Player X vs Y.

[Cruyff14]

CR7 has a ridiculous record with RM though, and that's just as a winger.

IMO CR7 is better in clubs but R9 was better for his country.

Have you seen Ronaldo's record at PSV, Barca and Inter?

 

[HolyRioli]

Reckon they could captain a defence who has kept 7 cleansheets in 10 EPL games?

Didn't know Smalling had done that

 

[ADL9798]

Robson > Souness (better comparison would be Keane or Souness)
Dalglish > Rush
Barnes > Beckham
RVP > RVN
Pires > Ljungberg
Zola > Di Canio
Viduka > Hasselbank
Cech > Van der Sar
Schmeichel > Seaman
CR7 > R9
Makelele > Busquets
Gerrard > Vieira easily
Dawson > Smalling
Messi > Maradona
Toure > Vidal
Di Maria > Lavezzi

 

[Sub_Zero]

Baines

Arteta

Koscielny

______

Fabio Coentroa vs Marcelo

LOL

 

[typeclub]

R9 was a striker and never had a better goal scoring rate in his career than CR7.

 

[jd2010]

Ginola vs Di Canio

 

[Cruyff14]

Robson > Souness (better comparison would be Keane or Souness)
Dalglish > Rush
Barnes > Beckham
RVP > RVN
Pires > Ljungberg
Zola > Di Canio
Viduka > Hasselbank
Cech > Van der Sar
Schmeichel > Seaman
CR7 > R9
Makelele > Busquets
Gerrard > Vieira easily
Dawson > Smalling
Messi > Maradona
Toure > Vidal
Di Maria > Lavezzi

Easily? Turn it up.

 

[jd2010]

Think its safe to say supporters views of their own players in thread is rather pointless when up against someone from another club

 

[Cruyff14]

And I'm not sure if Messi is better than Diego, yet.

Diego carried Napoli by himself, who knows if Messi could do that in Serie A at that time.

 

[Butts_JZZ30]

Rooney v RVP

Lineker v Owen

Lee Bowyer v Joey Barton

Gareth Southgate v Jonathon Woodgate

Peter Beardsley v David Platt v Mark Hughes v Ian Rush

 

[Stratton_Gun]

Me vs Ashley Young

 

[jod23]

CR7 (as a CF) or R9 (prime).

Prime Torres or Current Suarez?

Gerrard or Vieira?

Diego Maradona v Lionel Messi.

I'd go R9 over CR7. Only just though. CR's record at Real Madrid is quite simply stunning.

Prime Torres was just insane. Really tough one. Gotta go Suarez, just for his ability to bring others into the game and he certainly always puts in a shift. Makes you wonder though as prime Torres was out of this world, so just how good is Suarez!

Gerrard, scores more goals.

Messi. Just has to be. Messi is the best footballer of all time IMO.

 

[Cruyff14]

RvP.

Lineker.

Rush.

 

[Big Jim 11]

Rooney v RVP

Linecker v Owen

Lee Bowyer v Joey Barton

Gareth Southgate v Jonathon Woodgate

Peter Beardsley v David Platt v Mark Hughes v Ian Rush

rvp

linekar

bowyer

woodgate

too hard with 4, probably rush though

_______

Henderson vs Mikel

 

[jd2010]

Mikel

 

[jod23]

Rooney v RVP

Lineker v Owen

Lee Bowyer v Joey Barton

Gareth Southgate v Jonathon Woodgate

Peter Beardsley v David Platt v Mark Hughes v Ian Rush

RVP > Rooney - RVP just oozes class. He was better in an Arsenal shirt though.

Owen > Lineker

Bowyer > Barton - not sure what Barton actually brings to a side, other than red cards.

Woodgate > Southgate

Rush > Hughes > Beardsley > Platt - Rush was ridic.

 

[chef]

Me vs Ashley Young

Ashley Young.

 

[Cruyff14]

Not sure how Owen can be justified over Lineker for an entire career.

 

[moomba]

Henderson vs Mikel

Is playing with 10 men an option?

 

[Butts_JZZ30]

Lineker scored bags at every club he went to, including Barcelona and at international level. Underated in the scheme of things, can't see how Owen can be deemed to be better.

 

[Cooldude]

Lineker owns Owen, hard, Owen's a little s**tstain who had like 4 good years before he got more interested in making cash and horses and calling other people peasants

 

[Magma]

yeah but lineker was never a stokie legend

varane or ramos

 

[Butts_JZZ30]

Matt Le Tissier v Fabregas

 

[Big Jim 11]

Varane

Ramires vs Paulinho

 

[Butts_JZZ30]

Roberto Baggio v Bergkamp (good one!)