Competitions St Kilda All Time Draft

Should current players be picked?

  • Yes

    Votes: 18 90.0%
  • No

    Votes: 2 10.0%

  • Total voters
    20
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

TN25

Premiership Player
Suspended
Sep 8, 2014
3,349
1,737
Melbourne
AFL Club
St Kilda
Other Teams
Scorchers, Glory, Southampton
I have decided to hold an all time draft with just St Kilda players. There will be 8 participants, register your interest below. The draft order will be randomized and the draft will be held in a snake format (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 8, 7, 6 etc.). There will not be a time limit, but try to be online reasonably often to check if its your pick. The teams will be judged on this board.

Participants
1. goodie23
2. 12Chill
3. felsty
4. saintkildaman
5. Armitage2Riewoldt
6. Defacto
7. Uncle Barrels
8. Half Back Pocket
 
Last edited:
  • Thread starter
  • Banned
  • #2
Draft

1. goodie23 - Tony Lockett
2. Defacto - Nick Riewoldt
3. Daddy_Barrels - Ian Stewart
4. Armitage2Riewoldt - Darrel Baldock
5. 12Chill - Robert Harvey
6. Half Back Pocket - Stewart Loewe
7. felsty - Lenny Hayes
8. saintkildaman - Nathan Burke
9. saintkildaman - Nicky Winmar
10. felsty - Peter Everitt
11. Half Back Pocket - Bill Mohr
12. 12Chill - Fraser Gehrig
13. Armitage2Riewoldt - Verdun Howell
14. Daddy_Barrels - Barry Hall
15. Defacto - Trevor Barker
16. goodie23 - Dave McNamara
17. goodie23 - Carl Ditterich
18. Defacto - Stephen Milne
19. Daddy_Barrels - Brendon Goddard
20. Armitage2Riewoldt - Barry Breen
21. 12Chill - Ross Smith
22. Half Back Pocket - Kevin Neale
23. felsty - Justin Koschitzke
24. saintkildaman - Danny Frawley
25. saintkildaman - Sam Fisher
26. felsty - Nick Dal Santo
27. Half Back Pocket - Max Hudghton
28. 12Chill - Leigh Montagna
29. Armitage2Riewoldt - Luke Ball
30. Daddy_Barrels - Aaron Hamill
31. Defacto - Neil Roberts
32. goodie23 - Bob Murray
33. goodie23 - Lance Oswald
34. Defacto - Brian Sierakowoski
35. Daddy_Barrels - Colin Watson
36. Armitage2Riewoldt - Harold Bray
37. 12Chill - William Cubbins
38. Half Back Pocket - Ian Synman
39. felsty - Brian Gleeson
40. saintkildaman - Austin Jones
41. saintkildaman - Ben McEvoy
42. felsty - Gary Colling
43. Half Back Pocket - Greg Burns
44. 12Chill - Andrew Thompson
45. Armitage2Riewoldt - Jim Ross
46. Daddy_Barrels - Ian Cooper
47. Defacto - Michael Gardiner
48. goodie23 - Jason Blake
49. goodie23 - Daryl Griffiths
50. Defacto - Jason Heatley
51. Daddy_Barrels - Bill Stephenson
52. Armitage2Riewoldt - Wels Eicke
53. 12Chill - Alan Davis
54. Half Back Pocket - Alan Morrow
55. felsty - Geoff Cunningham
56. saintkildaman - Bill Young
57. saintkildaman - Steven Baker
58. felsty - Justin Peckett
59. Half Back Pocket - Jack Steven
60. 12Chill - David Grant
61. Armitage2Riewoldt - George Young
62. Daddy_Barrels - Matt Maguire
63. Defacto - Darryl Wakelin
64. goodie23 - Barry Lawrence
65. goodie23 - Roy Cazaly
66. Defacto - Adam Schneider
67. Daddy_Barrels - Lazar Vidovic
68. Armitage2Riewoldt - Joel Smith
69. 12Chill - Jeff Sarau
70. Half Back Pocket - Russell Greene
71. felsty - Keith Drinan
72. saintkildaman - Rex Hunt
73. saintkildaman - Alex Jesaulenko
74. felsty - Travis Payze
75. Half Back Pocket - Sam Loxton
76. 12Chill - Sean Dempster
77. Armitage2Riewoldt - Peter Bennett
78. Daddy_Barrels - Brian Mynott
79. Defacto - Gilbert McAdam
80. goodie23 - Dean Rice
81. goodie23 - David Armitage
82. Defacto - Brett Voss
83. Daddy_Barrels - Jack Davis
84. Armitage2Riewoldt - Xavier Clarke
85. 12Chill - Bruce Duperouzel
86. Half Back Pocket - Rod Owen
87. felsty - John Shelton
88. saintkildaman - Jason Gram
89. saintkildaman - Sam Gilbert
90. felsty - Stuart Trott
91. Half Back Pocket - Craig O'Brien
92. 12Chill - Jeff Dunne
93. Armitage2Riewoldt - Shane Wakelin
94. Daddy_Barrels - Harry Moyes
95. Defacto - Les Foote
96. goodie23 - Robbie Muir
97. goodie23 - Keith Rosewarne
98. Defacto - Glenn Elliott
99. Daddy_Barrels - Jim Guyatt
100. Armitage2Riewoldt - Fred Phillips
101. 12Chill - Robert Elphinstone
102. Half Back Pocket - Tim Pekin
103. felsty - Ernie Sellars
104. saintkildaman - Steven Sziller
105. saintkildaman - Farren Ray
106. felsty - Jim O'Dea
107. Half Back Pocket - Jack Billings
108. 12Chill - Vic Cumberland
109. Armitage2Riewoldt - Heath Black
110. Daddy_Barrels - Eric Guy
111. Defacto - Gary Sidebottom
112. goodie23 - Jack Newnes
113. goodie23 - Luke Beveridge
114. Defacto - Jeff Moran
115. Uncle Barrels - Vic Barwick
116. Armitage2Riewoldt - Harry Lever
117. 12Chill - Frank Coghlan
118. Half Back Pocket - Tony Brown
119. felsty - Harold Matthews
120. saintkildaman - Matt Lappin
121. saintkildaman - Luke Dunstan
122. felsty - Reg Garvin
123. Half Back Pocket - Dean Anderson
124. 12Chill - Val Perovic
125. Armitage2Riewoldt - Stephen Theodore
126. Daddy_Barrels - Rodger Head
127. Defacto - Allan Jeans
128. goodie23 - Jason Cripps
129. goodie23 - Russell Morris
130. Defacto - Alan Kiligrew
131. Daddy_Barrels - Jack McDonald
132. Armitage2Riewoldt - Luke Penny
133. 12Chill - Billy Schmidt
134. Half Back Pocket - Jamie Shanahan
135. felsty - Mark Scott
136. saintkildaman - Ahmed Saad
137. saintkildaman - Steven King
137. felsty - Col Williamson
139. Half Back Pocket - Michael Roberts
140. 12Chill - George Morrissey
141. Armitage2Riewoldt - Stephen Powell
142. Daddy_Barrels - Neil Besanko
143. Defacto - Angus Mason
144. goodie23 - John Stephens
145. goodie23 - Jarryn Geary
146. Defacto - Troy Schwarze
147. Daddy_Barrels - Barry Pascoe
148. Armitage2Riewoldt - Bruce Phillips
149. 12Chill - Barney Carr
150. Half Back Pocket - Rod Keogh
151. felsty - Ken Walker
152. saintkildaman - Aaron Fiora
153. saintkildaman - Brent Guerra
154. felsty - Gordon Dangerfield
155. Half Back Pocket - Matthew Young
156. 12Chill - Rod Galt
157. Armitage2Riewoldt - Kevin Roberts
158. Daddy_Barrels - Zac Dawson
159. Defacto - Jayson Daniels
160. goodie23 - Ross Oakley
161. goodie23 - Patrick McCartin
162. Defacto - Dale Kickett
163. Daddy_Barrels - Harold Comte
164. Armitage2Riewoldt - Wayne Judson
165. 12Chill - John McIntosh
166. Half Back Pocket - Paul Callery
167. felsty - Jack James
168. saintkildaman - Leigh Fisher
169. saintkildaman - Andrew McQualter
170. felsty - Phil Narkle
171. Half Back Pocket - Dean Matthews
172. 12Chill - Harold Davies
173. Armitage2Riewoldt - James Gwilt
174. Daddy_Barrels - Bob Flegg
175. Defacto - Craig Callahan
176. goodie23 - Charlie Baker



Team 1 (goodie23)
FB: Barry Lawrence / Bob Murray / Russell Morris
HB: Jason Cripps / Jason Blake / Jack Newnes
C: Dean Rice / Lance Oswald / Robbie Muir
HF: John Stephens / Dave McNamara / Luke Beveridge
FF: Keith Rosewarne / Tony Lockett / Roy Cazaly
R: Carl Ditterich / Daryl Griffiths / David Armitage
I/C: Jarryn Geary / Ross Oakley / Patrick McCartin / Charlie Baker

Team 2 (Defacto)
FB: Dale Kickett / Darryl Wakelin / Brian Sierakowski
HB: Trevor Barker / Neil Roberts / Jayson Daniels
C: Jeff Moran / Glenn Elliott / Les Foote
HF: Gilbert McAdam / Nick Riewoldt / Adam Schneider
FF: Stephen Milne / Jason Heatley / Gary Sidebottom
R: Michael Gardiner / Allan Jeans / Alan Kiligrew
I/C: Angus Mason / Troy Schwarze / Brett Voss / Craig Callahan

DB's Barbarians (Daddy_Barrels)
FB: Rodger Head / Zac Dawson / Jack Davis
HB: Jim Guyatt / Matt Maguire / Eric Guy
C: Brendon Goddard / Ian Stewart / Neil Besanko
HF: Aaron Hamill (c) / Barry Hall / Ian Cooper
FF: Brian Mynott / Bill Stephenson / Harry Moyes
R: Lazar Vidovic / Vic Barwick / Colin Watson
I/C: Jack McDonald / Barry Pascoe / Harold Comte / Bob Flegg

