Round 16 trades

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Why are people so prepared to give up Cripps, with Gibbs and Judd gone he is a key to CFC mids and will avg 90-100 which is good for mid 8. Far better to keep Cripps and upgrade your back 5&6 from pkayers like Saad, Lever and Oxley to Picken, Shaw or Mcdonald.

 

[Kadog]

8 trades & $2,900 left, what shall I do?

Option 1
Oxley > Malceski
Cripps > Rockliff

Option 2
Oxley > Maynard
Cripps > GAJ

Option 3
Dumont > Glenn/Maynard
Cripps > Rockliff


View attachment 153228

Option 2

Next week Lever > Eski

 

[Guardian Hawk]

May I get a little advice please? This is my team



9 trades and 90K
I have 2 main goals the next fortnight - get Ablett and upgrade Oxley. 2 decisions I am struggling with is:

Who to downgrade:
1. I can downgrade Cripps (to Daniel) and upgrade Sloane (to Ablett), leaving me 255K for upgrades next week (this leaves Steele as M9).
2. Downgrade Boston (to Daniel), upgrading Sloane/Cripps (to Ablett) leaving me no money but Cripps or Sloane at M9.

Note M9 will replace Jelwood this week

Who to bring in this week:
1. (Cripps to) Ablett (as the best player in the game and set to go big)
2. (Oxley to) Picken (as Oxley is due to be subbed, 3rd game since sub, Seedsman on bench)

Note I will get the other the following week.

How should I go about it please??

 

[Kadog]

You can 1 up 1 down Saad/CEY later.

Btw, you only listed 7 mids. Who's m8?

 

[Hairy Lager]

Why are people so prepared to give up Cripps, with Gibbs and Judd gone he is a key to CFC mids and will avg 90-100 which is good for mid 8. Far better to keep Cripps and upgrade your back 5&6 from pkayers like Saad, Lever and Oxley to Picken, Shaw or Mcdonald.

Cripps to GAJ sounds much better than Saad to Picken. A proven performer to a top 5 defender player group that has been a crap shot at best.

 

[Kadog]

Why are people so prepared to give up Cripps, with Gibbs and Judd gone he is a key to CFC mids and will avg 90-100 which is good for mid 8. Far better to keep Cripps and upgrade your back 5&6 from pkayers like Saad, Lever and Oxley to Picken, Shaw or Mcdonald.

It think it's a case of rooki fatigue setting in carrying a heavy workload. Kids a beast and should continue around 100avg but business end of SC season calls for a bigger output. You can't pass on likes of Rocky Sidey for similar $$ and a 115avg for remainder of season.

 

[Hairy Lager]

May I get a little advice please? This is my team
View attachment 153229
View attachment 153230

9 trades and 90K
I have 2 main goals the next fortnight - get Ablett and upgrade Oxley. 2 decisions I am struggling with is:

Who to downgrade:
1. I can downgrade Cripps (to Daniel) and upgrade Sloane (to Ablett), leaving me 255K for upgrades next week (this leaves Steele as M9).
2. Downgrade Boston (to Daniel), upgrading Sloane/Cripps (to Ablett) leaving me no money but Cripps or Sloane at M9.

Note M9 will replace Jelwood this week

Who to bring in this week:
1. Ablett (as the best player in the game and set to go big)
2. Picken (as Oxley is due to be subbed, 3rd game since sub, Seedsman on bench)

Note I will get the other the following week.

How should I go about it please??

Sloane/Boston to GAJ/Glenn

 

[leng jai]

You can 1 up 1 down Saad/CEY later.

Btw, you only listed 7 mids. Who's m8?

Big Wines. Probably don't want to be downgrading anyone from this point with only 4 trades left.

 

[Guardian Hawk]

Worked out the variables...

Am I better having (for this week only)...

Ablett & Oxley (with Ox sub risk)
or
Cripps and Picken

 

[Guardian Hawk]

Sloane/Boston to GAJ/Glenn

Thanks mate, although bringing in Daniel is better than Glenn right (using Steele's DPP)?

 

[Jiska]

Your plan allows me to get GAJ and Hodge NOW. I like it.

Like Kadog said, YOLO. Goldy and Nic Nat playing every game is not out of the question.

