distort things somewhat.

Chapman should argue he was trying to smother though. Worked for Dawson.
 
winty said:
Oh goody, a photo. Can't wait.

I've seen photos that supposedly prove the existence of Bigfoot and the Loch Ness Monster too. Must be true if there's photos of them!
Click to expand...

What do you think of the photo?
 
Purple Suit said:
Stealing the photo off deathevocation

Does Sttew and winty still think it wasn't head high?
View attachment 30080
Click to expand...
Firstly, Sttew and Winty is plural, so do rather than does.

Secondly has the game come to this - you have to find one still image to support your case? If you watch the footage without reducing it to a still image at a time there is no discernible head contact. Robbie Gray acts it up throwing his head back. Gets the free and that's the end of the matter as far as he is concerned
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

Chadwiko
    • Like
MRP / Trib. Dayne Zorko low blow - Gone?
Replies
23
Views
650
p4p1
p4p1
C
    • Like
Graham gone for 4
Replies
24
Views
918
Rich01
R
Chadwiko
    • Like
    • Sad
Patrick Dangerfield 'dangerous tackle' - gone or safe?
8 9 10 11 12
Replies
295
Views
13K
myblueroan
myblueroan

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom