2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[Flandersss]

Houli v Laird

Rory Laird.

Less likely to get a forward tag IMO.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Rory Laird.

Less likely to get a forward tag IMO.

Laird, Brodie, Danger, Sloane - too many Crows?

 

[Flandersss]

Laird, Brodie, Danger, Sloane - too many Crows?

Just a tad but not excessive.

Go with your gut is the best advice I can give lol.

 

[juddola]

Laird, Brodie, Danger, Sloane - too many Crows?

Personally wouldn't do it, but it isn't too bad.

 

[MightyDons4]

Houli v Laird

Had the exact same question.

Bit worried about the number of concussions Laird has had so I am leaning towards Houli

 

[SnappyHappy]

Had the exact same question.

Bit worried about the number of concussions Laird has had so I am leaning towards Houli

Brodie Smith is the one that's had the concussions, not Laird.

 

[scaryness]

Dahlhaus vs Edwards vs Deledio?

 

[AD03]

Dahlhaus vs Edwards vs Deledio?

Lids.

I suspect asked before but I can't find it.... simmo or bachar houli?

 

[DrummoSolo]

A slightly different one but one I'm sure a few supercoach players will have this week. Trade out Newnes, Saad, or Oxley?

 

[AD03]

A slightly different one but one I'm sure a few supercoach players will have this week. Trade out Newnes, Saad, or Oxley?

1. Newnes - in a protest against his year to date below par performance .. the goal should be for newnes to be in 0.0% of teams by years end

2. Oxley - tough run coming up for the pies which may impact his scoring. 2 great weeks but just remember it was only 3 weeks ago he was subbed out. Low breakeven is enticing though, if you will still upgrade later then id pick him over saad to hold onto this week.

3. Saad - dpp works beautifully with mckenzie.. ill be making smith my D6 and saad my floating cover between mid and back
. With his first responibility in his new role to cover rockys 0

 

[MightyMark]

1. Newnes - in a protest against his year to date below par performance .. the goal should be for newnes to be in 0.0% of teams by years end

2. Oxley - tough run coming up for the pies which may impact his scoring. 2 great weeks but just remember it was only 3 weeks ago he was subbed out. Low breakeven is enticing though, if you will still upgrade later then id pick him over saad to hold onto this week.

3. Saad - dpp works beautifully with mckenzie.. ill be making smith my D6 and saad my floating cover between mid and back
. With his first responibility in his new role to cover rockys 0

I have all 3, and will be offloading Oxley. Take from that what you will.

Newnes has a 5 round average of 92, i'll take that. his 53 was a poor performance but other than that he has been good of late.

 

[Jak!x]

Laird, Houli or Simpson?

 

[MightyMark]

Laird, Houli or Simpson?

Laird

 

[Hack_Watts]

S Edwards (fwd dpp) vs Sloane

 

[Jiska]

Simpson vs Hodge?

 

[MightyMark]

Simpson vs Hodge?

Simpson imo, but its purely opinion based on nothing.

 

[toxic]

Laird, Houli or Simpson?

Simpson

 

[toxic]

Simpson vs Hodge?

Kade

 

[toxic]

S Edwards (fwd dpp) vs Sloane

Sloane

 

[Big Fozza]

Simpson vs Hodge?

Hodge for me.

 

[Da Breust]

Simpson, Picken or Houli

Pick 1

 

[MightyDons4]

Brodie Smith is the one that's had the concussions, not Laird.

Laird has also had a concussion

 

[Jiska]

Simpson imo, but its purely opinion based on nothing.

Kade

Any reason why? Other than price?

 

[toxic]

Any reason why? Other than price?

He's coming good.
unlikely to be rested
barker may free him up as at least he can kick compared to 10 others in that team who can't

 

[SES SA]

Kennedy (Sydney) or Selwood or Watson?