Tough choices. I'm gonna have to sleep on this.

Other option is Yeo with the MID/DEF swing, 65k cheaper which leaves more cash for your later upgrade, but Hodge probably a better option.

Option 2

Next week Lever > Eski

Eski??

 

[Kadog]

Big Wines. Probably don't want to be downgrading anyone from this point with only 4 trades left.

I would. You got $700k+ to get another premo in.

 

[Kadog]

Other option is Yeo with the MID/DEF swing, 65k cheaper which leaves more cash for your later upgrade, but Hodge probably a better option.


Eski??

Yep.

 

[Hairy Lager]

Thanks mate, although bringing in Daniel is better than Glenn right (using Steele's DPP)?

Glenn is a mid ready to jump 70k this week that may average 60-70 points, Daniel is a midget forward playing
amongst men. You have plenty of trades left to get Steele back into the mids.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Worked out the variables...

Am I better having (for this week only)...

Ablett & Oxley (with Ox sub risk)
or
Cripps and Picken

Ablett 120 + Oxley 80

V
Cripps 90 + Picken 100

Much of muchness IMO.

 

[The_Steadier]

and will avg 90-100 which is good for mid 8.

No it's not.
My SC year is going bad enough as it is.
If my 8th mid is averaging 90 by the end of the year, I may as well go and play tiddlywinks.
Because I suck at supercoach.

 

[Hairy Lager]

Ablett 120 + Oxley 80

V
Cripps 90 + Picken 100

Much of muchness IMO.

Ablett's lowest base 120/ highest 180 and Ox sub 40/highest 120, 160 or 300
Cripps 100 and Picken 100, 200
HHhhmmm....

 

[TyroneVickery29]

Ok which rookie should I trade in...
Glenn

Maynard (covers a donut, but it isn't really important as I am going for league wins and playing against a spud this week)

Daniel (allows me to put Steele into the mids for forward cover)

 

[j0rdy1]

Pittard > Hodge
Krak > Maynard

Leaves me with 3 trades and 80k so will hold off till league finals and luxuy upgrade one of Murphy/Wines/Thompson/Treloar as long as I don't get injuries.

 

[gothedons]

should i burn a trade on Selwood to Rockliff?


Would leave me with 4 trades left to cover for any issues/injuries YTG

 

[psydoge]

Boston > Daniel (via Steele)
Meaning I can upgrade Danyle Pearce (lol)
Can't get Deledio, he's too expensive. I got 2 options

Zorko vs Higgins

What do you guys think?

 

[Spudwick]

8 trades & $2,900 left, what shall I do?

Option 1
Oxley > Malceski
Cripps > Rockliff

Option 2
Oxley > Maynard
Cripps > GAJ

Option 3
Dumont > Glenn/Maynard
Cripps > Rockliff


View attachment 153228

Id go with option 2, gets you Gaj and also opens up a rookie for the d/m link which may come in handy for future trades

 

[Ingy]

Saad > Malceski

Broomhead > GAJ.

Funnily enough, I traded out this same pair of players in Round 3 for 1.3 million. Getting them back in for a mill.

Shaw Murphy Docherty Smith Malceski Oxley | Hamling Pearce

Fyfe Pendlebury Dangerfield Parker Wines Sidebottom Rockliff Ablett | Griffen Heeney Lambert

Blicavs Maric | Cox

Martin Gray Swan Wingard Deledio Adams | Steele Dale

And one trade

 

[Figster]

Only 3 trades left and 180k in the bank. Would love GAJ but would either need to flick Ebert or Buddy (1 trade) or burn 2 with McKernan to Downie and Krak to GAJ. The second option works well however with injuries and suspensions would be walking on a tightrope. The other option is forget GAJ and do no trades which seems?

 

[SC fish]

Only 3 trades left and 180k in the bank. Would love GAJ but would either need to flick Ebert or Buddy (1 trade) or burn 2 with McKernan to Downie and Krak to GAJ. The second option works well however with injuries and suspensions would be walking on a tightrope. The other option is forget GAJ and do no trades which seems?

Yeah I'm leaning towards Rockliff rather than Gazz. Will save me a trade and some $$, both of which are in short supply...