A2R's Superstars (Armitage2Riewoldt)
FB: Harry Lever / Verdun Howell / Luke Penny
HB: Shane Wakelin / Wels Eicke / Fred Phillips
C: Xavier Clarke / Harold Bray / Heath Black
HF: Barry Breen / Darrel Baldock / Peter Bennett
FF: Stephen Theodore / George Young / Kevin Roberts
R: Jim Ross / Luke Ball / Joel Smith
I/C: Bruce Phillips / Stephen Powell / Wayne Judson / James Gwilt

12Chill's Chargers (12Chill)
FB: Jeff Dunne / William Cubbins / Sean Dempster
HB: David Grant / Val Perovic / Robert Elphinstone
C: Leigh Montagna / Andrew Thompson / Frank Coghlan
HF: Allan Davis / Rod Galt / Bruce Duperouzel
FF: George Morrissey / Fraser Gehrig / John McIntosh
R: Jeff Sarau / Robert Harvey / Ross Smith (c)
I/C: Barney Carr / Billy Schmidt / Vic Cumberland / Harold Davies

Team 6 (Half Back Pocket)
FB: Tim Pekin / Max Hudghton / Jamie Shanahan
HB: Dean Anderson / Ian Synman / Michael Roberts
C: Russell Greene / Greg Burns / Tony Brown
HF: Craig O'Brien / Stewart Loewe/ Rod Owen
FF: Sam Loxton / Bill Mohr / Jack Billings
R: Kevin Neale / Alan Morrow / Jack Steven
I/C: Rod Keogh / Matthew Young / Paul Callery / Dean Matthews

Felsty's Fighters (felsty)
FB: Harold Matthews / Keith Drinan / Col Williamson
HB: Justin Peckett / Gary Colling / Jim O'Dea
C: Geoff Cunningham / Lenny Hayes / Stuart Trott
HF: John Shelton / Brian Gleeson / Travis Payze
FF: Justin Koschitzke / Mark Scott / Jack James
R: Peter Everitt / Nick Dal Santo / Reg Garvin
I/C: Ken Walker / Gordon Dangerfield / Ernie Sellars / Phil Narkle

Team 8 (saintkildaman)
FB: Steven Sziller/ Danny Frawley / Sam Gilbert
HB Farren Ray / Sam Fisher / Austin Jones
C: Nicky Winmar / Steven Baker / Jason Gram
HF: Matt Lappin / Rex Hunt / Alex Jesaulenko
FF: Steven King / Bill Young / Ahmed Saad
R: Ben McEvoy / Nathan Burke / Luke Dunstan
I/C: Brent Guerra / Aaron Fiora / Leigh Fisher / Andrew McQualter
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

This is gonna be a great thread to watch. I wonder if Jason Daniels goes inside the top 10! :)
 
I have decided to hold an all time draft with just St Kilda players. There will be 8 participants, register your interest below. The draft order will be randomized and the draft will be held in a snake format (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 8, 7, 6 etc.). There will not be a time limit, but try to be online reasonably often to check if its your pick. The teams will be judged on this board.

Participants
1. dewah07
2. 12Chill
3. felsty
4. saintkildaman
5. Armitage2Riewoldt
6. Defacto
7.
8.
Why not! In.

If you want to throw a cat amongst the pigeons, exclude current players...
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Try to make the teams 'playable' guys; i.e not 21 mids plus Plugger.

IMO will make it more fun.

If you're game, you can still have the 183cm Alan 'LBL' Morrow rucking.

*Lenny before Lenny...
 
Last edited:
Team Lists

Team 1
B:
HB:
C:
HF:
FF:
F:
I/C:

Team 2
B:
HB:
C:
HF:
FF:
F:
I/C:

Team 3
B:
HB:
C:
HF:
FF:
F:
I/C:

Team 4
B:
HB:
C:
HF:
FF:
F:
I/C:

Team 5
B:
HB:
C:
HF:
FF:
F:
I/C:

Team 6
B:
HB:
C:
HF:
FF:
F:
I/C:

Team 7
B:
HB:
C:
HF:
FF:
F:
I/C:

Team 8
B:
HB:
C:
HF:
FF:
F:
I/C:
Don't rate the ruck division champ?

:p
 
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colin_Watson_(footballer)

Don't forget our very first Brownlow medallist guys. Won with a whopping 9 votes... What a year!!

Sounds like he was a player though. sadly he only played 93 games, so 7 short of qualifying for great great great grandfather / son rule. :)
 
The draft order has been done on random.org

1. dewah07
2. Defacto
3. Uncle Barrels
4. Armitage2Riewoldt
5. 12Chill
6. Half Back Pocket
7. felsty
8. saintkildaman

dewah07 You can start the draft now
 
Last edited:
I'm takin Roo at Pick 6 if he's still available!!! Screw you and your authoritarianism Unc!
Just reckon it adds a degree of difficulty, nostalgia and fun. Happy to abide by the umpire's call if we get it.
 
Back
Top