List Mgmt. 2014 Draft Trade FA Megathread

[goodie23]

Anyone interested in vickery and richmonds third for armo and our second? Was suggested on the Richmond board.

I'm late to the party, was at work all day.



Wouldn't do it as a straight swap, wouldn't do it if it was their second and our third. Seriously do not rate Vickery.

 

[Baughb]

I'm late to the party, was at work all day.



Wouldn't do it as a straight swap, wouldn't do it if it was their second and our third. Seriously do not rate Vickery.

What kind of an excuse is that?

...I may get fired this offseason.

 

[goodie23]

What kind of an excuse is that?

...I may get fired this offseason.

BigFooty is blocked on the network, phone credit is low and principal/parents/children would frown on it anyway...

 

[Superduperouzel]

AFL should allow picks in PSD to be traded as well.

No reason why not.

and a mid season draft. Its quite entertaining.

 

[RobbieMuir]

I wonder if anyone will understand this reference...

Woops! I thought it was Kevin Bartlett.

 

[Rors]

Only 105 posts to go to break last years trade thread total....
















We need to get a life

 

[sdswonit]

Hi All. As you can see, I have been a member for a while, but don't post a lot. I'm getting sick of all the negative comments on Saintsational, so came here for a look.
Now that we've missed out on JOR, should the Saints try to get Biggs chucked in with Membrey or look at say Lyons from the Crows instead?

 

[bird_man]

Hi All. As you can see, I have been a member for a while, but don't post a lot. I'm getting sick of all the negative comments on Saintsational, so came here for a look.
Now that we've missed out on JOR, should the Saints try to get Biggs chucked in with Membrey or look at say Lyons from the Crows instead?

I think they are both worth looking at but wouldn't want to give to too much for them.

 

[sammm]

I'm sick of Hawthorn. If they get JOR I will be even more sick of them.

Just on 3AW JOK preferred club is hawthorn. And Why not. Any player would want to play for the Hawks as they have back to back flags.

Can we ban them from trade week?

 

[sdswonit]

I think they are both worth looking at but wouldn't want to give to too much for them.

What about our 3rd round pick, 41? to Sydney for Membrey & Biggs?

 

[Sir Skid]

Hi All. As you can see, I have been a member for a while, but don't post a lot. I'm getting sick of all the negative comments on Saintsational, so came here for a look.
Now that we've missed out on JOR, should the Saints try to get Biggs chucked in with Membrey or look at say Lyons from the Crows instead?

Welcome sdswonit
You'll find we're a lot more constructive here.
Good to see more BF Saints newbies.

 

[sauce_head]

Hi All. As you can see, I have been a member for a while, but don't post a lot. I'm getting sick of all the negative comments on Saintsational, so came here for a look.
Now that we've missed out on JOR, should the Saints try to get Biggs chucked in with Membrey or look at say Lyons from the Crows instead?

Welcome. It's crazy season but it should still be okay here.

 

[hayes]

Hi All. As you can see, I have been a member for a while, but don't post a lot. I'm getting sick of all the negative comments on Saintsational, so came here for a look.
Now that we've missed out on JOR, should the Saints try to get Biggs chucked in with Membrey or look at say Lyons from the Crows instead?

First of all mate forget that place, much better here. Secondly I think just because we missed out on someone doesn't mean we should go and get someone else. JOR is a former pick 2 and there aren't many of those on the move. Stick to the draft.

 

[Joffaboy]

Only 105 posts to go to break last years trade thread total.

We need to get a life

You do, I'm never on here

 

[Mindtraveller]

Isn't Biggs a rookie? Maybe 3rd rd upgrade or Perri's?

 

[Rors]

Hi All. As you can see, I have been a member for a while, but don't post a lot. I'm getting sick of all the negative comments on Saintsational, so came here for a look.
Now that we've missed out on JOR, should the Saints try to get Biggs chucked in with Membrey or look at say Lyons from the Crows instead?

Like this post. I've liked Biggs & Membrey all year & brought up their names even a few months ago

Now that the Swans are getting pick 38 for Malceski compo, they may take 41 for both Membrey & Biggs, then trade 38 & 41 down to a better pick or another player

 

[Augustine]

Can't see that happening. What do you think is a fair deal from Collingwood?

I'm not sure. He had a very good season, 2nd in B&F. But at the same time he's out of contract and we really aren't in a position to bargain with them so I doubt we'll get anything worthwhile for him. I sort of want to go to the pre-season draft out of spite haha. I can't see any reason why he should be upset if he has to go to St Kilda rather than collingwood though, they're both two clubs in rebuild after all.

 

[Superduperouzel]

First of all mate forget that place, much better here. Secondly I think just because we missed out on someone doesn't mean we should go and get someone else. JOR is a former pick 2 and there aren't many of those on the move. Stick to the draft.

Still a long way to go in trade week. No one fires all their shots early. I think we might get an unexpected winner later in the week.
That´s purely a gut feeling only. I hope we get Membrey he´s that 3rd tall we´ve been hoping Lee or Markworth would be. I like both of them but injuries are making it hard for them to forge an AFL career. We need depth, options, flexibility in our team. No one has seen much of Membrey due to the stars in front of him at Sydney. He called be a gun he could be a spud. A 3rd round pick is worth a punt.

 

[Rors]

You do, I'm never on here

LOL....

 

[hayes]

Like this post. I've liked Biggs & Membrey all year & brought up their names even a few months ago

Now that the Swans are getting pick 38 for Malceski compo, they may take 41 for both Membrey & Biggs, then trade 38 & 41 down to a better pick or another player

38 and 41? I'm going to do a Barrells and say what about my man Rainbow?? Waaahhhh. Did I do it right?

 

[SaintLex]

I'm not sure. He had a very good season, 2nd in B&F. But at the same time he's out of contract and we really aren't in a position to bargain with them so I doubt we'll get anything worthwhile for him. I sort of want to go to the pre-season draft out of spite haha. I can't see any reason why he should be upset if he has to go to St Kilda rather than collingwood though, they're both two clubs in rebuild after all.

He's been offered a pretty good deal at Collingwood though. Who says we want to match it?

 

[Mowman]

Who would we prefer ?
Membery.
O' Shea.
Jaschke.

 

[Augustine]

He's been offered a pretty good deal at Collingwood though. Who says we want to match it?

I was being a bit tounge in cheek. But I'm sure if he did somehow in some extraordinary series events slip down to you, you'd offer him something reasonably decent. He's a good player and you'd want to keep him around.

 

[sdswonit]

Please call me Bunk_Moreland on here - oh wait, where am I??
Much better crowd over here and you get the news a lot quicker.

Also no P66 to knock every single thing suggested.

I haven't seen either Mewbrey or Biggs play so cant comment.

I only know that the Saints stuffed up because we could have had Mowbrey two years ago.

Cant remember who posted that. Anyone remember?

Yeh, I don't understand how P66 can call himself a supporter! He baggs pretty much everything & everyone!

 

[sdswonit]

Who would we prefer ?
Membery.
O' Shea.
Jaschke.

Membrey! He wants to come to us!