ziebell vs Vlastuin vs Prestia vs Selwood

[thetradesman]

Who will have the better career?

 

[timtamWB]

I reckon Ziebell will. He just has all the tools and he looks like he's going to explode soon.

 

[Joshen]

Pretty hard to judge given they are all in different stages of their career.

 

[UmpiringFooty]

Voted for Jack Ziebell.
Think that he's going to be way better than what Scott Selwood will be. Vlastuin is a talent as is Prestia. Scott Selwood is a bit of a ducker. He needs to play proper footy rather than look for free kicks.
Jack Ziebell is all class. The only fault with him is that he needs to stop getting rubbed out.

 

[themilkman888]

Voted for Jack Ziebell.
Think that he's going to be way better than what Scott Selwood will be. Vlastuin is a talent as is Prestia. Scott Selwood is a bit of a ducker. He needs to play proper footy rather than look for free kicks.
Jack Ziebell is all class. The only fault with him is that he needs to stop getting rubbed out.

I suggest you watch more of Scott Selwood play.

 

[Small Moves]

Voted for Jack Ziebell.
Think that he's going to be way better than what Scott Selwood will be. Vlastuin is a talent as is Prestia. Scott Selwood is a bit of a ducker. He needs to play proper footy rather than look for free kicks.
Jack Ziebell is all class. The only fault with him is that he needs to stop getting rubbed out.

Blue and white glasses..

 

[tazaa]

You got the wrong Selwood.

Strange selection of players.
Vlaustin is going to be a gun off halfback.
Prestia is a clearance and ball winning machine.
Selwood finds the ball and tackles like a maniac.

I would have put Cunnington in OP instead of Ziebell.
As unbiased as possible Ziebell is a matchwinner and the only one who can kick goals in that group. In terms of influence on games it is unfair.

 

[Dazb86]

Probably Ziebell. Definitely Ziebell if he can get his fitness right.

Think Vlastuin is a little overrated out of that group. Will be a good player but probably didn't have the year a few people are making out he had on bigfooty. Then again he's a first year player so who the **** knows. Prestia didn't look too good in his first year.

 

[Liam Boy]

Probably Ziebell. Definitely Ziebell if he can get his fitness right.

Think Vlastuin is a little overrated out of that group. Will be a good player but probably didn't have the year a few people are making out he had on bigfooty. Then again he's a first year player so who the **** knows. Prestia didn't look too good in his first year.

Ziebell apparently has some kind of condition that prevents him from playing full games (not sure if it's true but I think I heard it somewhere??? Take it with a grain of salt.) Anyway, myself and a lot of other North supporters on this board have been really impressed that despite this limitation he's able to have such a huge impact on games.

Honestly, it's hard for me to look past Jacky Z. Love the bloke.

 

[juss]

You can't put Vlastuin in this he's only just played his first year. Really odd poll with the different levels of development these guys are at.

 

[RobbyRoy]

I like them all a lot:

Ziebell - Probably the safe pick considering we've seen a lot more out of him than the rest. Seems to have it all; courage, skill, toughness, leadership, clutch, good overhead and on the ground and a good finisher.

Selwood - A bit of an old fashioned footballer. Doesn't have much style and at times can make it look very ugly, but he gets it done. I would be happy to have him in the guts of my team, and even leading them.

Prestia - Small, but can obviously find the ball and usually looks clean. I don't think he'll ever set the world on fire, but he'll play very good football for a long time.

Vlastuin - My personal favourite. I kept forgetting it was his first year and he was only a teenager when watching him this year. So cool and calm, was born to be doing what he's doing. Might just turn out to be a very serviceable and consistent performer, but I think he's got the tools to be more.

 

[NUFC Tiger]

Funny poll in terms of the players used - went for Vlastuin though due to my bias. All very handy players though who should have good careers injury permitting.

 

[Turmoil]

Voted Ziebell, but more than happy with Vlastuin.

You got the wrong Selwood.

Strange selection of players.
Vlaustin is going to be a gun off halfback.
Prestia is a clearance and ball winning machine.
Selwood finds the ball and tackles like a maniac.

I would have put Cunnington in OP instead of Ziebell.
As unbiased as possible Ziebell is a matchwinner and the only one who can kick goals in that group. In terms of influence on games it is unfair.

Vlastuin kicked 9 goals this season in 18 games. It wasnt till Ziebell's 4th season that he could match that

 

[tazaa]

Voted Ziebell, but more than happy with Vlastuin.




Vlastuin kicked 9 goals this season in 18 games. It wasnt till Ziebell's 4th season that he could match that

No doubt NVs a ripper. JZ did break his leg in his first 2 years tho.

 

[lmach]

By the end of their careers;

Prestia > Selwood > Ziebell > Vlastuin

 

[Red Black and Blue]

Prestia> Ziebell > Vlaustin > Selwood

 

[timtamWB]

Ziebell > Prestia > Vlastuin > Selwood

 

[tazaa]

By the end of their careers;

Prestia > Selwood > Ziebell > Vlastuin

lol do you love anything North related?
Even your coach?

 

[a_fighting_fury]

Flosstone, but I'm extremely bias.

 

[00Stinger]

Prestia easily

 

[Upgrayedd]

Prestia

 

[Big Tom 2013]

Voted Ziebell only because ive seen more of him, but very difficult one to pick-different players at different stages.

 

[lmach]

lol do you love anything North related?
Even your coach?

Because I don't rate Ziebell as high as Prestia and Selwood? I'll get you some tissues, buddy.

 

[Bulldog1954]

Would without a doubt take Prestia. All are good but would expect him to be the best comfortably

 

[Tragic sainter]

Prestia, blokes an absolute jet and is most likely to elevate himself to elite status.